Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD34 → Feedback comment stats → Ithildin
Feedback comments for LD34
Ithildin's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Ithildin's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 14 12:26:00 | Threads | Love the minimalistic visuals. Combined with audio you could create a really nice, relaxing mood. Game mechanics are also interesting once you get the gist of it. <br/> <br/>Very good job, congrats! :) | |
| Dec 14 12:31:00 | 5m 00s | Electric Dodgeball | Awesome concept! Trying to coordinate both sides is really challenging and fun. <br/> <br/>The background effect with the noise is also very cool when you see it in movement, with fitting colours for the balls and the middle area it might feel pretty trippy. <br/> <br/>Well done! |
| Dec 14 12:38:00 | 7m 00s | Crazy Tornado City | I love the moment you tear apart your first office building. It feels like victory n_n <br/> <br/>Awesome job for just one day, you've managed to fit both themes with a cool concept. Congrats!! :D |
| Dec 14 12:47:00 | 9m 00s | Shroom's | Awesome art style, I loved the death particle effect. <br/> <br/>Gameplay was simple and functional, I liked the progressive unlock of game mechanics. As some people have already mentioned, there is a bug with the moving platforms not transferring the movement to the player, and I was frequently having the developer console show NullPointerReferences. <br/> <br/>Good job! :) |
| Dec 14 13:01:00 | 14m 00s | Walden: Thoreau It All Away | I was attracted by the title. Visuals and sound effects are very nice. <br/> <br/>Gameplay wise, I had little input on my actions except for the time passing (kudos for the day/night cycle, by the way :)) and the heart depleting/filling up. For example, I could go to work at 1 AM and it made no difference. I'm unsure if that was intentional as a metaphor of modern life or I just lost my patience too soon and there was more to it. <br/> <br/>However, as I said before, I really appreciate the idea and aesthetics, well done! |
| Dec 14 13:25:00 | 24m 00s | Digicross | Ants ate my screen T_T <br/> <br/>Very cool idea! It took me some time to grasp the controls, but when you do the game is really fun. And graphics are really nice as well. <br/> <br/>I'm missing some sound effects when you reveal a tile, I'm sure it would feel pretty rewarding. <br/> <br/>Great job! :) |
| Dec 14 13:32:00 | 7m 00s | Lifenodes. | Lovely! <br/> <br/>Nice art and very interesting take on the theme, it's cool to see where the different choices lead to. |
| Dec 14 15:31:00 | 1h 59m | Can't Jump | I appreciate the challenge, the concept is simple but clever, and it fits the theme well. However, there are some glitchy bumps due to the physics on moving platforms, which increase the already high difficulty. <br/> <br/>By the way, on the web link it says the game has been removed by the author and can't be played. Will you reupload the game to Newgrounds? |
| Dec 14 15:38:00 | 7m 00s | Play with Dog or Cat | This is so cute! :D <br/> <br/>I love the detail of the cat becoming jealous when you play with the dog. Congratulations on your first entry! |
| Dec 14 15:43:00 | 5m 00s | Grown with the Flow | I like the movement of the polen particles (it works wonderfully with the music to create a melancholic vibe), but boy it's hard to click on them! :S |
| Dec 14 17:01:00 | 1h 18m | ..and the mooncats | Brilliant take on the theme. The control scheme is unusual but it works beautifully. You nailed the game mechanics, it totally feels like an old school game. Graphics and sound also contribute a lot and they shape an eerie mood. <br/> <br/>Congratulations! |
| Dec 14 17:04:00 | 3m 00s | BOOST | I'm glad you managed to fix your issues with the Unity builds in the end, the game is really awesome! <br/> <br/>Cool and challenging take on the theme, slick visual style and great sound, too. :D |
| Dec 14 17:07:00 | 3m 00s | Switcher | Very cool idea! <br/> <br/>I'm still feeling really clumsy coordinating the ships and the intersections, but mastering that is where the fun is. Good job! |
| Dec 14 17:16:00 | 9m 00s | Attack Of The Radioactive Octopus From A Planet Near Mars | Great entry!! It fits both themes perfectly, and it's really fun to play, although I got a bit lost with the controls for a few seconds the first time I spawned a new tentacle. <br/> <br/>Amazing job! :) |
