Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD48 → Feedback comment stats → Rovernoon
Feedback comments for LD48
Rovernoon's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Rovernoon's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 28 00:16:15 | Gregory`s Mine | ♥ 0 | **+**Great art and music **+**solid direction: almost everything contributed to the spooky atmosphere. **+**The thing on top of the elevator was a really nice touch. **-**The ambient flickering noise was a bit too clicky. maybe needs a low-pass filter? **-**too many dialog popups. could have floating "examine" text without the box and buttons **-**the minecart part didn't feel like it fit | |
| Apr 28 00:39:10 | 22m 55s | Egress | ♥ 3 | **+**good colors, high polish, clean ui **+**creative and consistent theme **+**cool screen effect **-**too much cool screen effect **-**combat too slow **-**clunky ux for managing programs & when they fight |
| Apr 28 01:10:03 | 30m 53s | Deeper & Deeper: Attorneys at Law | ♥ 1 | Good job, reminds me of Aviary Attorney **+** fun take on theme **+** the art and music fit the mood **+** good writing **-** Inconsistent UI; the first time I clicked "look around office" I thought the game had soft-locked **-** needs sound effects **-** variety in the text (e.g. bolding, colors) would be nice |
| Apr 28 01:30:54 | 20m 51s | CRASH Pit | ♥ 1 | **+** fun **+** satisfying sounds **+** upgrade screen drum loop **-** upgrade screen slow to navigate **-** explosions last too long **-** seems to freeze on scene change |
| Apr 28 04:37:09 | 3h 06m | Rooted | ♥ 1 | **+** creative take on the theme **+** great art and sound effects **+** the puzzles were fun to solve, the mole is a nuisance **-** easy to mess up with accidental key-presses **-** entry into cursor mode is sometimes jarring **-** some of the text was hard to read Very nice, keep it up! |
| Apr 28 05:09:39 | 32m 30s | Deep Dig Pizza | ♥ 3 | **+** excellent audio and visuals, high polish **+** lots of flavor, great take on the theme **+** it's a pizza planet and the ufo is spinning to dig for basil leaves and pepperoni **-** I often wanted to dig while in the air **-** The "complete pizza" buttons seemed mostly unnecessary **-** The hitboxes for ingredients could be slightly bigger Incredible entry! |
| Apr 28 05:35:42 | 26m 03s | A Taste of the Past | ♥ 1 | **+** lovely art and music **+** lots to think about **+** thematically consistent **-** The menu buttons were hard to make out from the background **-** sometimes it was tough to find the next thing to interact with **-** animations (e.g. walking) would be much nicer with only a couple extra frames Very well done! |
| Apr 28 06:04:16 | 28m 34s | Diggillion | ♥ 1 | **+** nice music and mining sound effect **+** cool fine-grained procedural generation + better ores lower in the map fits theme **+** charming pixel art **-** it felt a little tedious to dig tunnels wide enough to move through **-** I was hoping to find something at the bottom **-** I wanted an easier way to go back up Great start, lots of potential! |
| Apr 28 06:08:42 | 4m 26s | The Tourist | ♥ 1 | The visual style is great and reminds me of "The Witness" |
| Apr 28 21:30:54 | 15h 22m | Fever Dream | ♥ 2 | **+** Good sound and stylish visuals, nice variety in areas **+** good tutorial section **+** fun to go fast **-** Sometimes it seemed to slow down for no reason, breaking my vibe **-** In the "indoors" part it started going backwards and I flew out of the map **-** I felt the need to hold boost down all the time, perhaps a slow-down button instead? Great entry overall |
| Apr 28 21:44:57 | 14m 03s | Conspiracy Dive | ♥ 3 | **+** creative use of theme **+** funny and entertaining puzzles **+** I want to believe **-** I wanted to waddle faster **-** Those dudes running off blasted me with footsteps **-** It could use a bit more content & sound effects for interactions Short but good at what it's going for! |
| Apr 28 22:15:54 | 30m 57s | I Stole a Wizard's Sack and All I Got Was This Lousy Infinite Pocket Universe | ♥ 2 | **+** creative take on theme **+** good art and fitting music **+** clever puzzles **-** the lofi noise is a bit too clicky **-** I wanted an easier way to track which bag I was in **-** could use some more easing-in levels or text prompts for certain concepts (e.g. the bag loop) Love the entry. A "fractal puzzle" like this was one of my favored ideas going into the jam, but I couldn't find a fun spin on it. You succeeded at that. |
| Apr 28 23:21:28 | 1h 05m | Deepspace | ♥ 1 | **+** the music is really good **+** the hand-drawn art style worked well **+** Position-based effects in your equipment were cool **-** combat turns felt slow, and I wanted more feedback on when stuff happens in them **-** I often wanted to drag and drop instead of clicking **-** Some of the buyables were a little too good Best compo graph game I've seen so far |