Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD52 → Feedback comment stats → Mcnuttys
Feedback comments for LD52
Mcnuttys's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Mcnuttys's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 9 03:57:55 | Reap What You Blow | ♥ 2 | I really like the whole office chair movement and the sucking/blowing thing. Unfortunately the WASD controls are WAY too clunky for this style of control and honestly even if you were to tweak it to make it snappier im not certain it would solve the problem. Did you try using mouse controls instead? Unless you intend for the player to have to spin then the ability to snap directions using the mouse would allow people to increase speed massively. Regardless really cool idea, I enjoyed the game until door closed on me xD. Good game! | |
| Jan 9 04:06:43 | 8m 48s | Gold Harvest | ♥ 0 | Liked the game, good ambience. Might be interesting to add a little flashlight effect so the direction your facing is slightly brighter just another little ambience thing. Might want to make it more obvious the range at which the ghosts are attracted. Regardless cool game! |
| Jan 10 03:57:18 | 23h 50m | Farming Rush | ♥ 0 | Pretty fun, gets a bit chaotic but I think that was the intention. Controls are a little floaty but otherwise good game! |
| Jan 10 04:19:36 | 22m 18s | Mineralia | ♥ 1 | Really nice game! The lighting was a bit odd as sometimes the actual lighting would illuminate a tile but it would still be too dark to place. Other then that it would be nice if there was some other way of moving the camera other then hitting the edge of the screen. As the maps not too large it works fine but the far edges are nice to scroll too. Regardless nice game I enjoyed it! |
| Jan 11 03:09:23 | 22h 49m | the farmer | ♥ 1 | Pretty cool game! Im not sure if its just me but all the game sounds were pretty quiet so it got pretty weird trying to kite an enemy that moved super slow and I couldn't really see. So I ended up leading him around and around INTO the plot I was trying to rescue xD. Perhaps he could lose attention at times and do a predetermined path? Might give more meaning to the various giant props. Otherwise cool game! |
| Jan 12 03:47:39 | 24h 38m | Moon Harvester | ♥ 1 | I really liked this game. I really only had one super minor issue with it, and that is that the camera doesnt follow the snake. Only reason I suggest this is because given the perspective at the top of the crater it can be somewhat difficult to gauge exactly where you are in relation to the resources. Given that your harvester doesn't take that much damage its not that big a deal but I just think it would be somewhat better. Regardless really nice game, I enjoyed it! |
| Jan 18 02:42:11 | 142h 54m | Late Harvest | ♥ 1 | Really liked the game! The seeking movement instead of direct movement was pretty interesting and diffidently changed up how you needed to kite. Only gameplay thing would be, given that you need to click zooming out would be nice as it feels a little claustrophobic but like somebody else said it might lose its charm. Maybe a little bigger would be nice. Regardless really cool game! |
| Jan 18 02:55:04 | 12m 53s | Harvest Hop | ♥ 1 | Really like the game, throwing potatoes is always entertaining. My only issues were that launching the potato was somewhat inconsistent or at least felt that way and that alot of the time the randomness of the maps just results in a single path to throw. Im not quite sure what could be done about the throwing other then simply throwing it at a bunch of testers and tweaking values, which isnt really possible in a game jam. As for the generation having fixed variants that it randomizes using might be one option. Regardless really liked the game! Could definitely see this as a mobile game. |
| Jan 18 03:08:17 | 13m 13s | Beet Island | ♥ 1 | Fun little kiting game! I think having little powerups or something drop from the cubes would be nice just to incentivize taking the risk of going into the groups to make the gameplay a little more risky then just doing laps which is what I ended up doing towards the end. Regardless really enjoyed it, good game! |
| Jan 18 03:22:07 | 13m 50s | Ramming into Trees | ♥ 1 | I really like the game, add onto the fact that the idea was hilarious and you have something cool. My only issue is that im unsure how I was gaining money beyond simply harvesting lemons. The signs gave me some instruction but I guess im misinterpreted it or something cause I never saw the locals I was supposedly selling too. Reading other comments I see now that you sell them too the stores themselves which makes sense. Maybe throw in a little effect for the lemon being sold or like a cha-ching sound effect for when they are sold. Regardless really cool game! |
| Jan 24 22:01:07 | 162h 39m | Aquaculture | ♥ 0 | I thought this game was very cool! Only odd thing is if water is pumped in on one side then the first plant immediately following it (if your pump rate is low enough) will consume it all. While I would imagine the water would spread evenly and was anticipating that. Once I figured what was causing it though it made sense. Regardless cool game! |
| Jan 24 22:09:35 | 8m 28s | Out of Time | ♥ 0 | Cool game, I really liked the models! Most of the other comments have covered my issues so I will try to add something new. Because the ghosts can stack onto of each other and there is no invulnerability frames you can lose all your sanity in an instant. Regardless cool game! |
| Jan 24 22:19:25 | 9m 50s | Star Harvest | ♥ 1 | Really like these chain reaction type games. My only issue with the game is that its not named... HarvestSTAR... Regardless really cool visuals and such, fun game! |
| Jan 26 02:18:16 | 27h 58m | Lunar Harvest | ♥ 0 | Pretty cool game! Only issue I got is I wanted to move lots of cows at a time and it felt a little odd you could only get one at a time given the size of the rings. Im not sure if thats intended but I think it would be much more hilarious if you could launch multiple cows around at a time if you take the effort to bunch them up. Regardless, liked the graphics, and your sound effects, nice game! |
| Jan 26 02:51:21 | 33m 05s | Ether Warp | ♥ 1 | I really like this game! The graphics and the audio are great! My only issues are very minor. First is that I have a little trouble with the rotation speed maybe tweaking the angular drag? Second is that when you collide with an asteroid your bounce is a little odd. I dont know the fix for this one if your already using a physics material other then mirroring your velocity over the normal of the collision Unity can be a little weird with circle bouncing against each other. Regardless super cool game I really enjoyed this one! |