Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD45 → Feedback comment stats → Noshiz

Noshiz

Feedback comments for LD45

Noshiz's games and stats for all events →

Timestamp	Since previous	Game		Noshiz's comment
Oct 7 22:40:50		Survival Cubed	♥ 0	Question, are you moving the cube using physics or transform ? And do you use raycasting? If yes the last one maybe have a look at implementation some interpolation which I think would help with the collisions and the "shakey" feeling it gives. Other than that the work is solid for the time given.
Oct 7 22:46:01	5m 11s	Spooky Mansion	♥ 1	Is the windows build available at itch.io ? I can't seem to find the download link. Nevermind found it sorry.
Oct 7 23:11:17	25m 16s	Brian's Quest	♥ 1	Interesting little game, wish the character was moving a little bit faster but I get it that then it would finish much faster.
Oct 7 23:34:41	23m 24s	SwordMaster	♥ 1	Fun game and I liked the twist with the weapons. I was a bit confused as to what I had to do in the beggining because the green button wasn't being pressed (I had to run and poke at it at the same time) but other than that its a solid entry. Nice job.
Oct 7 23:50:45	16m 04s	Blind	♥ 1	Cool game, I loved the art style and the music but not so much the talking sounds. Some translations are missing as you probably know, making the game a bit hard to follow, but I liked the concept. With some polishing this one has some premise.
Oct 8 00:01:35	10m 50s	Evolution of Civilization	♥ 0	Cool idea but it really needs some form of a progression bar. Something in order to know how long till the next unlock. Interesting game otherwise.
Oct 8 00:46:07	44m 32s	Gardening Take Over	♥ 1	Fun little game. It was a bit hard to buy stuff from the market with the sword swinging around and it took me a while to figure out I had to press Space to buy something. Other than that I liked the concept and I think with some improvements it could a be a fun game to play.
Oct 8 00:52:31	6m 24s	You Are Nothing	♥ 2	Interesting idea but a little bit confusing. I get you have to follow the lights in certain order but I got stuck twice on the ghost puzzle. I like the concept though.
Oct 8 01:03:42	11m 11s	Cleaner!	♥ 1	Very interesting game but a little bit confusing in the beggining. Wasn't sure what I was supposed to do, maybe have some sort of missions or something? Good game however I liked it.
Oct 8 01:22:52	19m 10s	The Micro Bang	♥ 1	Really cool idea. Was a bit confused in the beggining as to what I had to do but I figured it out eventaully. Sadly all the planets went a extinct a little bit too fast. One thing I didn't understand it's purpose was the rocket camera, were those rockets that attacked other planets ?
Oct 8 01:39:35	16m 43s	Raiders of the Lost Bark	♥ 1	Very fun game. I loved the idea and very good excecution. One of the better entries, good job. The only real feedback I have is that the camera was moving a little bit too much and felt a bit nauseating, also it would be nice to have a compass as an upgrade so you can find your way back to the shops. Great game.
Oct 8 01:44:52	5m 17s	Agnus - Balls of Steel	♥ 2	Interesting idea and I liked the fact you were trying to offer something new each level. The sound of some of them was a bit too loud but the gameplay itself was fun. Nice job.
Oct 8 01:48:13	3m 21s	Genesis	♥ 2	Very very interesting concept I liked it. Was a bit confused in the beggining as to what I had to do but great game, I want to see more.
Oct 8 09:57:55	8h 09m	Unfold	♥ 1	Very very good entry I loved it. Great art style, nice balance between puzzle / skill in order to finish a level and possibly the only game I played so far with no bugs. The only thing that confused me a bit was flying. While I can see it allows you to move around faster I also assumed I would be able to fly above the spikes. Also, why did the chosen one killed me? :( Good job.
Oct 8 11:43:48	1h 45m	SYNTHMAN	♥ 1	Navigating using sound is an interesting concept, I liked it. I managed to finish it without getting attacked by the beasts or getting hit by the train so I would say it was a bit easy. Also, it was a bit short too. Other than those two things, it was a solid game. I would like to see and play more of it.
Oct 8 12:16:00	32m 12s	Negation	♥ 2	Very original concept, I really liked it! It was quite hard though and I was stuck on a level for a long time. Also, the camera speed felt a bit slow. If you could implement some sort of a hint system (not something that gives you the full solution) that would be amazing. Great game, really good entry.
Oct 8 14:23:00	2h 07m	Space escape	♥ 0	Cool little game, I loved the walking animation both on feet and hand. The gameplay was a bit glitchy however, it seems collisions don't register correctly making jumping some times hard. Also, in some parts the jumping required to get to the next platform is quite hard and takes a few tries. Other than that it was an interesting game, nice job!
Oct 8 16:14:55	1h 51m	Ahoy!	♥ 1	Really good game, I played it a few times. A bit hard and takes a while to start building a nice raft and I was a bit confused in the beggining (I thought I could swim) but other that those things this game is amazing. Great art and fun / addicting gameplay. Good job!
