Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD45 → Feedback comment stats → Atomic
Feedback comments for LD45
Atomic's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Atomic's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 7 16:36:31 | The Defective Detective | ♥ 1 | Loved it, I listened to whole radio broadcast. You should have expected that :D But it really worked well. I took me some time to get what I was supposed to do, but was understandable in the end. Still kind of bummed out for missing the dragon fight tho. | |
| Oct 7 17:33:25 | 56m 54s | Entangled | ♥ 1 | The art is really cute. Game has some issues, I got semi-stuck at the place with the boots, and fell through a floor once. The boss design and animation is really cool. Simple, but cool to look at. |
| Oct 7 18:14:42 | 41m 17s | Loop to the unknown | ♥ 0 | Looks very nice. I really like the "cinematic" and visual style overall. I had a lot of issues playing though. Had to read the comments to know to use the F button, and had to hit every key on the keyboard to figure out punching was a thing. Then I didn't see why I was dying for several attempts. The tentacle kept killing me before it came out of the main body, and I didn't see it because I was up close for melee. The rocks killed me when they fell on me, and other time, they didn't. Also they kept changing the direction in which they were flying, which I found weird, as I didn't see the reason, why they should. The repeating of flashes of your attempts when you died, although a fun idea, started to be annoying pretty soon, as you couldn't skip them. This was also the problem with the cinematic. I'd love to play some finished polished post LD version though. If it ever comes to it, ping me in the comments, please. |
| Oct 8 13:24:29 | 19h 09m | Witch's Cauldron | ♥ 1 | Let me say I really enjoyed this. It felt nicelly wrapped up and whole - had a relatively clean start, progression, and also an end. If you plan on expanding this idea, please let me know when a new version is out, here in the comments. Good job! |
| Oct 8 13:38:05 | 13m 36s | Raid 51 | ♥ 2 | The controls were a little bit heavy. I couldn't avoid obstacles or collect secrets once I've gotten to higher speed, so ended up hitting the obstacles to stay slow. The secrets were amazing though. All of them made me laugh. Nice ideas .) |
| Oct 8 15:34:25 | 1h 56m | Red Escape | ♥ 1 | The sounds and music are very pleasant, visuals simple, yet pretty. It controls well, and there's just the right amount of difficulty for a LD game. Well done. |
| Oct 9 07:04:10 | 15h 29m | A Fishermans Friendly Island Builder | ♥ 1 | A few suggestions: - change directional keys for WASD - the game gets repetitive VERY fast. I'd increase the speed of debris generation, their movement, and speed of the fishing hook for this volume of gameplay mechanics. The fact it takes an hour to finish it doesn't mean your game has an hour of gameplay. - add some "you won" at the end...? I did a fork on your GitHub so I could play around a bit, and actually built the whole island - it would take an hour otherwise, a time I would not be willing to spend. I suspect the charm of builder/survival games lies in the size of their loop, and this one is not big enough. Despite the criticism, I like your work - your game is the first one I ever downloaded the source for, since I really wanted to finish playing it. The graphics is cute, and this idea could maybe go somewhere - I think this type of game is still trending. |
| Oct 9 14:06:15 | 7h 02m | Start with Nothing | ♥ 0 | The 2D sprites are really pretty. It's a shame there wasn't enough time to animate them and make proper environment, but I still very much appreciate quality 2D art. The music is great! I really love it. The game itself seems very inbalanced and purely luck based. Also, there's no sure way to tell which enemy you're targeting, and the unskippable intro scene that you have to watch every time you die is outright annoying. The "DECK" button doesn't seem to be doing anything either. I'd really like to play and finish this game, but the fact that your choices don't really matter much, and having to wait 30 seconds every time you die (which RNG makes you quite often) made me quit at the fourth battle, by the third time I died. |
| Oct 9 14:22:51 | 16m 36s | Nothing to Lose 🌍💥☄️👽 | ♥ 1 | Wow. The visuals were a surprise for me, somehow it all fits together so very well. The audio complemented the story and the mood, as did the title screen. I got some serious Liu Cixin vibes from this one. Nice job! |