| Dec 14 17:24:00 | 8m 00s | Famous Bus Movie Game | Awesome idea! Graphics are very nice (but too strong for my tired eyes >_<), and mechanics are really fun. <br/> <br/>One thing...when I crashed the Unity console opened and began tracing physics-related exceptions. It didn't prevent me from playing, though. |
| Dec 14 17:30:00 | 6m 00s | Munchy Munchers | Very solid entry! From the theme to the graphics and, of course, gameplay, you've managed to create a really good game. Congrats! |
| Dec 14 17:35:00 | 5m 00s | The Star War | Sounds and graphics were hilarious :D Like others, it reminded me of agar.io or the first stage on Spore, but the not-star-wars theme made me chuckle. |
| Dec 14 21:48:00 | 4h 13m | Germicide | Great idea, and execution was very solid. Congrats! |
| Dec 14 21:57:00 | 9m 00s | Super Lefty Garden Fighty | Fun and very polished, a great entry! |
| Dec 14 22:06:00 | 9m 00s | Revenge of the Ducks | Concept is hilarious :D <br/> <br/>The game is fitting and I liked the visuals, but it was a bit hard to understand the feedback if you were hitting or being hit. |
| Dec 14 22:24:00 | 18m 00s | U.G.O | Very polished! I really like the graphics and the animations. Sync'ing the attack delays adds some challenge, too. <br/> <br/>Great job! |
| Dec 14 22:28:00 | 4m 00s | Turnips-n-Pigs | I'm getting warnings from Avira about a trojan when I try to download the game. Could it be a false positive? |
| Dec 14 22:32:00 | 4m 00s | Alien Number Attack | Great concept! I like how new numbers are slowly introduced and the inclusion of arithmetic operations. Well done! |
| Dec 14 22:51:00 | 19m 00s | Grow | The idea is pretty cool, and the atmosphere defined by the visuals and music is very nice, but at the beginning it is a bit unclear what to do, and some initial states are irresolvable (perhaps you're actually making sure of that and this was just me before I figured out how to place tris). Also, there are some memory issues, I got an "out of memory" WebGL error. <br/> <br/>You still have time, so if you can solve those issues you can have a solid entry. |
| Dec 15 21:06:00 | 22h 15m | Dead Man's Volley | Wow, this is one of the best entries I've seen so far (and it's a compo entry, that scores double on my book!). Everything from the visuals to audio to (of course) game mechanics looks incredibly polished. <br/> <br/>Congratulations, I'm impressed! :D <br/> <br/>And now back to defeat that stupid Shadowdancer! >_< |
| Dec 15 21:26:00 | 20m 00s | Dandelion | Controls feel a bit awkward, and there seems to be some minor freezes when the game restarts, but the concept is nice and graphics are lovely. Well done! |
| Dec 15 21:30:00 | 4m 00s | Snow World | Wow, this is a great entry. Graphics are very polished, audio fits the game and combat gameplay, besides fitting the two-button theme, has a very classical JRPG feeling. Congrats! |
| Dec 15 21:39:00 | 9m 00s | The Serpent's Shadow | I love the take on the Snake game and how it fits the theme. Well done! |
| Dec 15 22:14:00 | 35m 00s | MILK TEETH | I'm getting the creeps when I pull :S:S:S <br/> <br/>Very interesting concept, well done! |
| Dec 15 22:22:00 | 8m 00s | Get to the Points | Great idea! When I saw the screenshots I thought the game might be hard to grasp but it's actually the opposite, easy to get and very fun to play. Good job! |
| Dec 15 22:28:00 | 6m 00s | Don't Mess With Totems | I love this one, the visuals are just beautiful, and the mechanics are great: simple, they really fit the theme and they're challenging. I also appreciated the humorous touches, congratulations for a solid entry! :D |
| Dec 15 22:35:00 | 7m 00s | Lands of TSR Lore | I really enjoyed the graphics, and the concept, even if it doesn't fit either of the themes. <br/> <br/>However, gameplay-wise it was a bit lacking, so I'd say it would be premature to take it to Kickstarter in its current state. Keep working at it to improve it, as it does look promising. |
| Dec 15 22:41:00 | 6m 00s | Tale Of Two Buttons | The Webplayer build works fine, but the WebGL one is crashing on Chrome :S <br/> <br/>Graphics and audio are lovely, but unfortunately the controls were a bit lacking, which made the game frustrating. Coordinating both sides is already a challenging task (and where a huge chunk of the fun resided), so there's no need to add further complications ;) <br/> <br/>If you can improve that you can get a very nice game. |
