Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD23 → Feedback comment stats → Robert Swan
Feedback comments for LD23
Robert Swan's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Robert Swan's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 24 13:17:00 | ResourceCollector | I played this for quite a while - but it would crash after a few minutes every time while piling into a group of aliens and trying to take them all out at once. <br/> <br/>Having said that, I kept replaying it hoping it would get past it so it means I was genuinely enjoying myself once I worked out the keys! | |
| Apr 24 13:49:00 | 32m 00s | IOTA | The picking up specks was pretty hard but I carried on anyway! Nice ambince. My laptop runs most games (LD or commercial) ok, but iota hung my machine (well I was getting 1 frame every 30 seconds) once I got to the second stage so couldn't see any more. |
| Apr 24 14:38:00 | 49m 00s | LittlePlanetBigRocket | Nice concept! More levels required :) |
| Apr 25 11:47:00 | 21h 09m | My Little Planetoid | Great! I did get one zone that after I trashed I couldn't build on - but only a minor point when the rest was raelly interesting. |
| Apr 27 16:21:00 | 52h 34m | Save the tiny world! | Excellent music and good (if hard) gameplay. Looks nice too! |
| Apr 30 05:53:00 | 61h 32m | Serendipity with Cubes | Very nice. Once I'd worked out what to do it was enjoyable - although I admit I had a hard time being able to plan ahead to avoid "floaters" because the next two pulsing cubes to join was random. Those are small, tweakable things, and overall it was worth playing. |
| May 3 21:43:00 | 87h 50m | Tiny Room | Cute menus and lots of bullets and powerups which was nice. The sound effects and music were decent. I also got massive slowdown and wasn't sure if it was deliberate or not! I wished it was at times to give me a better chance of dodging. I only have manged to get 6th in the high score table so far. |
| May 3 21:47:00 | 4m 00s | orange thing | For a first attempt - you've got jumping, moving platforms and parallax backgrounds (always a must!). Congrats! |
| May 3 21:53:00 | 6m 00s | Zilla the Destroyer | I really like the vector graphics. I was just overwhelmed by choppers at the end, but it was still fun to splat them to pieces for as long as I could. |
| May 3 22:05:00 | 12m 00s | Searching for Heaven | For the short period of time that is excellent. One of the few original games on here that could easily be expanded into a full title. Impressive! |
| May 3 22:15:00 | 10m 00s | Watercolour | I enjoyed it - got stuck in an area and could do nothing but wait until the end of the world! I didn't mind. Really liked the look and the music was very very good. |
| May 3 22:21:00 | 6m 00s | Disastronaut | Played it until the end and I actually wanted to as well! I enjoyed playing it and the ending cheered me up! |
| May 5 13:33:00 | 39h 12m | AdventuresInTinyWorld | I try to avoid commenting on the what I think are obvious flaws the author knows about but didn't have time to fix (such as the flawed physics and the awkwardness/impossibility of escaping the other cats). <br/> <br/>I played it a fair bit trying to even see the ball at the end but no chance. The gfx were ok, and getting in audio was good. Joypad control in XNA would have been easy and made life easier, but maybe you don't have an Xbox controller. With some changes to the physics and changing the level to make moving around easier this could be the basis of a solid platform game. I like cats so the bum wiggle is a win for me! |
| May 5 13:39:00 | 6m 00s | Poor Pluto | Highest score 2462 - longest chain 46. I am not very good. <br/> <br/>Game brought a big smile to my face - very straight forward and good fun. While I struggled massively with abrupt changes of attack I kept playing. I could see this either being tidied up a bit to be a cool minigame in a full release, or having many cool tweaks to make it really polished looking and give the gameplay some more legs. <br/> <br/>Excellent for 8 hours. Big smiley face is nice. |
| May 5 13:43:00 | 4m 00s | tiny hostile world | I enjoyed this quite a lot - the collision detection could do with some tweaking (I expect you know this of course!) but otherwise I'd have loved to carry on to reach the "desperate but just under control" stage I like on these sorts of panic-inducing games. |
| May 5 13:49:00 | 6m 00s | We're going to need another Gnomy! | Throwing the gnomes was nice, I enjoyed the audio too. So a complete product - but I'm sure you are aware (as everyone is) that the difficulty made it impossible to play for more than a minute! Unless there is a strategy we were unaware of. Could have been great with some tweaks. |
| May 5 14:02:00 | 13m 00s | The Lair | I won! Audio + proper end goal + end of game boss = cool. |
| May 5 14:08:00 | 6m 00s | WTF World | Very interesting idea. I bet there are lots of cool things that could be done with this. Played for some time and then exe crashed on a replay of level 2 and looked like it affected stuff on my desktop (which was very unusual so I doubt it will happen to other people) so I didn't run it again, which was a shame :( |
| May 5 14:23:00 | 15m 00s | This Precious Land | One of the few games that I've come back to and even now my girlfriend wants to play. Very nice! |
| May 5 18:35:00 | 4h 12m | Pin Party | Far too hard... and maybe swapping wasd and arrow keys would help some of us used to other configs too :) Shame as I like these games, and this did look cool |
| May 6 20:28:00 | 25h 53m | BamSquitch | Nice. Simple and nicely thought out levels - there is an actual "game" here! Congrats. |
| May 6 20:43:00 | 15m 00s | 12 Days in a Snow Globe | Very nice looking game. Could easily see adding a few more things to do would turn this from a 48-hour game into something that would draw people back repeatedly. I played for a few days until I realised I had essentially "beaten" it. The quality of what was laready there made me feel more was going to happen! |
| May 6 21:07:00 | 24m 00s | Penguin | Only a few minor things that were confusing but I'm sure you know this. I played for some time and enjoyed it. |
| May 6 23:56:00 | 2h 49m | Bacterial World | Straight forward and enjoyable. I can't get very far with my reactions though! |
| May 7 10:19:00 | 10h 23m | Boxed in. | Excellent game. Not just because of it's polish but because the game has given rise to puzzles that show the designer's brain trying to tease the gameplayer's brain fairly :) I like that sort of stuff! |
| May 7 23:26:00 | 13h 07m | Tiny Cubic Maze World | I are very win. Could be taken a lot further as there's a solid and clean base game. On some faces you had the "puzzles" where you had to chase around the sides a bit. These were the funnest. |
| May 8 19:40:00 | 20h 14m | Save the World | Nice small little game. A bit of tweaking to make it a bit easier would have gone a long way. Or maybe I'm just rubbish, which is very likely. |
| May 8 19:50:00 | 10m 00s | Out for arrest | Hard but fun. A great idea. Could do with better or different clues for the bad guys but was novel. Reminded me of a game I saw years ago, back in the days of Doom, where someone set out to have a Doom-like fps with 1000s of mobs walking around, and you have to run through them and spot the few miscreants in the middle. That was hard too! |
| May 8 23:01:00 | 3h 11m | (Tiny) Worlds of Illusion | Again, not sure about the theme. But 6 stars out of 5 for innovation! Fantastic idea - really had me doubting my eyes at points which I love. |
| May 8 23:09:00 | 8m 00s | Green War on Earth | Nice to get in the audio and sound effects too. I found the 2nd and repeated levels easier than the first! |
| May 13 14:26:00 | 111h 17m | Leaving the Tiny Earth | Very good to get the game in there that you did in the time. Sure it's rough around the edges. As its pretty much a clone of Terraria/MC it's not original, but of course working to a restriction can enable productivity which is a great lesson to learn as well. |
| May 13 20:34:00 | 6h 08m | Tiny Crash Landing | Good to get some stuff working, including audio which is more than I ever attempt. Cute artwork definitely - so keep going! |