Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD2 → Feedback comment stats → richard
Feedback comments for LD2
richard's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | richard's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hitsuji: Shears Of Fury | Nice graphics! Nice gameplay, except that I seemed to get stuck on walls sometimes. Couldn't figure how to get to part of the second level too, but that might just be me being dumb :) <br/> <br/> Can't get hurt by stuff either, as far as I can tell :( <br/> <br/> No construction in the gameplay :( <br/> <br/> Sounds were pretty cool too :) <br/> <br/> JM: And yes, there might be construction workers, but they're merely cosmetic. No actual construction gameplay, which was the point. <br/> | ||
| The Destruction of The Sheep | Some of the levels were obvious, but then this was a 48h competition :) <br/> Excellent stuff! | ||
| Sheep Town | Had no idea what I was doing - you didn't include the readme in the source dist. Got the windows dist, and was ok from then. <br/> <br/> Had to rate it down one on the technical 'cos some of the dialogs a) where very hard to read (font too small and text squished together) and b) there was no "close dialog" button :) <br/> <br/> Full points for construction, minus on on destruction 'cos "death" is a bit of a metaphorical game - and destructing buildings didn't make any sense in the game (never had an occasion when I'd want to). <br/> | ||
| SheepCom | Points for following the theme, but there didn't seem to be much game in there. | ||
| BallerSchaf - Sheep of Death | Repetive gameplay - the timer and combo counters didn't seem to do anything. There was certainly no progression. The graphics were nice, but there seemed to be errors in lining them all up. Also, the terrain didn't appear to do anything, certainly not to the tank anyway. No construction. <br/> Nice intro though. <br/> | ||
| World Domination: Sheep vs Wolves | Has promise, too bad you had to spend valuable time doing other things. | ||
| Sheep Attack | This game desperately needs some player-guidance aids. Such huge spaces, and a time limit, means I spent many attempts just trying to find flock. Finally got the lone sheep there and nothing happened... <br/> Great music, no other sounds though :( <br/> No construction or destruction (apart from the flock, which I'll give you points for). <br/> Also far too easy to get a sheep stuck on a wall, and not be able to get them off again). <br/> | ||
| Sheep Strike | Couldn't quit!?! <br/> Collision detection was a bit off (sheep flying straight through chunks of blocks), as was the turret-pointing code (try aiming below a turret). <br/> Otherwise, an ok game - and it's not like I can knock people's collision detection routines, really ;) <br/> <br/> | ||
| chicken | The gun idea sounds neat, too bad it didn't do anything. <br/> <br/> No sheep, except in the intro ;) <br/> | ||
| Onslaught! Sounds intriguing, no? | No indication from the start where the onslaught is coming from. <br/> One sound sample that I could hear, but it was appropriate :) <br/> No sheep!?! <br/> Kinda bland graphics, though at least I could recognise my turrets. Not sure why the onslaughters had pointy bits... <br/> "You deserve a gold star young _man_"... are there no females in your universe? <br/> | ||
| Bleten | Not really sure what I was doing :) <br/> | ||
| Battlefield Sheep | Good effort. I liked the parallax fg/bg. The construction, destruction and sheep elements were all there. I had a ?club? but could only swing it randomly. Would've been nice to have been able to defend myself or the home base. <br/> | ||
| Sheeps R Us | Great game - all the theme's there, and it has a start, middle and end. <br/> It would've been nice to have earned money from the sheep, and perhaps for there to be more attackers (though shooting less often), to make it more frenetic. <br/> | ||
| The Sheep Wars | Nice game - bloody hard once those turrets start multiplying. There needs to be some game balance work - too many turrets :) <br/> | ||
| save the sheep | Cool game. Points off for being so tetris-alike, sorry ;) <br/> It was hard to figure where the blocks were going to drop too, which made the game really difficult. <br/> | ||
| SheepShifter | Excellently executed and great interpretation of the theme. If I had to pick, I'd say that the only let-down was the level design. In a puzzler game, the level design is everything (beyond the initial 32 hours of programming ;) <br/> <br/> You had some interesting puzzles in there, but level 5 for example got tedious once you were going for that last box. One bomb/rock would have served the same purpose as four. <br/> | ||
| Bleaters | Hard to figure out what I'm supposed to be doing - or what the sheep are doing for that matter. <br/> | ||
| Sheep & Crates | Wow, amazing artwork :) <br/> The physics were handled nicely, though they sucked the CPU out of my machine, and boxes could end up in an undamped bouncing game between two other boxes sometimes. <br/> There didn't seem to be any point to this game. No destruction either. <br/> | ||
| Mut Shbin | Cool game, great idea. No construction? <br/> | ||
| Final | I enjoyed the game, but would enjoy it more if the blocks weren't random. That made it too hard, IMO. Also, I seemed to just happen on a random set of angles that bounced the sheep in the correct direction for 100 saved. <br/> Cute, not really in place music :) <br/> | ||
| s a pult | Controls are kinda hard to use. There needs to be better feedback about when a sheep can be thrown and when building is ok. Great sound! Technically flawless implementation for what you were trying to achieve. Good interpretation of the themes too. Made me laugh :) <br/> | ||
| Sheep O Rama | Most of the graphics were pretty, but some of them weren't recognisable ;) <br/> I could pick up sheep, but not build barriers or shoot. Didn't see any wolves either. No building, so I feel I have to rate you down on the gameplay (but a 3 because you at least are supposed to have building). <br/> On a technical note, the timer seems to count down even before you start a game. | ||
| Sheepenstein | Cool graphics. Very slow on my computer though. Nice sounds too. Game very biased towards the player blowing the sheep up. Full marks for the theme. <br/> | ||
| Entry | The wolf made me laugh and laugh, definitely the high point of this game :) <br/> Technically, it crashed on exit. <br/> Full points for construction and destruction, though I guess it would have been nice for the fence to play some part in the game W.R.T the wolf :) <br/> Full points for your sheep too. <br/> Sadly the gameplay is lacking, there seeming nothing really to do (creating fence and destroying it are the only interaction I have, and that has no outcome on the game). <br/> Also, it never ends :) <br/> | ||
| Sammy The Sheep | Couldn't build, annoyed that I died when I got hit by one of the fast-moving eyeballs. Crashed on exit... <br/> | ||
| Sheep Massacre | Hurm, bullets appearing in odd places... <br/> Not a very exciting game, I'm afraid. No construction... | ||
| 48game valles | Presumably self-voting doesn't count. <br/> |