| Dec 15 23:03:00 | 22m 00s | Sir Croc vs Plantzilla | Graphics and music are awesome, but the game was a bit too punishing from the start, with little to no time to get the pacing of the game in most restarts. |
| Dec 15 23:15:00 | 12m 00s | NGHGM | The connection to the theme is a bit loose, but I love the game. From aesthetics to mechanics, it's a really solid entry, well done! |
| Dec 15 23:28:00 | 13m 00s | Heart Murmurs | Very nice idea, it is a clever take on the theme. The end result is impressive considering the context you developed the game in, congrats! :) |
| Dec 15 23:33:00 | 5m 00s | Harvest | I have LUA installed on my machine, which seems to be causing runtime errors when I try to launch the windows executable, any ideas? :S <br/> <br/>This is the stderr.txt dump: <br/>error: [string "init.lua"]:221: module 'config' not found: <br/> no field package.preload['config'] <br/> no file 'd:\development\Lua\5.1\lua\config.luac' <br/> no file 'config/init.lua' <br/> no file '.\config.dll' <br/> no file 'D:\games\ld34\ld34_rxi_win32\config.dll' <br/> no file 'D:\games\ld34\ld34_rxi_win32\loadall.dll' |
| Dec 15 23:40:00 | 7m 00s | Belly Smash | Hehehe, I loved this :D <br/>Graphics and sound were awesome, and I loved the humour. I was terrible at turning, though T_T <br/> <br/>Great job, this has been one of the funniest entries I've seen so far :) |
| Dec 15 23:44:00 | 4m 00s | Knitted Fighter | Awesome graphics, and pretty cool concept. <br/> <br/>Unfortunately the game looks pretty bugged at the moment. Most of the time I've just entered the game state to exit immediately with either a victory or defeat screen. |
| Dec 15 23:59:00 | 15m 00s | GURU | Perfect five here, I was smiling the whole time I played the games. The idea is brilliantly executed, quotes are hilarious and visuals were really cool, too. <br/> <br/>Amazing job! :D |
| Dec 16 00:06:00 | 7m 00s | Feed your demon | Cool take on the theme I really like the game mechanic, the idea and aesthetics, especially the music. Mechanics are also very cool, but collisions were a bit clunky when I tried to attack. |
| Dec 16 00:17:00 | 11m 00s | Carrot Stories | I'm loving this one. The atmosphere is melancholic and beautiful, you did an impressive job with graphics and musics. I'm still struggling to reach day 7, but I'll make it. Congratulations!!! |
| Dec 16 19:48:00 | 19h 31m | MK-F417XX3 | I liked the game and even if I played it alone controls worked perfectly fine. Nicely done! |
| Dec 17 00:15:00 | 4h 27m | Reap | Loved the graphics and general polish of the whole game. I'm really curious about the world generation, so I might give a go to the source code :) <br/> <br/>Congratulations, this is an awesome entry! |
| Dec 17 00:36:00 | 21m 00s | Milgram | I already knew about the experiment, so I was kind of expecting most of what I saw in the game (!!!), but still, I LOVE the entry: you've taken a deep, interesting topic, applied a very fitting mechanic and created a very solid entry, with awesome voice acting. Congratulations! |
| Dec 17 00:40:00 | 4m 00s | Dog Gone Big! | Very good game, mechanics are simple but work well, and it fits both themes in interesting ways. Good job! |
| Dec 17 00:57:00 | 17m 00s | Molly's Dreaming | This is very cute, graphics and music are lovely and the game itself feels fun and polished. Well done! |
| Dec 17 01:03:00 | 6m 00s | 99 Steps | Brilliant game! Minimalistic graphics, sound and gameplay blend perfectly here, it's really addictive. If you keep working on it in the future (please, do!) it would be cool to add other tile types, as some people have already mentioned. <br/> <br/>Congrats!! :D |
| Dec 17 01:12:00 | 9m 00s | Decay Dynamics | The game is brilliant in pretty much all areas, one of the best I've seen so far. However, I see a small problem: you need to focus so much on the pieces UI to assemble the robots and not lose ground against your rival that you miss the actual action, so all the really cool visuals get ignored, and that's a bit of waste, sadly :S <br/> <br/>Perhaps a slower pace and/or actually positioning them at the bottom of the screen could help give more relevance to the action. |
