Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD17 → Feedback comment stats → Tenoch

Tenoch

Feedback comments for LD17

Tenoch's games and stats for all events →

Timestamp	Since previous	Game	Tenoch's comment
		Intercontinental Drift	Meh? Quite hard, and very annoying music. Mostly I felt like randomly pushing stuff around and see what happened.
		Island Repair Man	Quite minimalistic but pleasant. Although for very conceptual games like that, a nice athmosphere would help a lot (music and visual effects).
		Pleochorism	Quite amazing idea. Got pretty hard very fast, but the athmosphere maked you want to keep going. <br/>Great job!
		The Naturalist	Cool concept, nice graphics. Physics were a bit off I think. And the lack of proper ending is a bit frustrating. <br/>As they say, try to make it more, it'd be great!
		BRAVE ISLAND DIVER	Nice realisation and everything, but I really dont get this one oO
		Larma and the Missing Island	Wow, I'm hypnotised by this one. Played it through. <br/>Amazing visuals and animation. Interesting and unusual gameplay (although doing pretty much anything seemed ok to pass to the next level, I did funny stuff anyway :) ). <br/> <br/>However, quite lazy connection to the theme. And did you actually compose/record the music during the compo? Seems unlikely, but if you did, kudos!
		Tiny Armada	Heh, I'm hooked. Really nice mechanics, and these ennemies are not so easy to beat. I've been playing it for a while now :)
		Island Hopping	Very nice looking albeit simple. Pretty hard, though, and the first straight line is maybe a bit long, since we die and start over every 3 islands :) <br/>Music is clean but a bit repetitive. Overall quite well polished.
		Island Defender	I love fast and reactive games like this. Simple but efficient. Powerful sounds effects, and nice music. <br/>All good!
		Roller-Derby 20XX: Mega Islands of Awesome	Sweet! Love the universe, background, graphics, humor, music. Gameplay is a tad annoying sometimes (big leaps of faith that end, well, badly) but otherwise quite smooth and enjoyable. <br/>Yay!
		Rocket Bike To Space	Wow, tough one, but addictive. <br/>Extreme frustration when jumping over a star, you don't get the checkpoint activated. Extreme <br/>Marvelous paletted drawings and psychedelic music!
		I HATE ISLANDS	Good laughs from this one! The drawings a pretty cool, and the overall idea of personificating islands is interesting. <br/> <br/>Also I liked how the copter fired both bombs and bullets for increased rage. <br/> <br/>Did you make the music during the compo, though? Ôo
		The Floor Is Lava	I like the gameplay and the little funny details. The music is pretty nice too.
		Nieuwe Aarde	Very well polished (lacks music perhaps). <br/>Gameplay is a bit confusing at first , and a bit slow afterwards (clicking "work" repetedly). The traveling method was odd (adding lots of boats on the sea like this?) <br/>But you might be able to make a great game out of this.
		The Lost Hebrides	I seemed to have an aiming problem as well. I needed to click far below the guys for it to work. <br/>Otherwise beautiful!
		Monkey Islands	Now this is insanely cute, and the music is nice. <br/>But yeah, not a game, really...
		Islands: Through the Sweep of Stars	That would have been nice, turned into a Pretentious Art Game, with some delicate music and a minimum of interactivity (moving a guy around to get clues?) The drawings have a pretty distinctive style, would have like more! <br/> <br/>Most of the questions were far too tricky to be answered without cheating. Perhaps basing them only on clues in the images would have been more interesting. <br/> <br/>It has some charm though.
		Island Hermit Hop!	This one got me hooked. The colors and music made the game very poetic and charming. Animation and big pixels too. <br/> <br/>The movement is very well balanced, but those darn homing sharks are quite a pain.
		SkyLands	Great fun! The simplest ideas are sometimes the best. <br/> <br/>Never managed to beat the second level though, these rotating ones are nasty. Adn sometimes the collision detection is a bit severe. <br/> <br/>But the great music made me want to finish the game!
