Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD58 → Feedback comment stats → SirRed
Feedback comments for LD58
SirRed's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | SirRed's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 7 14:03:13 | The Odd Job | ♥ 2 | Cool concept. It definitely made me try to figure out what was going on. I think another level with distorted colors or a more bizarre conclusion before the tape tv scene could have been cool. If you made the collider on the character smaller, around leg height, I think it would have been much easier to move around the levels | |
| Oct 7 14:12:59 | 9m 46s | Katamari Survivors | ♥ 1 | Reminds me of Donut County. My ball ended up being a lot towards 1 side being bigger so it made it a bit hard to get around at the end. I guess that is my fault I should have been a better collector. I could have easily spend more than the 3 minutes it took to beat if the map was bigger and you could start adding the houses and pipes to your collection |
| Oct 7 14:28:20 | 15m 21s | Beelines | ♥ 1 | Reminds me of the old airplane control tower mobile games so I liked it a lot. I would have liked it a bit more hectic with faster bees for more multitasking when planning their movement |
| Oct 7 14:53:01 | 24m 41s | Knock-N-Treat | ♥ 1 | Loved the game. played it twice and got 91 candies on the second try. Fun and cute game |
| Oct 9 21:45:26 | 54h 52m | The Garbage-Man Of New Trash City | ♥ 4 | Love the audio and vo you guys did. I think a little bit tighter turn radius on the car would have made getting around a little bit smoother. I managed to get up to 214 and had a good time. |
| Oct 9 22:26:08 | 40m 42s | Aeternia | ♥ 1 | Walking around and taking pictures felt really good and was super smooth. I found 3 of the meditation circles and tried all of them in various places and was not able to figure out how to get something to happen. I assume I needed to be in a certain spot when I did them, but was not able to find it. I did like figuring out them but a bit to cryptic I guess on where to actually input the code |
| Oct 9 22:44:52 | 18m 44s | Collector Kitty | ♥ 2 | Cute game. I really like the art. I think the player movement being faster would help a lot on being able to move around. The puzzles were good although simple since they were not expanded on. Great entry |
| Oct 9 23:08:06 | 23m 14s | Souls Keeper | ♥ 2 | Super fun on the movement side. I love games like neon white so this is very much like that. Progressing level 2 was quite annoying with having to do level 1 over and over again to get it to again, also the start door opening inwards instead of outwards made the restarts take a long time. I think having the angel at specific points in the level or a specific time would have made it much more interesting. It randomly deciding to start while grappling is rough. I would have liked that mechanic much better if it was something you could plan for. My game also has some crazy momentum stuff in it so that was my favorite part by far. I also found it better to skip wall riding when possible since it actually slowed you down by quite a bit so i tried to maintain my momentum by skipping them. I read that you didnt get a chance to implement checkpoints, but I did get some crazy speeds and skip large sections of level 1 since I had to do it so many times so that was a cool side effect at least. |
| Oct 9 23:19:35 | 11m 29s | Give Me A Grin | ♥ 1 | Great job getting your first game jam done. I swear those dentist were locking on to me the first few attempts |
| Oct 9 23:38:19 | 18m 44s | Crystal Tower Luxogenics | ♥ 1 | The mirror defense was really fun. I managed to get to wave 21. It took me a bit to be able to figure out the rotation since I thought initially it was a key bind, but once I got that figured out I set up a nice defense. |
| Oct 11 02:00:13 | 26h 21m | Crown Crow | ♥ 3 | Movement felt great. It took me a few runs to realize what was happening, but i figured it out on my own. I like managed to beat it with only the first 4 upgrades since i didnt realize you could scroll until i got the crown, so probably made it a bit harder on myself. |
| Oct 11 02:29:34 | 29m 21s | The Collection Machine | ♥ 1 | Gameplay loop felt good. I think it would have been more interesting for the game to get a lot harder through the days. The first day i had to do 2 collections and once i wanted to see how the game ended there were still only 1 to 3 collections a day required and just doing those and putting the dangerous objects in was more than enough to sustain. Everything felt really smooth to play though great job |
| Oct 11 03:12:37 | 43m 03s | Trivia Hart in "The Case of the Porcelain Tricorn" | ♥ 1 | Great game. I have played a lot of the old point and click games from the 90s so glad there werent any crazy logic gaps like those ones lol. Voice acting is funny and the time mechanic was very interesting and intuitive to use. Very impressive for a compo entry. When you said "would you kindly" i did get a bioshock flashback so I thought i was about to do something terrible. I mean who would jump into a spike pit willingly... right. (i did do both endings) |
| Oct 11 03:38:21 | 25m 44s | Voltaic Harvest | ♥ 2 | Really solid gameplay. I really liked the lighting mechanic and it felt great to use. I do think it was pretty easy to get overwhelmed but they did not seem to do much damage. There is a lot of information overload in the beginning so the first run I forgot that I could shoot. |
| Oct 11 04:03:36 | 25m 15s | If I Ran the (Alien) Zoo | ♥ 1 | Great concept for the theme. Loved the art and audio and gameplay was smooth. It did occasionally get stuck sometimes and not bring up things, but resetting the beam seemed to do the trick. I would have played much longer if the quest were endless. |
| Oct 11 04:22:27 | 18m 51s | Ammonite Hunter | ♥ 1 | Nice relaxing game. Some of those were very hidden. I also experienced some movement jank. I did manage to dig straight down and then hug the wall to climb back up which was very efficient. |
| Oct 11 04:35:01 | 12m 34s | Styx of Souls | ♥ 1 | Loved the art and dialogue. I felt like most of the time you barely had to interact with the wings unless changing from fat to skinny so I wish it was more required or that you could mess up by using up all of your good or bad guys. I also like the random God of War requirement that gave me a good chuckle. |
| Oct 11 04:54:31 | 19m 30s | Recollections | ♥ 2 | Was not expecting a story and was very interested in it. I do like the variety in gameplay. Unfortunately the game kept closing the tab on the arms level and opening new tabs randomly so I was not able to beat that one, but I think I got towards the end of it. Wish I was able to finish as I expect there would have been another level with the whole skeleton. A downloadable version would have helped with that, but otherwise great entry |
| Oct 11 05:05:26 | 10m 55s | Debt Collector | ♥ 1 | I ran around like a mad man yelling Move Dammit to everyone. They seemed to be intimidated by that since I got the money from them. The only thing that I would have changed is the camera since it is inverted it broke my brain so I got into a spot I could see all the house when entering it and just used wasd to move around and didnt move the camera again. Super cool that you made this with your own engine. |