| Dec 17 01:15:00 | 3m 00s | Arc | This is madness!! <br/> <br/>Insanely difficult and very fun concept. It doesn't really fit the theme, but the entry is awesome. |
| Dec 17 01:20:00 | 5m 00s | Conga Master | Perfect 5 here. You've nailed it in every category, and the game looks and feels awesome. Now, if you'll excuse me, I have some more conga to dance. <br/> <br/>¡Enhorabuena! :D |
| Dec 17 22:40:00 | 21h 20m | FLOW | You've managed a very nice, relaxing mood :) |
| Dec 18 00:26:00 | 1h 46m | It's a Big World Afterall | The atmosphere here has a surreal touch that I really like. Gameplay felt a bit bland, but the concept was also a very clever interpretation of the theme. Nice work! |
| Dec 18 00:50:00 | 24m 00s | Heinsenberg | Awesome entry, even if the theme connection was a bit frail. The atmosphere gave me the chills, and the story kept me interested until the end. Puzzles were original, too. Great job!! :) |
| Dec 18 10:56:00 | 10h 06m | The Last of Egg | Loved it. The concept is hilariously absurd, and execution was awesome. I can totally see the next Goat Simulator or I am Bread here. |
| Dec 21 21:44:00 | 82h 48m | Double Helix | Great entry! Gameplay and graphics are awesome :) |
| Dec 21 22:48:00 | 1h 04m | Shroomys quest for fuel | I really liked the flooding-like mechanics as you removed parts of the shroomy and the concept was pretty interesting. Nice job! |
| Dec 21 23:16:00 | 28m 00s | Grow a Beard! | Nice micro-game based entry, it was funny and fun to play. Well done! |
| Dec 21 23:24:00 | 8m 00s | Valk Unit Lawyer | Great take on the theme, with cool graphics and very suiting music. My only issues are the inability to skip the verdict scenes, and that sometimes it's a bit too subtle to get the hints. <br/> <br/>Congratulations! |
| Dec 21 23:33:00 | 9m 00s | Mobsferatu | Perfect five. From art and music to game mechanics and level design, you've crafted one of the best games I've seen this entry. You should keep working on it and develop it onto a full game, the idea is already proven. <br/> <br/>Impresionante es poco, ¡felicidades! |
| Dec 21 23:47:00 | 14m 00s | DESEEDER | Awesome game! It's really polished, fun and the mechanics really fit the theme. Nice done! :D |
| Dec 21 23:51:00 | 4m 00s | Roll-Ball | Cool concept, well executed! |
| Dec 21 23:59:00 | 8m 00s | Growing Sakura | Awesome idea, it's very challenging and execution has an overall relaxing vibe with the sakura setting. <br/> <br/>Well done! |
| Dec 22 00:41:00 | 42m 00s | RhythmRider | Very solid entry, it feels polished and it looks and sounds awesome. <br/> <br/>I beat it at easy but got completely owned as soon as I started hard T_T Still, congrats!! |
| Dec 22 00:49:00 | 8m 00s | Double Kick Heroes | Amazing art and sound design. My hand hurts a bit from all the button mashing, which is a good thing despite it sounds the opposite :D <br/> <br/>Brilliant entry. |
| Dec 22 01:07:00 | 18m 00s | Backwards and Bonkers! | I love the trippy visual style, and gameplay feels solid. I actually expected it to be longer T_T <br/> <br/>Cool entry! |
| Dec 22 13:10:00 | 12h 03m | ORB LORDS | Brilliant concept! Polish level is also top-notch in both audio and art, and switch mechanic was a really original addition. I'm envious :D <br/> <br/>Congratulations!! |
| Dec 22 13:22:00 | 12m 00s | Cultivate | Very nice interpretation of the theme, you managed to fit an interesting story-based game into the restrictions. Awesome job! |
| Dec 22 13:29:00 | 7m 00s | Simultaneism | Brilliant! |
| Dec 22 22:19:00 | 8h 50m | Mon Démon et Moi | Beautiful graphics and audio. The core idea is interesting, the mood supports it perfectly and it's well executed. <br/> <br/>Amazing job, I think you did make a meaningful game. |
| Dec 23 14:33:00 | 16h 14m | Nepeta Cataria | Cute graphics! :D |
| Dec 23 14:49:00 | 16m 00s | Crane to Freedom | I don't generally like physics-based games, but yours was a welcome exception. The crane mechanics felt realistic in an annoying BUT fun way. Good job! <br/> <br/>And now back for that ***** whale. |
| Dec 23 16:17:00 | 1h 28m | Snowman Builder Extreme | The idea is simple, effective and very fun. Controls feel polished, which helps a lot with the feeling. <br/> <br/>Great entry! |
