Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD37 → Feedback comment stats → Big Cow
Feedback comments for LD37
Big Cow's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Big Cow's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 13 19:39:00 | The 5th Room | Hey nice work! Great atmosphere and interesting story. Cheers! | |
| Dec 13 19:52:00 | 13m 00s | One Room | YEAH I touched the bird. Celebration times! haha. |
| Dec 13 20:12:00 | 20m 00s | Janusz: The handyman simulator | Great idea for a game. This could be expanded to do an entire house one room at a time in stages. Anyway good work for the compo. Well done -RS |
| Dec 13 20:25:00 | 13m 00s | Room Jumper | For me this wins for innovation and theme. Really great idea and nicely executed. It has a puzzle dynamic I have not seen before in a game. I like the fact the person outside taunts you as well to give you something humorous to read as you are playing. Just long enough to get into it and feel a sense of satisfaction from getting out. Nice job! |
| Dec 13 20:39:00 | 14m 00s | DestrucToy | Great job on this. Found it really fun driving around the room and trying to make the loops. Its pretty unforgiving I mean I found it hard to make it all the way round -RS |
| Dec 13 20:52:00 | 13m 00s | The Living Room Battlescape | Nice idea! Had classic flying shootemup feel to it. I like the facts that a lot was going on the hoards keep coming and its a bit frantic. Pixel graphics gave me a terminal velocity flashback. Found a bug: I died and kept racking up the kills though :P. Anyway nice work. Cheers -RS |
| Dec 13 21:15:00 | 23m 00s | Escape from Man Cave | I'm really impressed by this. Its a really great idea to implement for the compo and nicely done. It took me an embarrassingly large amount of time to realize a movie was playing so I was doing it by sound looking at the computer screen LOL. I'm glad its quite forgiving as I made a few mistakes too and I didn't want it to reset to 0. Anyway thanks and best of luck. -RS |
| Dec 13 21:25:00 | 10m 00s | Defeat the Kraken | Decent multi level boss fight and I found it very hard even on easy :) not really to theme but a nice little shooter. Thanks. -RS |
| Dec 13 21:37:00 | 12m 00s | Books! | It loaded up but I was stuck and couldn't move. Just wanted to say how cool the demo looked on youtube. Ever since I saw https://libraryofbabel.info/ on a vsauce video the concept of every possible phrase being searchable on that website is kinda cool and kinda spooky. You seem to have captured that and added some cool physics. Nice work. -RS |
| Dec 13 21:44:00 | 7m 00s | Lost In The Dance | Gorgeous. Nice modelling, materials and lighting. Really cool set up and I like the mystery element to it. Good work! |
| Dec 13 22:14:00 | 30m 00s | nO mooRe | Really atmospheric, the music fitted really well, engaging story. The ending genuinely made my hairs stand on end. There wasn't always logic behind when something became allowed to be picked up, but I got through the puzzles no problem and enjoyed the journey. |
| Dec 13 22:35:00 | 21m 00s | Undermind | Very atmospheric, loved the graphics and audio. Good use of horror theme without resorting to jump scares. I could never take my eye off the painting on the wall! |
| Dec 15 00:15:00 | 25h 40m | Just pick a number | Very nice. Made me think, very tense decision making. |
| Dec 15 00:20:00 | 5m 00s | One Room for No One Anymore | Nice art, and the last lines got to me. |
| Dec 16 16:40:00 | 40h 20m | Voyage | This was great! Reminded me of the ren and stimpy episode "space madness" :) also the character style is great and makes me think of Swords and Sworcery. Its such a great idea to have his attitude to the very same objects evolve over time as he changes. Overall true to the theme, intriguing and eventually shocking (in a good way). Thanks -RS |
| Dec 16 22:04:00 | 5h 24m | Love Bar | This reminds me of nights I've had trying to find a partner when going to bars and clubbing.What an interesting and original experience you created! Cheers -RS |
| Dec 16 22:12:00 | 8m 00s | Last Call | I think this might be my favorite game so far! Excellent concept, great balance of dodging and aiming skill, stylized graphics, nice use of music and sound even if you didn't make it. Found it really fun and addictive and it was funny. Nice one! Cheers -RS |
| Dec 16 22:20:00 | 8m 00s | The Chamber Crowd | Great take on the theme. Nice way of gamifying the room moving and hitting targets. I like the choice of the thin line around the models to give it style and the kind of chaotic katamari feel to it. Its quite tricky but managed to get a perfect score after 3 goes so im happy :) Cheers -RS |
| Dec 16 22:35:00 | 15m 00s | Tiny House | I really liked this. I liked the graphics style and the puzzle element. Reminded me of boxxel or boulderdash style games but a really original take on it. Thank you. -RS |
| Dec 17 00:24:00 | 1h 49m | A cats life | Just brilliant, Fantastic concept and well executed. Really loved the art style and animation and the choice of sounds. Also great sense of humour. It ramps up really quick at one stage and it feels impossible to stop the noise and keep baby happy. Anyway nicely done! Cheers -RS |
| Dec 17 00:35:00 | 11m 00s | Kitchens Master Chef ! | Hey nice idea. I really wanted to give the girl a banana but when I clicked an item it just jumped away! Anyway well done on what you were able to get done for the competition. -RS |
| Dec 17 00:47:00 | 12m 00s | Ilea's Life | The skull image is gorgeous and I found the idea of travelling through it on a platform game as the "one room" really nice. I'm really glad you had fun making this its why I do Ludum Dare! -RS |
