Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD58 → Feedback comment stats → johncast123
Feedback comments for LD58
johncast123's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | johncast123's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 7 00:45:52 | Mid-Sized Monsters | ♥ 2 | wow such a polished entry for something made in 48 hours that's so awesome! The landscape is the most impressive thing for me. | |
| Oct 7 00:54:11 | 8m 19s | Death Collector | ♥ 1 | I love the art! I do wish the controls were a little bit more sensitive (especially the jump) and it was a little difficult using the umbrella when it was at the s position. But great work yall!!! |
| Oct 7 01:05:41 | 11m 30s | A Lifelong Hobby | ♥ 1 | I love the art and I love the theme you incorporated. I used to collect cards too when I was young. I used to play a lot of Duel Masters, and back then it was the hottest card game. I think very fondly back on those times, but now that the game is considered outdated, I'll never relive those moments. A very bittersweet relationship indeed. Thank you for sharing your childhood with us :) |
| Oct 7 01:13:05 | 7m 24s | I Want to Have a Bike | ♥ 1 | Art is amazing, and I love the soundtrack. It has a really wistful, longing vibe to the game. It was a little frustrating having to go through the loading everytime I was punched by the guy haha I also glitched through the boundaries a few times and had to restart. Good stuff! |
| Oct 7 01:40:26 | 27m 21s | Cap Corp | ♥ 3 | This is my favorite game this jam so far!!! The art-style is amazing, the humor is humorous, and the puzzles are fun! I will say the flute player puzzle did frustrate me a little because I didn't know which key corresponded to which note lol |
| Oct 7 01:52:50 | 12m 24s | deck of doom | ♥ 1 | No way you made this in 12 hours! That's awesome. I love the crispness of everything. It's so good. I did find it hard to get cards that made a hand other than pair though. |
| Oct 7 02:16:37 | 23m 47s | Weather Collector | ♥ 1 | yo this is hella creative and lowkey addicting! Balancing is quite off but this is fun haha |
| Oct 7 07:28:49 | 5h 12m | Wishdom Teeth Pact | ♥ 2 | This is such a sick concept! So creative, and the art is stunning. I also chuckled at the wishes. A few too many papers/conditions come out and it felt a little less like a puzzle and more like a task list. But amazing still! |
| Oct 7 07:37:17 | 8m 28s | BulkUp | ♥ 1 | This is epic bro. The cutscenes are so funny and the alien at the end... Let's just say, I had a fun night XD jokessssss |
| Oct 7 07:56:59 | 19m 42s | Little Timmy, Big Dreams | ♥ 0 | haha I loved it. Nice to see a wario ware style fast paced game. Thanks for the experience :) |
| Oct 7 08:14:02 | 17m 03s | Plant Pack | ♥ 2 | This is insanely good for a compo entry. How even?? The visuals and mood go a long way, and you could totally do something with it. |
| Oct 8 08:48:07 | 24h 34m | Octrobat | ♥ 2 | This game has so much potential and I have some notes on how I really think you could improve the user experience because seriously I can see this being a killer platformer. I think the movement at the moment feels way too floaty, and the lack of sensitive movement (especially when just moving left to right, there is a lot of drag) makes precise movements feel sluggish. I think that was what mainly made me frustrated at certain levels (even though I seriously adore this game and the concept), because I just didn't get the user input that I wanted since it was so floaty. I also think that it would really be helpful to have an indicator which shows the range of how far your tentacle will reach, so you have an idea about what nodes you are in range of. I also think it'd be nice to have some way of salvaging your progress even if you are stuck at a single node because swinging back and forth doesn't really preserve that much momentum, so it feels really sad when you're just stuck at a node and have no choice but to restart. This is one of my favorite games I tried this jam and has a ton of potential. |
| Oct 8 08:54:37 | 6m 30s | Collectorogue | ♥ 2 | super interesting concept that is so unique! I think whilst the idea is really interesting, I feel what ends up happening is I'm so focused on just dumping stuff on the table that I never really paid attention to the battles. This is something that could definitely be expanded on. |
| Oct 8 09:00:15 | 5m 38s | Stamp Collector | ♥ 2 | This is a lovely game! The art style is such a standout and the vibes are so great. The only feedback I have is that some of the colors are really similar so I got tripped up a bit with yellow and beige. |
| Oct 8 09:10:46 | 10m 31s | To The End Of Time | ♥ 2 | Really cool stuff, so impressive that you did this in 72 hours man! |
| Oct 8 16:25:12 | 7h 14m | Collectore - Ludum Dare 58 | ♥ 1 | solid entry! I wish there was some instructions because I couldn't figure out if I wanted to just survive or if the goal was to collect all the letters |
| Oct 8 16:36:01 | 10m 49s | Enter the Cardgeon | ♥ 1 | Super cool and polished game man! I think there's so much you can expand on here, in terms of variety of enemies and making collecting the red cards have some incentive (risk vs reward factor). Super cool to have a game where you are building it as you go. Good job. |
| Oct 8 16:41:09 | 5m 08s | Rujum Jare | ♥ 1 | what a unique entry. amazing! |
| Oct 8 17:05:16 | 24m 07s | Fair Trade | ♥ 4 | Wow. This might be my favorite game from the jam. Only feedback is I wish I could see my deck when choosing the shop. |
| Oct 8 21:19:49 | 4h 14m | HarvestValley | ♥ 1 | SO ADDICTING. Something in our human nature to just collect stuff. It's why cookie clicker got so successful. Fun game! I wonder how you can further expand on the concept. I found my method for optimizing became just going to the sheep because it was closest to me. |
| Oct 9 07:03:08 | 9h 43m | Purarger Collector | ♥ 2 | This is so cute and creative!!! You somehow took this simple idea and made it so fun and enjoyable, and you do it all in an art style that I could look at all day. I envy the art skills greatly. Good job!!! ps: this is my first game jam, but I worked with someone who's been game jams for a while now and back in the day you commented on one of his previous entries. Ever since then you've been considered his GOAT and it would be so funny if I could surprise him with news that you commented on our entry this jam 😆 |
| Oct 9 07:18:22 | 15m 14s | Hop, Skip, Jump | ♥ 2 | This game is awesome!! How did you come up with this idea in 5 hours?? I'm so impressed with human talent man... I think the only issue is that I found the strategy I had was just to do trial and error, but I'm wondering if there is a way to make it more puzzle based. |
| Oct 10 04:58:47 | 21h 40m | Cluster Claw | ♥ 1 | Idea is so great! I really like the concept of building this overwhelming ship that can't be stopped. I did wish there was more control over placement of the weapons as well as more control of the firing (or maybe even make the bullets tracking). But great concept man! You should be proud :) |
| Oct 10 05:02:57 | 4m 10s | Planet Saver | ♥ 1 | Wall E! |