Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD48 → Feedback comment stats → Ilyas Aqil
Feedback comments for LD48
Ilyas Aqil's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Ilyas Aqil's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 27 07:48:06 | Deep molatoes | ♥ 2 | Nice game! I found the mechanics of the game very interesting to play around with, it's quite innovative in that sense. I would have appreciated a tutorial of some kind but I understand it's hard to do that in a Jam, and also some sort of goal to work towards, maybe a small trophy once you hit 1000 coins or something. That being said, I enjoyed your game very much! | |
| Apr 27 11:27:53 | 3h 39m | Search and Resque | ♥ 1 | Very cool game! The digging was pretty fun to play around with, and there's some very nice puzzles with solutions that balance being evident and challenging at the same time. I think, however, the laser mechanic is a bit unnecessary and the buttons for the doors could have simply been buttons. Overall, a very cool concept well executed. |
| Apr 27 11:37:33 | 9m 40s | Deep Seeker | ♥ 0 | Same as a lot of commenters here, I'm struggling to understand exactly how to play the game. Not sure what I'm supposed to do with "chiral compounds". I think you could improve this by having a guide to what all the programming bits do, as well as maybe some kind of indication about how the cells work and when they are destroyed/alive? This is a potentially very interesting game unfortunately held back by poor graphic design and bad theming |
| Apr 27 11:56:35 | 19m 02s | Search for the Quacken | ♥ 1 | Overall a very well made game, very well polished and focused. I enjoyed your application of the theme, and the gameplay loop of collect in shallow water -> purchase equipment -> go deeper makes for an engaging enough time. I think my main criticism would be that it takes too long, I feel, to get enough money to buy a submersible to go deeper. On a smaller note, I was a bit confused about collecting the black orbs for money, maybe it would be better if they were a more attractive texture. Overall, a solid game |
| Apr 27 15:29:36 | 3h 33m | H.M.S. Rustbucket | ♥ 4 | Very nice co-op game! The gameplay is definitely much improved with a friend coming along! Me and a roommate enjoyed it very much, and the art is super cute and well polished |
| Apr 27 15:41:07 | 11m 31s | Sonder (a story) | ♥ 4 | I loved this game so much! Environmental storytelling at it's best. You've really succeeded in evoking that feeling of Sonder™. The art style is I think the best part, the warm browns with fresh green highlights really help make the game feel so intimate. A great look into a part of someone's life that feels very real. And the audio, even if a little bare, helps to make all the memories that much more tangible. Wish it was longer! |
| Apr 27 15:51:02 | 9m 55s | Debate Time | ♥ 2 | Great design combined with snappy gameplay! I think the design of the UI and the cards is definitely the strongest point of this game. However, I did get a little bit bored with the main combat after a while. The enemies are a little bit too similar, it would be nice if you could see them playing cards as opposed to just dropping your health. But I did really enjoy the humour in the card's text. |
| Apr 27 16:12:31 | 21m 29s | Deep in hell | ♥ 4 | Probably the best art I've seen yet in the entirety of LD48. The pastel style is great at blending light and shadow for that noir look. The text animations are great as well. The story could use a bit of work, I found the twist to be out of nowhere, but overall a very well put together game |
| Apr 27 16:29:23 | 16m 52s | Down the Mines and Ghosts | ♥ 1 | Interesting way of scaling up the difficulty, the gameplay mechanics are definitely extremely innovative. I'm not such a pro gamer :( so I could only make it to level 23 before it got too hard for me. I don't really have much to say about how this game could be improved, maybe have new enemy types? But overall, very cool game, and the 3d elements are especially well polished. Everything just works |
| Apr 27 16:46:48 | 17m 25s | 20.000 LIGHT YEARS deep in THE SKY | ♥ 3 | Amazing idea, the variety of planets really enhances the replay value; I can honestly say that this is the first game of Ludum Dare that made me go "Wow that was amazing, I want to try it again and see what else there is!" The humour works very well too, the astronaut has a lot of personality (and a great accent). The art is very charming and works so well together. This is definitely one of my top games of LD48 |
| Apr 27 16:56:46 | 9m 58s | Rodirroc | ♥ 3 | A very nice atmosphere, the dense impenetrable fog really adds to the mood. I have to admit I had trouble finding any of the skulls before I eventually found one |
| Apr 27 17:19:09 | 22m 23s | Burst Vein | ♥ 4 | I guess I can't be surprised that someone else would have a game about unions in mines, great minds think alike after all! Jokes aside this is an amazing game, the atmosphere is great. My favourite part is how small the player character is in relation to everything, really enjoyed jumping about on the shelves like the tiny goblin you are. It helps to set the mood very effectively. I noticed in the hall leading up to the elevator the lighting with the two torches was a bit messy, but overall the low-poly graphics style was really cool, lo-fi horror is the best. The transition from mystery into horror with the one way elevator was great as well, really cool stuff |
| Apr 27 22:08:56 | 4h 49m | Foundations | ♥ 1 | At first, I wasn't sure if the architecture of the game would send me in a loop, but then I realised how well crafted the game world was for it to have such an intuitive path structure even when everything looks the same. The art style is simple, but not simplistic. The short LOD really enhances the feeling of living in the moment, the past and future dissolving away. Great use of audio static to guide navigation. |
| Apr 27 22:41:45 | 32m 49s | Nuclear Arms 8: Navigate the Hate | ♥ 3 | Surprisingly mechanically challenging, but the satisfaction of shooting a bear in the face is incomparable. Killbane is a great character, and I'm now going to go binge the last 7 nuclear arms games |
| Apr 27 22:57:55 | 16m 10s | Deep Below Ground | ♥ 1 | I love the idea of an infinite game which still has a compelling backstory. The way the narrative is interwoven is pretty great. The spells are pretty responsive and fun to use, I love games which let you experiment with their systems. If I had to change one thing, it's that I think you should try and make a version of the game which is playable in the web. I had to download a Java IDE to play the game, but I didn't mind since it was fun! |
| Apr 28 18:01:00 | 19h 03m | Depths of Mind | ♥ 3 | Nice art! I enjoyed the humour in the job searching minigame, and the use of tasks appearing and disappearing to show what it's like to deal with depression is pretty clever. I also like the somewhat hopeful ending, very relatable and touching as well |