| Dec 17 01:02:00 | 15m 00s | Time Passes | Really nicely done subtle story. I like what you did with the theme. The choice element is excellent and I think the way the story unwraps is compelling and well written. I think you brought a sensitivity to what it must be like to be in that situation too. Thank you -RS |
| Dec 17 19:40:00 | 18h 38m | Throne Room | Nice work on this. It feels like a complete game, which is impressive for the short space of time. I also probably played this longer than any game so far to try to build up my kingdom but eventually I ran out of gold and all my people died :(. I like how you expanded the universe out of the room without leaving the room.The room itself looks cool too. Thanks. -RS |
| Dec 17 19:50:00 | 10m 00s | Spatially Efficient Party | haha the idea of this game is brilliant a simple but engaging puzzle game using logic. Found myself forgetting who was who which wasn't very efficient anyway nice one. Cheers -RS |
| Dec 18 11:21:00 | 15h 31m | Euclid | I like this idea of being stuck in a room where if you turn the wrong way you end up in the same place instead of progressing. I thought the choice of colors, materials and sound for this were good. Cheers -RS |
| Dec 18 11:53:00 | 32m 00s | The Leaky Ceiling | I find these click to collect games very addictive so I couldnt stop playing. Once I got the last item there was nothing else to do! Anyway nice work on the creativity dog? what? and sound track and game logic. Cheers -RS |
| Dec 18 12:04:00 | 11m 00s | Rotate the room! | Great idea! Found the ball really hard to move right and it kept falling out of the front face of the room also not technically one room as it had levels :P. It looks amazing though I love the pixelatted 3D look and lighting. Nice one -RS |
| Dec 18 12:11:00 | 7m 00s | Sign | I think this was brilliant! Really creepy like a bad dream or dark poem. Nice work! Cheers -RS |
| Dec 18 12:18:00 | 7m 00s | Room of Chaos and Creation | The way the room changes when you aren't looking is creepy it really added to the mood. Love the idea! Cheers -RS |
| Dec 18 12:30:00 | 12m 00s | Super Indie Dev Bro | That poor dev guy I feel for him haha! The work you put into the graphics clearly shows and the game has a sense of humor. Nice work -RS |
| Dec 18 18:52:00 | 6h 22m | Psychiatry | Really funny game, I spotted the jumper cables reference. Nice innovative gameplay. I enjoyed the music too. Only problem was that once you figured out what was the right answer for a given person you could just spam that answer. |
| Dec 18 19:22:00 | 30m 00s | Dead by Morning | Great mood, loved the aesthetics and audio |
| Dec 18 19:34:00 | 12m 00s | Super Battle Cycle | Really fun - I liked the physics and controls, and the aesthetics, particularly the smoke effect. |
| Dec 19 22:05:00 | 26h 31m | Prorotype Scrapyard | Took me way too long to release like 2 years. Never mind sold over 2 million copies :) Interesting take on the one room challenge great mood of tension and metaphore for game dev and release close to all ludum darers hearts :). Thanks -RS |
| Dec 19 22:17:00 | 12m 00s | Evil Udolfs Room | I think you are really underselling it by saying its unfinished. Seriously you have the main game dynamic working (levers expanding the room which by the way I think is a great idea that I have not seen anyone else do yet), it looks fine (materials and enemies have color and textures), you have sound working, you worked in some humor with the voice, you can fire a gun and hit targets which I found quite satisying and the health counts down when get hit! To me that makes it complete enough! A lot of LD entries dont get that far its impressive you got this much done in such a short time honestly :) Cheers -RS |
| Dec 19 22:41:00 | 24m 00s | Box Kingdom | Nice take on the one room theme! The art has a fairy tale feel but the enemies are dark and the noise of the bird, look of the prince, and the maggots are creepy. Nice work -RS |
| Dec 19 22:47:00 | 6m 00s | John in the room | Haha nice work. First time there was a bloody dead voxel man on the floor. I love this idea of keeping stuff away from this poor depressed man I think it was really innovative though very short. |
| Dec 19 22:52:00 | 5m 00s | The One Roomed House | Haha I like the tile clue. Try as I might I couldn't climb up though :) Anyway nice work on the one room concept for this LD. Cheer -RS |
| Dec 21 20:19:00 | 45h 27m | It Came from the Dessert | Cool idea to lure the ants with food and gameify it. Managed to lure and kill a few of them in the fridge but who wants pizza when you can have cake haha! Anyway good work. |
| Dec 21 21:03:00 | 44m 00s | Room Escape | I'm really impressed by what you did here with the time provided! There is quite a lot of stuff to interact with and logic. It feels like a complete experience. The puzzles were challenging enough and interesting and you even had time to have an ending. very satisfying nice work! -RS |
| Dec 21 21:13:00 | 10m 00s | Bad Dreams | The art is really lovely in this and the spiders creepy. Makes you wonder whats going on as well as being a basic shooter. The sounds hurt my ears a bit and crackled on my computer. Nice work -RS |
| Dec 21 21:30:00 | 17m 00s | Cloud Chaser | This has such a lovely mood and the world you created is really original. The music matched the experience in a really good way to make it relaxing. I have to admit I like the idea of the controls but in practice found it infuriating and would have preferred if it was easier to get around. The idea of going from inside the ship to outside kind of blows my mind a bit great innovation. -RS |
| Dec 21 21:39:00 | 9m 00s | The Last Room | Kept playing for the challenge and to see what happens next! Its really unforgiving and sometimes requires a bit of luck to be in the right place. I thought it was very clever and you created a creepy mood and hard as nails type skill game thats really unique. Well done! -RS |