Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD52 → Feedback comment stats → coatline
Feedback comments for LD52
coatline's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | coatline's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 9 01:38:31 | Monster Harvester | ♥ 0 | I did the same with my game by mistake! @me when it's fixed :D | |
| Jan 9 01:54:48 | 16m 17s | Typefarmer | ♥ 1 | I played this twice around and got 2nd at the leaderboard (I'm sure that won't stand for too long)! Coming from someone who has played a lot of typing games, this far surpasses most if not all other typing games I have ever played, even the multiplayer ones. And to think that you made it in just 48 hours or so is crazy. Everything is greatly polished, I like the music and sounds, and I like how the scoring works. There is also lots of room for expanding on this to make it even cooler. Overall, I expected nothing less from a game that you made -- high quality, satisfying fun. Great job! |
| Jan 9 02:07:17 | 12m 29s | Agricultural Express | ♥ 1 | Don't forget to add your source code! It is a nice, relaxing, cozy game. It did have some trouble retaining my attention though, there isn't too much to do except wait for the crops to grow. I mean, theoretically, I could just buy beans and leave the game running to eventually retire! I will say, the environment is very nice and I like the overall esthetic. 😄 Good job! |
| Jan 14 21:16:40 | 139h 09m | Bubble Rancher | ♥ 0 | Fun game! The sounds are really awesome, and it just feels good to push bubbles with the precision of a caliper. I like how the bubble tension is displayed using a red tint and the animation is really nice to indicate the speed and bubbliness of the bubble. I really like the text before and after the levels to add a bit of personality to the game and oh the sound of the text typing is nice. Everything is overall just very polished as a whole! Also, thanks for the Pop room. Critiques: I think the difficulty curve could be a little softer. The pushers are a little frustrating to work since they keep rotating even when they are deactivated. Also, the level: "A Bubble Test" revealed an issue with how the required bubbles are detected and ended up not telling me that I couldn't complete the level. Bug in Bubbles.PNG |
| Jan 14 21:32:37 | 15m 57s | Crop Carnage | ♥ 1 | Really cute game! The music is impressive, pretty sure I recognize those as BeepBox tunes! The game unfortunately crashed every time I pressed tab to open the shop! 😄 I feel like that is unintentional but I still had a good time, corn was enough to sustain me! Great job! |
| Jan 14 21:39:14 | 6m 37s | Frozen Dragon | ♥ 2 | Very cozy game, I love the art style! The idea is unique and cute, I just love the idea that a dragon can cultivate a garden in the middle of an ice age! At first, I couldn't figure out how to melt the snow because I thought the hand item slot was fire! Anyways, I figured out that you needed carrots to melt the snow eventually. I really like the mood of this game, the music sets it on par along with the snow particles. Really solid entry. |
| Jan 14 21:43:59 | 4m 45s | 30 Days With Thiiis Guy | ♥ 0 | I like, style good, game interesting, not quite understand how fill water, plant grow, plant grow big, no news is good news, entry good. 🍅 |
| Jan 14 21:50:27 | 6m 28s | Petra Rabbit's Carrot Chase | ♥ 1 | Cute game with a really nice aesthetic to it! I really enjoyed the experience. The mood was on point with the music and "yummy" carrots! I love testing the volume. Good job! |
| Jan 16 20:37:08 | 46h 46m | The Rise of the Giant Beanstalk | ♥ 0 | Oh no! The game looks very fun and promising but slows down to unplayable after shooting the initial balloon! @me when it is fixed please! |
| Jan 16 20:43:19 | 6m 11s | Hermesh | ♥ 3 | Nice game! I like the chill yet moody music in the background. I dig the way the camera snaps to certain areas of the map, though I wish in certain places it were more flexible or the environment would adapt to the camera angle. The only other thing is that the background is a bit bland. I like your sprite work and really cool that you made a small Metroidvania in such little time! |
| Jan 16 20:58:50 | 15m 31s | Seed Gun | ♥ 1 | Game with potential! Congrats on making a working game in such a short time! I like: - The way the ants viscously attack plants until they are completely gone - Gameplay is overall engaging - The game idea has lots of potential (lots of room for expansion to full game) Wishes/Critiques: Note: Obviously this being a jam game, I don't expect any of these, just feedback. 😃 - It were more obvious where ants were coming from or when they were coming / some easier time viewing the whole map - The ant sound didn't loop in the menu - More feedback for literally every action (harvesting, which plants are queued for harvesting, killing ants, etc.) - New ant sound 😈 - Some of the ground tiles in the middle of the map are too light to tell how far apart they are - Music/more Sfx (would add much to the game feel overall) - A reason to continue playing (highscore system? (Unity has a very easy and quick way to add this using PlayerPrefs)) - New weapons (wave system maybe?) Anyways, I hope I'm not being overly critical, after all, it was made in 48 hours or less, but thanks for the game! |
| Jan 16 21:04:57 | 6m 07s | Kobold Fishing | ♥ 2 | Haha! I love it! Super cute, I love the mousedrawn art style and the little sounds the kobolds make! Why is it so satisfying? I think the main thing that makes this game fun is going around collecting tons of fish at once, feeling very powerful, like in Vampire Survivors. Therefore, I purpose that you get rid of the waiting for fish to respawn time and instead focus the gameplay on getting stronger and catching more and MORE FISH YIP YAP. . . (like in Vampire Survivors) Anyways, gg. |
| Jan 17 22:32:09 | 25h 27m | Harvest Space | ♥ 1 | This is really cool! It makes me want to make a multiplayer game next LD! Only problem is that there was no one playing 😢 but on the bright side, I won! |
| Jan 17 22:35:13 | 3m 04s | Organic Mouse | ♥ 3 | Is it impressive for a first game, plus being made in 48 hours? Certainly. Is it rough? Certainly. Is there a strange sense of charm that it radiates? Certainly. ✌️ |
| Jan 19 01:06:34 | 26h 31m | The Time Traveler's Garden | ♥ 3 | Super cute game! I really love the high contrast between the normal world and the time travel world, super awesome. The music is really cute and, again, very well done with the contrast. The planting is a little wonkey and I would like some more feedback (visual/audio) when you are hitting enemies and when you pick up their ingredients. This was actually quite enjoyable, great job! |
| Jan 19 01:16:27 | 9m 53s | Fast Aerial Harvesting | ♥ 1 | Cool prototype, I think it has a good amount of potential as a puzzle/Terra Forma - (https://pixelbyte.itch.io/terra-forma) kind of game. Adding a leaderboard, more unique blocks, events, heck even a level creator would definitely expand this concept. Honestly, I wasn't a big fan of the sounds, I think they were a little piercing. Maybe replacing them with more soft, even homemade mouth sounds would be an improvement. Either way, congrats on completing a game in such little time! |
