Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD44 → Feedback comment stats → Kilian BAPTENDIER
Feedback comments for LD44
Kilian BAPTENDIER's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Kilian BAPTENDIER's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 30 16:03:07 | Orgain | ♥ 1 | I think I have some problems with the build, I can't play it well: I can't change items (with both my keyboard and my mouse) and when I press Space, I'm not hiding but playing a weird animation and There is no restart button, I have to reload the page. Whatever, I understand what you wanted to do, and it could be interesting. I have to admit that my first jam was clumsy too, discovering Unity can be hard. Don't give up, you can learn a lot in jams. So just a tip: Search what is an anchor on Unity doc, so now your UI can fit any type of screen ;D | |
| Apr 30 16:25:06 | 21m 59s | Noobmancer | ♥ 4 | That's an amazing game. The concept is cool, the art fits well, I didn't see any bugs (That's the harder xD) and there is a excellent tutorial (In a jam I think it's mind-blowing). Unfortunately, I can't listen to the audio ('cause I don't have headphones on me...) so I won't rate it. I know it could be a style, but if you want to smooth the edges of a mesh on Unity, you click on it in the project folder (not the scene), and there's something called "Normals" in the Inspector, swith it to "Calculate" and add some numbers in "Smoothing angle". Just a tip if you didn't know. Great job you did ! Hope we'll see you in the next Ludum ! |
| Apr 30 16:40:38 | 15m 32s | Dead Only | ♥ 1 | Dam this game is hard ! I'm a big fan of pixel art and I think these graphics are really good, I appreciate the reference with the first Zelda's. The concept is quite simple but good. An amazing work for a compo, big respect. |
| May 2 19:48:22 | 51h 07m | Clock of Your Life | ♥ 1 | Good concept. I just don't understand why you say that it's not fun. A game is made to be fun, and degrading your game is just like saying "Please don't play my game". Get more confidence and always think every person sees fun differently. Good continuation for the other jams ;D |
| May 2 20:14:19 | 25m 57s | Dungeons of Taradith | ♥ 0 | The concept is pretty strong, the graphics are smooth and the audio feeling is pretty satisfying. There's just one thing: I think the game is way too easy. I reached floor 30 by spamming cards and buying nothing. The curve of difficulty is the only problem for me, and the skill cap is really low. Nevertheless, this game can have a future, with more and more cards, it could be really interesting. Good job. |
| May 2 20:40:22 | 26m 03s | Nutty Twins | ♥ 1 | The concept is amazing, the graphics are top tier and the levels are well-designed. But, there's two problems for me: 1) I can't bear the audio, the SFX and the music are giving me headaches. I have to admit it's polished, but it is not enjoyable at all for me. (I had to mute my PC sound) 2) I don't see the theme. I know lots of people don't care about that, but I really have the impression that you've thought about the concept before the jam, and then try to adapt it. I personally don't think it's fair for the others (even if I know sometimes a jam is just an excuse to have time to develop an idea). Maybe you haven't done that, and just adapt the theme to your mind, but for me, you didn't check the "constraint" part. Nevertheless, this prototype is polished, and the concept have a future (except for the sound xD). Furthermore, it looks like you've done it alone, so big respects. |
| May 2 20:59:40 | 19m 18s | Bloody Money | ♥ 0 | I see it's your first jam, and I have to admit it's better than my first one. Of course, this game isn't perfect at all, there's lots of problems (hitboxes, spiders...) but even if you've suffered during these 72h, you achieve to post something, and that's how you improve yourself. Don't give up, you can learn a lot in jams ! Ps: Try to find a team, the creativity is better and you have less work to do 😉 |
| May 2 21:15:33 | 15m 53s | Red Rock | ♥ 2 | Hey ! It's actually pretty fun to destroy asteroids. Even if the Character controller is kind of "slippy", I find it quite enjoyable. Your menu is perfect, so beautiful, I also like your FX on the canons: pretty simple and clear. |
| May 2 21:31:04 | 15m 31s | shoot out your life | ♥ 0 | Love the art, the sound is pretty satisfying and the theme is well-adapted. I don't know how Tetra works but you seems to know it pretty well. |
| May 2 21:48:20 | 17m 16s | Trash Planet Explorer | ♥ 1 | What a beautiful game. The mechanics are cool, the graphics are incredible, the "toggle screen" button and the minimap are proofs of quality xD. Even if you didn't fished what you wanted to do, this is currently satisfying. Oh, and why did you put rating on Audio and no rating on Graphics ? I can't hear any sounds and I thought you've done every asset. |