Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD52 → Feedback comment stats → Martta
Feedback comments for LD52
Martta's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Martta's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 9 19:32:36 | Breaking Catnip | ♥ 2 | I am unable to play. I am getting this error message when the game is loading: "Unable to parse Build/buildWebGL1.framework.js.br! This can happen if build compression was enabled but web server hosting the content was misconfigured to not serve the file with HTTP Response Header "Content-Encoding: br" present. Check browser Console and Devtools Network tab to debug." | |
| Jan 9 20:19:03 | 46m 27s | Gene Harvesting | ♥ 0 | Either I am stupid, or the game is bugged. I read the insturctions carefully, tried to click any visible UI element with left-, right- and shift-click without any visible progress. Also there was no sound. I managed to get some progress with cheats, but I did not know what to do with the inventory items and I got frustrated. :( I am sure there is a game somewhere there, but I was unable to find it. |
| Jan 10 17:08:59 | 20h 49m | Elonkorjuu - Live Harvest | ♥ 1 | Onko mahdollista saada Web/Mac buildia? |
| Jan 10 17:17:45 | 8m 46s | Flower Dash | ♥ 1 | This is exactly the game I needed after long and stressful work day. :-) As others have said, this was relaxing and solid game. Good graphics, good controls, good sounds and music, good feedback, interesting mechanics (i really liked the double click mechanic, even though you did not need it necessarily). Only thing I would have added would be some 3 star system like in angry birds, for completing the levels with extra speed/low number of moves. Games like these could have endless number of levels, enemies etc, but I am glad that the game was short so that I could see the ending. Good Ludum Dare game does not need to be long. :-) |
| Jan 10 20:55:27 | 3h 37m | The Onion Quest | ♥ 2 | This game was great! If this game would have had sounds, it would have been my favourite game so far! Even some 8-bit "thump" sound for attack would have made the game 2 times better. You should check this page: https://sfbgames.itch.io/chiptone I think you should have dropped one of the vegetables and add 1 or 2 sound effects instead. But the gameplay was really good! I really like the FTL-style world map, random events, different kind of vegetables etc! This game is suprisingly feature rich and it kept suprising! Beat the game on my 2nd try, so the challenge was also fitted well for a ludum dare game, where you usually play every game for only few minutes. |
| Jan 11 16:04:22 | 19h 08m | Turmsoil | ♥ 1 | Little bit buggy, but I forgive you for making a true MMO game! Excellent! I wish people would make more games like this! I think there is no need to leave improvement ideas, as you already know what could be done better. Really impressive that you made online multiplayer! I think there were some bugs. Sometimes my money was changing. I was at 10 money, then it showed 7 money and then 10 again. Also after 10 minutes of playing the game, the game suddenly stopped working altogether and I was unable to get money from harvesting crops. |
| Jan 11 19:28:03 | 3h 23m | Soul Property: Who's Life is it Anyway? | ♥ 2 | Somewhat impressive graphics and game (3D requires always so much more work than 2D). I always give extra credit for making 3D during Ludum Dare! I really liked the main menu and the intro. And you had also great sounds, voice lines and music! The gameplay is little bit boring and basic, but I think that it is still a good game. |
| Jan 12 19:28:29 | 24h 00m | The Unidentified Flying Cat Burglars! | ♥ 1 | Cool game, but lacks polish. The controls vere not enjoyable. It was cool that the spacecraft had acceleration and lots of inertia, but it did not feel nice for me. Also the projectiles were annoyingly slow, which made killing enemies somewhat unsatisfactory. However, there were excellent music, good graphics and good all around implementation on all aspects of the game. I liked this game, especially the enemy fighters were cool. I wish there would have been some end goal, like collecting 100 cats or collect as many cats as you can in 1 minute or something like that. |
| Jan 13 15:47:41 | 20h 19m | Stealing for the Rocket | ♥ 0 | Is there mac version somehwere? |
| Jan 13 16:07:08 | 19m 27s | Anne & the Carrot Islands | ♥ 2 | Got stuck on the level 9 :D I tried it 10 times and then I had enough, I hate this kind of puzzle games (it is not your fault!). I think this is a good entry. Good music, graphics and mechanics, no apparent bugs and even little bit of story. Even though I am not fan of the genre, I think is a proper game! Not sure if I can give any tips how to improve it, it is well rounded and good experience. Maybe cheat codes that I can beat it and see the ending! :D I really liked the carrot animation for restarting level. |
| Jan 13 19:04:31 | 2h 57m | Money harvest | ♥ 1 | Well, this was compo game, so lack of polish can be forgiven. Maybe instead of choosing between all of the options all the time, there could have been a choice between random 2 actions. And maybe get rid of the timer. And maybe the effect would be shown only after you have chosen it, so that you can have time to think "hmm, how would scamming affect my family relations?" (and because the timer would be off, you would have the time to think about it). But now I am just listing things how to make this game just like Reigns... I am glad that you took the time to make music, but I think there could have been some little sound when pressing a button. Overall a good and impressive game for compo, although lacking some polish. |
| Jan 13 21:29:17 | 2h 24m | Highway Harvester | ♥ 1 | I really like the art style and music. The game is ok, but however unfinished. I dont know if you could have dropped some of the features so that you would have had enough time to finish the game with win/lose condition. Maybe the initial game idea was little bit too ambitious given the available resources? Maybe if the initial idea would have been simpler, the game would have been more polished? But congratulations for finishing your first Ludum Dare game!! Only ~50% teams are able to submit anything, but you managed! This year there were 3483 signups but only 1600 entries. |
| Jan 14 20:15:22 | 22h 46m | Galactic Garden | ♥ 3 | Played it 4 times and I was not able to finish it (I got places to be etc.). But I really enjoyed this game! This might be the best game I have reviewed! I really like the open world feel of the game, the complex features of the game etc etc. It had ok sound design, solid graphics, good controls and very impressive set of features. There was a strategy level involved in managing the energy and crops, but it was not too overwhelming as the enemies came in waves. I think best part of this game is the gampelay loop: Harvest seeds, fight, collect seeds, buy upgrades, fight, harvest crop... Only thing I really hated was the rotating asteroids and the short viewing distance. The asteroids were moving and rotating too fast which made them not very pleasant to look at and also it was rather difficult to keep track of them because some of them were moving so fast. Also the last few waves feeled really overwhelming, as next one came in before I was able to finish previous wave. I tried to use the nuke to destroy the Tree boss, but it was not very effective and instead drained the energy. I did not like the fact that the better weapons required energy (I can see what you were going after: some incentive to switch weapons). I think the game would have been better if none of the weapons would have consumed energy, and there would have been no option to switch to previous and inferior weapons. Thank you for making such a great game! |
| Jan 15 10:46:34 | 14h 31m | CVC Presents: Roberto Farmermun's Horrific Planting Adventure 2023 | ♥ 2 | This game was a rough ride. The learning curve was rather steep and I had to go back to the tutorial few times in order to understand what was going on. I think you should have made the game much, much simpler (or at least if you care about good scores, which are arguably irrelevant compared to the artistic process). I would have removed the different kind of attacks and plants (what was the point of them anyways?). I think there also is little to no need to ranged + melee attack, so melee attack could also be stripped away. If you would have tried to do less complex game, maybe you could have polished it little bit more. There were also lacking sound effects, which made me sad. :( I also agree that the day was too short for a game this complex, I was unable to figure out how to get more money/energy/health. With this game, less would have been more. The game has impressive number of features though and it is always more fun to add more features rather than polish and fix the existing ones. |