Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD48 → Feedback comment stats → Madorly
Feedback comments for LD48
Madorly's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Madorly's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 4 02:57:22 | Tropical Singer | ♥ 0 | Nice adaptation of the theme, really innovative! It's also super impressive that you manage to make such a long rythm game all alone in 48 hours, you can be proud of yourself! I really like the landscape changing gradually as I progress through all the levels, such a nice touch :) The story was a bit silly, I loved it! Going through all the body parts was a bit confusing at first but it really emphasize the "going deeper" concept in my opinion, nice touch! However, the music at the very beginning of the game was way too loud for me, and too high pitched :/ Also, the first levels were a bit too easy and/or repetitive to me, maybe you could change the pacing of the notes to make these levels more interesting? Having more and more notes was a great idea to increase difficulty, it got quite challenging for me in the last levels! I could not reach the end of the game though, it was getting too long for me D: (I didn't expect it to last this long, super impressive for a game jam game!), I went to the Left Kidney level I believe. I really like the graphics (felt like vacation!), however I think the keys we had to press did not really match the style of the rest of the game. Maybe changing them to a more "pixellated" version could improve the consistency of your game? Also, I think it would be nice to add some features to add more dynamism during a level, like combo or bonuses, maybe? I'm not that familiar with rythm game in general, sorry I cannot be more precise! Once again, good job on your entry :) | |
| May 6 01:10:33 | 46h 13m | Well, that sounds fun! | ♥ 0 | I really like the game, god job! The art is really simple yet beautiful and effective. The controls are super intuitive and the ennemies are well design. I don't have much more to say, honestly. I didn't manage to reach the bottom, I need some more training! |
| May 6 01:28:19 | 17m 46s | Madness Inc. | ♥ 1 | Nice entry! It was quite challenging for me since it's not really the kind of game I'm used to play, but I really enjoyed it! The graphics and sound design are effective, turning the screen slightly in red when you have only one life left was a great idea! Good job :) |
| May 6 01:45:54 | 17m 35s | Deep Blue | ♥ 1 | I really liked the game, such a cool ambiance! The graphics, the music and the sound design worked really well together, the lighting was stunning! I really enjoyed my dive, good job! I had some trouble understanding when the fishes will attack me (did they spot me with my flashlight or something else?) but it didn't prevent me finishing the game. |
| May 6 02:39:02 | 53m 08s | Depth of Memory | ♥ 0 | I loved your game so much! The puzzles were clever and I loved to search through the doctor's belongings. I didn't manage to unlock the phone or to get the answer to the bronze, silver and gold equation but I found all the memories so I'm really happy about it! the music was quite discret but nice, and the graphics were pretty effective. Nice job! |
| May 6 03:01:29 | 22m 27s | HELL deep is your love? | ♥ 5 | I loved the game! It was quite challenging for me since it's not the kind of game I'm used to play but I had a really great time playing it! The music was really nice, I liked the fact that it evolved with my progression in the game. The art style was really beautiful, overall the game had a great visual and audio consistency! I will try to reach the bottom of the hell pit next time, but once again you guys did an amazing job :) |
| May 6 03:26:16 | 24m 47s | PANEMUAN | ♥ 1 | What a sweet game, I really loved it! The art style was really nice, simple but effective and cute. The music was quite soft and calming, really fitting for the ambiance of the game. I'm not sure I understood exactly what was the monster at the beginning that was chasing us, but I was really moved by the scene at the school. I'm glad I follow the flowers :) Good job! |
| May 13 00:40:09 | 165h 13m | RogueRally | ♥ 2 | I really enjoyed the game, the graphics were quite simple but pretty, and the controls were really intuitive. I had some trouble seeing the grid sometimes, maybe making it brighter would have helped? It was also a bit tricky for me to differentiate destructible walls from other walls. One thing that I would love to have is a way to tell how well we did on each level (how many turns it took us to complete the level, the optimal number of turns,...), although I understand it could be difficult to implement with random commands. Overall it was a really nice game, good job on your team! |