		Poke-Slayer	Mwahaha, the best laugh! Absolutely charming drawings and sounds, and that crappy-recording non-edited song is just gold! <br/> <br/>Thank you so much for this!
		Hairgel Quest	I appreciate the effort in making this game, and bonus points for that! Fun drawings, humor, etc. We need more graphical adventures. <br/>It was however a bit slow to move and buggy.
		Hula Girl HD	In a ryhtm game, the music should probably by in tempo with the game... <br/>Once I managed to ignore the music, it was actually quite fun. Got to 82% or so.
		YOU ARE ISLAND.	Meh? What's going on there? :D
		The Noah's Ark	Ha, overall gets minimal, but humor maximal grade! <br/>Someone had to do it!
		Pedestrian Voter	Fun sounds. A bit slow perhaps.
		Isolated Empire	Very nice looking and quite complete game. I did suck at it though. Maybe it would be nice to see which zones are being worked at, even when not having the mouse over them.
		Eyelands	Mmm, i agree with the others. Death is swift and mercyless in this game. Funny graphics, but the environment is quite empty. Feels desolated.
		the Traveling Salesman Problem	Oah, the movement is super slow. Too bad the cute graphics didn't extend to the shores.
		Evil Lair Command	A clicking-frenzy game like this requires mad sounds and visual effects :) <br/>It seems that the difficulty wasn't increasing, so after 200 I got bored. <br/>Could be turned into a fun little game though!
		Tango	Erm, is that a game? =) <br/>Looks okish though. Minimalistic.
		Loneliness	Ha, I loved it. I half wanted to do something similar. Funny patterns sometimes, and the expected ending. <br/> <br/>Music would have been great though.
		Ultimate Baluga Whale	Bonus points for "so bad it's good", but minus points for all the rest...
		Awesome LifeBoat Game	Cool sounds, but the game is a bit boring. <br/>It's not bad, though.
		Golden	Nothing really special, but platformer movements worked well.
		Island Abduction	I can make a port to Windows tomorrow if you want, it should be quite esay. I'll let you know. <br/> <br/>This being said, except if you actually live on a paradisiac island, there's little chance that you could take the background pictures during the compo (or the jungle sounds), thus breaking The Rules. <br/> <br/>Too bad, the game itself is fun and quite well realised.
		AlienIslands	The guy was really slow. And the game slightly boring. But looked quite nice. I didn't like too much the very big open space before the boat. Seemed unfinished.
		Island Shoving	Compilation is fine (Linux), but segfaults at start...
		Simcano	Cute art, but what's the goal?
		NapolÃ�Â©on et la punition mystÃ�Â©rieuse Ã�Â®le du diable	Frustratingly hard, probably because of bad physics? <br/>Otherwise I liked the athmosphere, with the looks and sounds.
		Pirate-Go-Round	I like the bullet patterns and how you can shoot yourself if you want. Graphics are simple but nice. <br/> <br/>Not sure why there are 4 fire buttons though. Is there any difference? <br/> <br/>Didn't play with someone, but i imagine it could keep us busy for a while.
		NoNameIsland	It's not really easy to understand what's happening, maybe a more complete explanation of the mechanics would have helped. <br/>Appart from placing a lot of buildings and flags, and wait, is there anything to do? Is there a winning condition? <br/> <br/>The little ingame texts are quite funny though.
		Atollery	Took a while to figure out controls (left/right click) and despite the explanations, the goald was not clear. Managed the first few levels, but then there seemed to be several solutions, and mine weren't accepted.
		108 seconds of loneliness	At first I thought there was nothing to do on the island, just wander around and push boxes, and with the name, I figured it was a case of Prententious Art Game that would make you meditate on isolation... <br/> <br/>But once you figure out the goal, it's quite fun. It has a nice sokoban feel, plus interesting mechanisms (streams). And it looks good. <br/> <br/>The 4rth level seems undoable though?