azmaeve 2012-04-23 14:44
I don't think I got the rules of your card game.
Also I don't get the relation with "Tiny World"
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD23 → "The best" CCG
By cantorfew
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coolness | 3 | 60 | ||
| Innovation | 523 | 2.73 | ||
| Audio | 759 | 1.17 | ||
| Humor | 767 | 1.46 | ||
| Mood | 858 | 1.47 | ||
| Overall | 880 | 1.85 | ||
| Fun | 893 | 1.38 | ||
| Graphics | 902 | 1.25 | ||
| Theme | 904 | 1.15 |
I don't think I got the rules of your card game.
Also I don't get the relation with "Tiny World"
when i ran "run.bat", it opened and closed straight away. will try reinstall python and will come back to this!
@azmaeve: If you are back to read this, could you elaborate a bit on what confused you in the rules? I agree that a lot was taken out so the theme is no longer obvious (and some of it is little rather than tiny).
@angrygeometry: Thanks for trying. If it still doesn't work, could you run "python.exe menu.py" from command line and see what it does (or change the properties of "run.bat" so it doesn't close the window after execution)? I can give you more specific instructions if you are willing to help me test.
Does not fit the theme. Plus, learn how to use py2exe to ship python apps to windows.
You'll get more ratings if you can figure out a way to package your game so it's easier to run.
This game is quite frustrating - I had positions 4 and 0 matching the goal, but turn after turn all my cards involved swapping either 4 or 0 with something else. I can't see any king of strategy to use to give myself better odds over this game - I seemed to be just randomly swapping cards around.
It is a creative card game, but it's difficult to relate it to theme. Besides that is hard to visualize opponents play without a gui. A simple GUI (even curses) would have made the game much more enjoyable. I see some future though.
Thanks for the game!
I think the rules aren't explained that well. 'card 1-4' doesn't tell much about what it does and such. You also didn't really incorporate the theme.
Was unable to download. Got a "Could not open user data."
Yay for card games!
Susan
This game felt really complicated for the interface. As it happens I got lucky and managed to win each of my first two matches in 2 plays, but if I had to strategize I think the setup would have gotten in the way. If you're looking for specific suggestions, I would get remove any mention of unimplemented features, not let you enter names for the cards, and get rid of the compound actions like "3-4 1:opp discard". I'm not even sure what the 1 means in that case.
On the third match it crashed with this Traceback:
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "menu.py", line 160, in <module>
odeck=[gendoublecard() for i in xrange(DECKSIZE)]
NameError: name 'gendoublecard' is not defined
PS: if you want to join a game competition where everyone uses python so everyone will be able to run your game, consider PyWeek! :)
I was unable to run it, and from the screenshot, it looks very arcane. I think simple graphics would have benefited this game greatly.
Also, I believe python can be packed into the deliverable exe, look into that for future projects.
Maybe look into PyGame?
Wouldn't run, sorry. But it looks good from the screenshot :D
I could understand the game as far as it was a text-based card game, and the goal, but once I was in the game I was lost.
Thank you everyone for your feedback and comments. I like to read them, both positive and negative.
For packaging, it seems that py2exe needs a Windows computer to start with (not impossible, but its hard for me to find one). However, given that it is text-based and I came across this:
http://shell.appspot.com/
I might look into hosting it server side (as a post-competition entry) if its not too difficult. (I might as well attempt to use the lack of a GUI to my advantage. :) )
Alternatively, I might also consider a post-competition PyGame entry. But in that case, I'm pretty sure I'll have problem distributing though.
@artefon: I think you are spot on and some of the confusion about the rules could be cleared up with a GUI. The current visual disconnect is making this game hard to grasp.
@SusanTheCat: That's odd. Maybe Fileden is being unreliable. I've uploaded it elsewhere just in case (the original entry).
@Cosmologicon: Having only swaps (or permutations) was the original design but then I ran into the problem cakemonitor stated above. Basically, you couldn't gain a significant advantage in that case. The secondary effects were added to give you a more permanent advantage.
That's quite some luck for winning in two rounds twice! I guess nobody got to level 3 before. Thanks for reporting the bug (its a function renaming error)!
I've done PyWeek before under a different pseudonym (and really like your work there, by the way). Unfortunately, I can't afford a weekend worth of time anymore, much less a week.
@cakemonitor: Some of the things you can do is to increase your hand size (by drawing), decrease your opponent's hand size (by making them discard) and increasing compromise. Also, originally I intended
@NAMKCOR: You guessed correctly and PyGame is what I intended to use for the GUI. I think even a GUI with no proper graphics would have helped. (Also see my comment about py2exe above.)
Couldn't get it to run :( windows xp here
I actually kind of wish this was a pdf of cards to print out instead of a program to run :)
Can't run it. Maybe I'm missing something but either by launching menu.py or run.bat, it close almost instantly.
There was an error when launching menu.py but didn't had time to read it as it closes directly.
Played the web version.
Interesting, though the interface is a bit austere, so it's a little difficult to follow the game, and creating a deck a bit tedious.
I like that you can customize your deck and collect cards!
Cool game. I like the gameplay, although it took a while to figure out that each card was switching both players' positions. The interface could be a little cleaner (i.e. more space between goal and hand and make it clearer when you're discarding. I threw away my winning card :(
Overall cool stuff. I think I want to play this with real cards.
Hard to understand