Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD41 → Feedback comment stats → Samusoidal

Samusoidal

Feedback comments for LD41

Samusoidal's games and stats for all events →

Timestamp	Since previous	Game		Samusoidal's comment
Apr 26 13:39:36		Rapid Fire	♥ 2	Well, as others have said, it could have used more polish; but I understand you were really trying hard just to get it out on time. - The graphics were really good! I liked the main character and he fit in the world really well. - Some feedback (a sound effect or a screen flash) might have been good so that the player knows when he's been hit, and having a jump height based on how long you hold the spacebar and not based on your velocity would have been a better system (in my opinion). @pebkac nailed the hard bits of the design. - The music was very reminiscent of those classic SNES RPGs, good pick there! - I liked the level design, it was intuitive and easy to navigate, though it could have used a little more variety in textures (I think). I had a lot of fun playing it, good job!
Apr 26 13:49:17	9m 41s	Fishing With Mr Bear	♥ 1	I like the concept a lot! The randomizers did seem a little unfair but 🤷 Here's a couple other things: - The lighting was pretty good but the graphics in general were fairly basic. I know compo in 3D is really hard though 🙂 - The bear was funny! It scared me the first time but then it just got funny. @niterich nails it in terms of gameplay increasing suspense. - It didn't seem like catching fish actually made Mr. Bear happy? Or maybe that was just me. Overall it was a good concept and fun to play. Good job!
Apr 26 13:57:31	8m 14s	Impossible Car Game	♥ 0	That was fun! I especially liked the music and humor. "Hint: Hints are useless. That's canon!" I made to ~80 seconds on my second run. I'll echo @Bookworm31 here as he has the same impressions as me: ``` Neat game! It’s an interesting concept and fun to play. I didn’t get a chance to try out the LAN arena, but that sounds really cool. Also, the music was amazing! The only thing that kinda bugged me was the edges of the infinite track; they were super unforgiving. Overall, really cool game! ``` Good job!
Apr 26 14:04:18	6m 47s	Bullet Break	♥ 1	Oh no, clowns! - I wasn't able to get very far. The sheer _impossibleness_ of keeping balls alive was a little much. - The music was very reminiscent of the Spore Spawn from Super Metroid (my favorite game). I liked it. - I have to give you points for theme: you truly combined two incompatible genres, and came up with a workable idea. It just needed more tweaking and polish. Overall, good job! Ludum Dare is a difficult challenge anyway and the ideas that came out of this theme were very difficult to pull off in time.
Apr 26 14:09:21	5m 03s	Invitris	♥ 1	I actually like this a lot and I have no complaints! Graphics were good, music was fun, and as @lerg said, it would be great on mobile. Once you get the hang of it it's really fun! Good job!
Apr 27 03:31:32	13h 22m	Jeff From Accounting	♥ 0	I really enjoyed playing this one! It was a little difficult at first to get the words right but I quickly got the hang of it. I wish it was a little bit longer, though. The graphics were excellent and the music fit right in. Theme interpretation was spot on, and the humor was hilarious. Good job!
Apr 27 03:37:07	5m 35s	ACCIDENTAL EXISTENTIAL	♥ 1	Wow... that was deep 😄 The graphics were excellent and the narrative was well put. The music was a little harsh but maybe that's just me. The themes of the narrative were so true to real life. This is a work of art. Good job!
Apr 27 03:43:29	6m 22s	F.P.S - Frootz per Second	♥ 2	Moore frootz pleez! That was addicting, clever, and a unique interpretation of the theme. Good job!
Apr 27 03:49:15	5m 46s	Speeddating	♥ 2	That was funny! I love the concept and the art and writing were spot on. It could have used some sound, though. Good job!
Apr 27 03:56:53	7m 38s	-Limits- By: Sharks	♥ 1	Well, for 12 hours, it's a good start. I thought the premise and the lines were funny. On the low-end PC setting the graphics loaded in a strange way that made it a little hard to look at. There also weren't that many objectives and I got to the end in a minute or two. I'd like to see what this would have looked like if it you had been able to put more time into it.