Oct 8 16:34:44	19m 49s	The Quick Fox Jumps Over The Lazy Dog	♥ 2	Some feedback. First I will start with the obvious about building for the windows (or any platform for that matter), what you could do is create a folder in the root of your project (where the .exe currently is) and name it "Builds" or something along those lines. Inside that folder you can have subfolders for the different versions (Windows, WebGL etc). This way you will only need to share the folder containing the actuall build instead of the entire project. About the game, while I understand the idea of the trial and error approach it was a bit frustrating trying to guess each time where each letter goes without having some form of a hint somewhere. I believe it would have been a bit more fair to the player if somewhere in the scene there are hints hidden regarding which bucket each letter has to go to. Also having 3 lives is not enough given how many letters a sentence has and how much luck is involved into completing a game. If there was a hint sort of system then this game would have been a proper puzzle game. Given this is the first time you made a game I'll give you kudos for that. You did far better than my first game. Keep up working on it and you will improve it.
Oct 8 20:06:41	3h 31m	itemless	♥ 0	Cool game but I think its a little bit too hard in the beggining, the night arrives too fast and there aren't enough materials around to build something up quickly enough. Also it seems the weapon upgrade requires you to hit somethin with the point of it? So if a monster has passed the point (like the fast walking ones) then you can not kill them anymore. I like the idea of 2D survival games, sadly not as many of them exist, and I think you could get somewhere with this one but needs some balancing for now.
Oct 8 22:16:11	2h 09m	Checkboxes	♥ 1	Very very original and cool idea. I loved it! Wish there were more levels to play.
Oct 8 22:33:34	17m 23s	Broke'n'Bad	♥ 1	An addicting little simulator about ermm... running a business. Cool idea but I feel like the police meter goes up a bit fast and the attention meter generator upgrade didn't seem to be doing much? Also, was there a purpose for the textured tiles?
Oct 8 22:36:50	3m 16s	Dungscoot	♥ 0	I got the same error as the people before me. Do you have a version without the java bundled with it?
Oct 8 23:05:07	28m 17s	...and to Nothingness Return	♥ 1	Very cool idea and I liked the story. Managed to get to level 16 where I got stuck but I enjoyed it. Good job.
Oct 9 13:57:52	14h 52m	Bathtub Admirals	♥ 2	The client doesn't seem to have a build, just the project files. Also, do we need to run the server in order to play ?
Oct 9 14:08:27	10m 35s	THE WALK	♥ 0	Interesting concept and love the idea with the graves but the game is a bit slow. I think if the timer reached zero faster and faster with each hill it would be a bit more engaging but I do realise that it's done this way mostly for when you reach the old age.
Oct 9 18:59:53	4h 51m	You Gotta Be Kitten Me	♥ 3	Cool game. It was a bit short and a little bit easy but I enjoyed it. My only feedback would be on the cats movement, when you leave one of the WASD buttons the cat keeps moving for half a second or so which made me feel I wasn't in full control. Also, when you right click is the cat supposed to dash forward? Sometimes it did and sometimes it didn't.
Oct 13 14:04:47	91h 04m	Food Fight	♥ 1	The movement was interesting but I think we should be able to keep a key pressed and move towards a direction without having to "spam" the key. I get it's borrowing from the Crypt of the Necrodancer but without the beat to sync with it, it felt a bit tiring. Apart from the I liked the lighthing and post-processing and I managed to finish it although I got lost several times. A bit more variety in the enemies and a smaller amount of health pick ups would also make the game a bit more interesting but given the time and that it's a game jam what was made is good. Good job!
Oct 19 11:19:19	141h 14m	Naked Guy	♥ 1	Best birthday suprise ever. I might do this to my boss for his next birthday. Funny little game, I liked the concept but the movement felt a bit "floaty". I assume you used a rigibody and physics to move the character around, if that's the case then have a look at how to do 2D character controllers using raycasting, this will improve the feeling of the movement a lot and be more inline with good indie games. Other than that I liked it. Good job!
Oct 19 12:37:05	1h 17m	Super Goat Life	♥ 3	I really enjoyed it, incredible job. Didn't manage to find the hidden one though :( My only comment would be on the goats controller, it felt a bit floaty and not very tight but that's the only thing really. I managed to get out of the world too, with some good old school wall climbing. Loved it, great job!
Oct 19 12:57:09	20m 04s	Fall of RS-17 Icarus - an Akaban Tale	♥ 0	Interesting game. I managed to get 3 out of 4 endings, not sure what the 4th one is. My only feedback would be on the movement that was a little bit slow, I get the idea that you are in a space stations and there is zero gravity but still felt a bit slow, and the I kept messing around the mouse. It locks when playing but unlocks when reading text and somehow I managed to keep losing it lol. Fun game otherwise, wish I had found the 4th ending too (which I suppose is a good one?).