| May 13 01:04:03 | 23m 54s | UnderwOtter | ♥ 1 | I had fun playing the game, although it was a bit challenging for me! I couldn't beat the game, I'm wondering if it's because I didn't choose the right order to buy the items. The graphics were quite simple but I really liked the colors, so soft! The "fisherdragon" looked so nice too! The sound effects were really effective, having a nice music while playing whould have been cool but I know that 48 hours is pretty short for that! Overall it was a really nice entry, good job! |
| May 13 01:22:09 | 18m 06s | Bubbly | ♥ 2 | What a nice game! I really liked the graphics and music, it was really feating and gave a great mood to the whole game. The difficulty was a bit high for me, I could get a score over 93! The fact that the spiders were following me accross plateforms was really tricky, I think it would work better if they stay at the same depth once they appear. Having to get your particules back each time you throw it was also a bit teadious. Once again, a really nice game, just a bit too difficult for me. Good job on your team! |
| May 13 01:40:28 | 18m 19s | Find The Page! | ♥ 1 | That was a really unexpected concept! It worked really well and was quite fun, good job! Although I had a small problem on my first playtrough: the game started at the level 2, and I'm pretty it skipped another level (the one from Game Jam to Ludum Dare). Apart from that, it was well executed, the timer and clicks limit were enough to make it challenging. Good job! |
| May 13 01:51:20 | 10m 52s | Dig Dog! | ♥ 1 | It was a fun game, really simple but addictive! The art style is cute, the music was nice, just a little too loud for me. I don't have much suggestions to offer, just maybe to add more diversity in the levels? Like different kind of objects to grab, or maybe some ennemies along the way. But it's a really fine entry as it is, so good job! |
| May 13 02:16:08 | 24m 48s | L.D. Noire: Down the Rabbit Hole | ♥ 1 | What an interesting game! The concept was really innovative and fun, and those headlines were so cheesy! The art style is a bit rough, and I had some difficulty to see eveything (let's that after some time, my board was just a giant red and green spaghetti plate). Also some images were out of the screen for me (the one that says "you're not quite there yet, keep looking" or something like that), so I was not sure what I did wrong. Now I'm really curious to know who did that awful thing to Tony Hawk... I hope I will find the culprit one day! Good job :) |
| May 18 01:25:27 | 119h 09m | Dahla's Journey | ♥ 1 | I loved your game so so much! The cutscene at the beginning was really intriguing, and what an ambiance!! The music is really effective, the graphics are beautiful. I didn't unsderstand how the ennemis were supposed to move, I guess it was random? Either way, I managed to find some kind of strategy to progress through the levels, so that's fine for me! I don't have much to suggest, you did a really fine job here, congrats! |
| May 18 01:31:01 | 5m 34s | Falling apart | ♥ 1 | I really liked the atmosphere and the concept of the game. The graphics were so nice, I just wish there were some mucis or soudn effect! Good job on your team, it was a really unique and interesting experience! |
| May 18 01:48:42 | 17m 41s | Deep Cover | ♥ 2 | What a nice game, I loved it so much! The story was really interesting, the gameplay was nice and fun, and those graphics! I loved them! It reminded me of a table game. Just a little thing, I found it a bit strange that the main character was a waiter in all the game, but oeverall it was a really nice game. Good job on the team! ETA: the tutorial was really effective and simple, good job! |
| May 18 01:57:42 | 9m 00s | Air-O-Space | ♥ 2 | That was a unique game for sure! Sorting the aliens while breathing was a really innovative gameplay idea, I really liked the graphics, the music and ambiance, the aliens sound effects were really cute! However, I just couldn't multitask at all xD so I didn't get really far into the game. I also had trouble understanding how breathing was suppose to work. I'm guessing the fact that the screen got darker and darker while my commandant (?) was talking to me at the beginnin didn't help. (I played on the web version, I don't know if it chages anything). Good job on your entry! |
| May 19 00:57:28 | 22h 59m | Mindcraft 2: Robe Squadron | ♥ 1 | I like the idea, it's really innovative! I just had trouble get past 3 ir 4 followers, maybe my thougts weren't so deep after all ^^' |
| May 19 01:10:49 | 13m 21s | Masseuse you Loose | ♥ 3 | What a fun and original game, I loved it! It had a great variety of gameplay with all those massages to perform, and it was quite challenging. Acupentur was my favorite of all time! |
| May 19 01:17:02 | 6m 13s | Under The End | ♥ 0 | You did a really nice game here! It has so many tools and the digging mechanism worked so well. However I didn't manage to go really far, I was unable to build a new power station. I'm guessing I'm missing something obvious, don't know what though. I really liked the ambiance of the game, really surreal and creepy. Nice job! |