| Dec 23 16:26:00 | 9m 00s | FUN BUNNY SQUID MASTER | I really like your take on the theme and the blocky graphics. <br/>Nice job!! |
| Dec 23 16:30:00 | 4m 00s | Albert & Zoe | I really like the idea, but it's a bit unclear to see if the attack was successful or not and the way the boss reacts. If you can improve a bit on the feedback side you can have a very interesting entry. |
| Dec 23 16:40:00 | 10m 00s | Planet Under Siege | The game is really hard, but the idea is awesome, great take on the theme! :) |
| Dec 23 17:33:00 | 53m 00s | ＵＰＳＱＵＩＤ | Nice take on the theme and Downwell, you gave it a clever twist :) <br/> <br/>Controls, audio and graphics are very polished as well, so here goes a perfect five for one of the best compo entries this LD34. <br/> <br/>Amazing job! |
| Dec 23 21:12:00 | 3h 39m | SAUROPOD vs THEROPOD | Nice concept well executed. I liked the dinosaur sounds :DD |
| Dec 25 23:33:00 | 50h 21m | Slash Quest | Brilliant entry! Art style is lovely, and sound is fitting, too. At first I thought that controlling movement the way it's implemented would be tricky, but it works perfectly fine. <br/> <br/>Congrats, you've done a great job! |
| Dec 25 23:55:00 | 22m 00s | GROW | The idea has a lot of potential, I like the combination of resource/space management mechanics. <br/> <br/>Making the feedback on the resources lacking to build something could be useful, but it was generally easy enough to see which one it was. |
| Dec 26 00:18:00 | 23m 00s | Long Long: A snake lies in the Past | This is brilliant! Gameplay was interesting and deceivingly difficult, which was fine to me except for having to repeat all the screens since the last checkpoint. On the one hand that makes some part of the challenge, but I can see how it can become frustrating, too. <br/> <br/>Despite this, I've really liked how you managed to blend to seemingly unrelated games with amazingly polished art and sound and some nice humorous bits. Well done! |
| Dec 26 15:12:00 | 14h 54m | Twin Condition | Great entry. I love the graphic style and colour choice, and audio contributes a lot to create a soothing mood. Gameplay is also really polished, and it fits the theme perfectly. Awesome job! :D |
| Dec 26 15:30:00 | 18m 00s | Auto Racer | Interesting idea, well executed. The blinker hints was a nice addition, and controls worked flawlessly for me. Some more audio cues might have been a welcome addition, but it's understandable due to the time constraints. Good job! |
| Dec 26 15:35:00 | 5m 00s | Cockatiel Egg | Great entry! Graphics and audio look cute and really polished, and gameplay is solid, too. |
| Dec 27 15:37:00 | 24h 02m | Blobitronica | Great entry! The music helps keeping a fast pace, graphics are minimal but clear (I really liked the zoom-out effect) and gameplay is simple but effective, polished and addicting! :D |
| Dec 27 19:28:00 | 3h 51m | Memory Jump | The game idea is brilliant, the game looks nice and the music set a nice mood. Controls were a bit glitchy and the player got stuck a few times, if you fix that you'll have a great entry with lots of potential. Nice job! |
| Dec 27 19:48:00 | 20m 00s | treadmill | Great idea and nice graphics and sound. Unfortunately after around 10 movements or so the game freezes (haven't played the lo-fi version, though) :S |
| Dec 28 19:22:00 | 23h 34m | Armageddungeon | Art, sound and concept are awesome! Controls-wise, jumping over gaps was near impossible when the jump would hit the ceiling (basically, on the bottom). It wasn't too punishing as you'd reappear on the top of the screen instead of dying as in other games (this was a clever detail), but it didn't feel right. I'll be waiting for the post-compo version to see what you can do there, everything else is really solid. Good job! |
| Jan 5 01:14:00 | 173h 52m | ZZXXX the Gremlin | Interesting gameplay, detailed story and really cool music. Gameplay-wise, though, perhaps the patterns for the locations of the keys could vary across executions. Some more feedback on the prompt could be useful, too. <br/> <br/>Nice job! :) |
| Jan 5 01:30:00 | 16m 00s | Grow Your Love | Lovely game, and I just had to find it almost at the end of the voting time! Congratulations, it almost got a perfect 5!! |
| Jan 5 01:47:00 | 17m 00s | Row Row Row Your Goat | Brilliant, hilarious idea, awesome graphics and a lot of content for 3 days. Congrats! |