| Oct 10 10:32:37 | 20h 09m | Seed | ♥ 0 | Thank you. I'm still laughing out loud. You deserve a reward. Here: \*blows raspberry\* |
| Oct 10 10:51:22 | 18m 45s | Ant Wars RTS | ♥ 1 | Nice to have a RTS I can actually win. Great job! The best game for me fun-wise so far! |
| Oct 10 11:42:57 | 51m 35s | Over The Threshold | ♥ 2 | 5* for mood, 5* for theme, and two more almost fives, audio and overall. Hats off to you. |
| Oct 12 22:07:19 | 58h 24m | PlainMan | ♥ 1 | Fun game, loved the story. You should make more of these, I'd definitely play them .) |
| Oct 12 22:58:52 | 51m 33s | Island of the Coconut Spirit | ♥ 0 | Whole island dancing to the rhythm of the song is cute as hell .) Maybe remove the vocals from the music theme...? |
| Oct 14 18:06:35 | 43h 07m | Nothing and Everything and Anything | ♥ 1 | Great job. I really enjoyed this. Text games truly are underrated. You've got some of the best scores I gave so far for fun, theme and mood from me. |
| Oct 15 19:41:50 | 25h 35m | Water | ♥ 1 | Neat concept AND execution. As others have said, character movement was really slow. Also I kept falling through the floor in the web version, so I downloaded win version - no porblems there. |
| Oct 15 19:50:04 | 8m 14s | All Aboard ! Thousand portholes | ♥ 1 | The game fails to execute, because it misses a "urctbased.dll" file. |
| Oct 15 19:59:44 | 9m 40s | Dungeon Crawler | ♥ 0 | I won! yay! 😆 |
| Oct 15 20:06:30 | 6m 46s | Bob Bobinson's Revange | ♥ 3 | Neon Genesis: Revangelion AU! A-TAK! I really laughed a lot 😆 |
| Oct 15 20:17:46 | 11m 16s | Delta Test Site | ♥ 1 | Waiting for platforms in the second level was too much for me, and made me rage quit. It'd work a lot better if there were multiple platforms. I'd rather fail jumping up than wait for 10 seconds for platform to come down every time I fall. Apart from that, the music fits perfectly, I loved the few audiotracks that played (jump sound, and that red thing between two gray things), and the graphics is solid. Good job! |
| Oct 16 07:26:12 | 11h 08m | Succulentia | ♥ 1 | succulentia.png The insect clicking wasn't that much fun for me. My hand still hurts from it. I really liked the planting/watering aspect of the game though. Can't remember the last time I cared for something virtual as much as I cared for my beautiful succulents. 🤔 Am I getting old? If you added a pause functionality, I'd keep playing later, and if the pace of the game reeeealy went down, I can imagine having it run on the background, and check on the plants time to time. I even might make a game like it for my own satisfaction. Anyway, great job, and thanks for this game. |
| Oct 16 18:38:28 | 11h 12m | Spikt | ♥ 1 | Great use of color black. The graphics are really pleasant to look at, the game gives me some serious old school platformer vibes, which I grew up with. There were a few glitches, but nothing game breaking. Also, I'd do something with the little dark lines/cracks on background panels. They're quite disturbing, and don't look that good. The rest of the game I loved. Nice job! |
| Oct 17 16:58:21 | 22h 19m | Wandering Soul | ♥ 2 | A big YES from me! The gameplay is on the simpler side, but with this being a game jam and there being only so much time to wrap things up, it is understandable. (Also, I'm really not the one to talk about gameplay this time around). Apart from that, I love the aesthetics! I really appreciated there being three different enemies, the sound is haunting, even chilling, and the low framerate of the animations adds a nice little something to the creepyness of it all. Great job people! 👏 |
| Oct 17 17:14:20 | 15m 59s | OverClerked | ♥ 0 | Great job. Very pleasant sounding, fun to play, and nice to look at. Also cute AF. When I grow up, I wanna be like you 😆 |
| Oct 17 17:28:22 | 14m 02s | The Howler | ♥ 0 | srsly WTF 5* |
| Oct 18 07:14:51 | 13h 46m | They stole my stuff :( | ♥ 1 | Funny game 😆 I had my share of chuckles .) |
| Oct 18 07:34:49 | 19m 58s | Unlock Everything | ♥ 1 | Well, the others said it all. The game's awesome, progression is great, difficulty curve perfect for a compo game. The final boss is just spot on difficult. Took me three attempts to find a strategy and win. Audio - awesome, visuals - awesome. I'm rooting for you. And now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to play "Inflate me to the moon" again. (still got it on my phone) |