Apr 27 04:03:54	7m 01s	Late Night Shopping	♥ 1	Almost! Late Night Shopping by Kciwsolb - Mozilla Firefox.jpg I liked the graphics in this one a lot, and it was fun to play. Sound design was excellent as well. Good job!
Apr 27 04:33:02	29m 08s	Swimming and Strangling a guy	♥ 0	This caught my eye due to the Seinfeld reference... I thought the concept was hilarious! The gameplay itself was a little bland, there didn't seem to be much skill involved in winning. I completely understand that it's unfinished, I just wanted to play. Take all this with a grain of salt. JerrySeinfeld-trans-300x229.png
Apr 28 03:22:29	22h 49m	Don't look at Greg	♥ 0	That's creepy... Good entry! I liked the premise and Greg kind of creeped me out 😱 The sound design was great as well, it kept me on the edge of my seat in suspense.
Apr 28 17:44:38	14h 22m	BlowScape	♥ 3	The gameplay was confusing at first and the controls weren't very intuitive... but overall that's the only gripe I have with this game. The graphics were good and the music kept the suspense and sense of urgency up through the whole playthrough. The 'platformer' element seemed to be present only in the jumping, but it was a very challenging theme this time around. Excellently scoped and overall well polished entry. Good job!
Apr 28 17:48:48	4m 10s	Haiti Kitty	♥ 1	Charming graphics! I like the music as well and the gameplay was concise and easy to understand (besides the baseball one, it took me two tries). Overall, good job! It was fun to play and had me laughing the whole time!
Apr 28 18:01:30	12m 42s	Similize the Savages	♥ 1	😆 I love this one! The music and art fit very well with it and the gameplay was extremely addicting. After the first few robots I went around killing all the scientists! I never got to 100 population but it was fun to play anyways. Good job!
Apr 28 18:10:42	9m 12s	1st / 3rd Last Word	♥ 3	I feel like the idea has potential, but it wasn't polished enough to be very fun. I had a very difficult time aiming the gun when I couldn't stand directly behind it, and there wasn't much feedback in things like the gun getting too hot, which would have made it much easier to play. I'd be interested in a post-jam version if you're going to make one, though.
Apr 28 18:58:13	47m 31s	Duality	♥ 1	That's extremely hard single player! It was a good concept but needed some polishing, in my opinion.
Apr 28 19:01:40	3m 27s	PizzaBrawl	♥ 1	The gameplay is extremely difficult for me, but I liked the graphics a lot. It could have used some audio, but it was a good concept overall. Good job!
Apr 28 19:13:34	11m 54s	Ratty's Stew: An Immersive Cooking Simulation	♥ 2	I enjoyed playing this one! The graphics were quite good, and the level design was intuitive and easy to navigate. The physics were a little buggy, I found my self getting hit by bugs a little too often, and the music was a very short loop that grated after a little bit. The cooking sim part of the game didn't seem to be there besides collecting the ingredients, but I couldn't think of any better way to do it. Overall, good job!
Apr 28 19:17:15	3m 41s	Dancing Bandit	♥ 1	Definitely a good prototype. I found it to be very hard and slow, but the graphics were good and the concept was solid. Good job!
May 3 00:18:54	101h 01m	Math Drag Racer - First Ludum Dare and First Game Ever.	♥ 1	First off, good job on completing your first Ludum Dare! I liked the concept that you had, I would have liked to see it a bit longer (only two questions get me to the end) and with more variety. I understand you only had 72 hours but I have to critique honestly 😉 The music was a good choice if a little grating after a bit. The graphics were consistent and not distracting from the gameplay. Overall, good job!
May 5 15:27:47	63h 08m	clickjumper	♥ 0	I liked the concept and graphics in this one. The gameplay was fluid and the level design was exceptional. Plus it's always fun to see games made in Blender (which I started out in, and still prefer for 3D games). Good job!