Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD17 → Feedback comment stats → onefifth
Feedback comments for LD17
onefifth's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | onefifth's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dare Islands | Simple and fun. I believe it has a lot of potential to become a full game if you add some variety to the gameplay. Congratulations. | ||
| Islands of the Stone God | Original and interesting idea. I loved the graphic style. First time I wasnt sure what to do, but second time I play (and read the description) was fun. I think it has a lot of potential. Congratulations. | ||
| A Fishing Adventure | Excellent game! Super original. It's so sad that you couldn't include a song or sound effects. Include music, sounds, more levels/puzzles (are you planning to include enemies?) and you will have an incredible game. Congratulations. | ||
| Island Repair Man | Congratulations. Usually I don't enjoy puzzle games, but playing Island Repair Man was a real joy. Great idea and excellent execution: simple to understand and fun to play. I missed some visual effects, music/sound effects and some (not too much, please) gameplay variety, but I understand that you run out of time. Please add those and you will have a great game. Congratulations. | ||
| Planetfall | I couldn't play. Same error: <br/> <br/>"The procedure point _ftol2 could not be located in the dynamic link library msvcrt.dll" <br/> <br/>I'm using XP. I will try on a Vista PC later. | ||
| Wow, Islands And Stuff!! | I really liked it. Simple and fun. I agree it's a lot of content. Excellent music. In my opinion, the only thing that could be better is the collision detection, but you don't even notice when playing because it's a great game. Congratulations. | ||
| Rocket Bike To Space | Great graphics and song. It's very hard.. but I'd like the idea of bouncing because it makes things a little different when comparing to traditional one-button jumping games. Audio effects would be great. Great game. Congratulations. | ||
| Galapagos | Hello, It doesn't run in my notebook.. I wil try in a a different computer later. | ||
| Monkey Islands | Great name and graphics. Excellent music. Unfortunately you couldn't add a goal :( | ||
| Radio Silence | Great atmosphere. Excellent use of audio. Sometimes and I had to close my eyes to focus on the sound to found all radios. I think it could be better if you die if you stay too long in the water. Great game. Congratulations. | ||
| SkyLands | Excellent audio. Simple and fun gameplay. Restarting after dying impeded me to finish the game. | ||
| Island Rescue | Great gameplay, I would have liked to turn pieces close to the borders. Excellent song, It's great to know that you played it. Congratulations. | ||
| Zombie Island | Good graphic effect!! Simple gameplay and fun. It reminded me old classic arcade games. <br/>* You can kill zombies, they have to be close to you. | ||
| Island Tour Racing | It's a good idea/tech demo. It reminds me of a game I programmed for the ZX81 (yes, I'm old).I think it is a good start. | ||
| Awesome LifeBoat Game | Great audio. Are you rescuing zombies? :) At the beggining I didn't like the idea of reversing your boat after a collision, but I think it could be a great gameplay mechanism. | ||
| Ferry catcher | The running/surboard switch idea is interesting, but as you said "it lacks polish". Good song :) | ||
| Horrible LD17 Game | Good start. I hope you can make more levels and variety. It crashes when I won. | ||
| Pirates | Simple and good idea. Great sprites. I agree with comments regarding controls and having something drawing the player away from the chest, or the game is too easy. | ||
| Hovergirl in Island World | Couldn't find the game :( | ||
| Waves | Good game.. I missed some music. Congratulations. | ||
| Lonesome Flotsam | It's sad that you didn't include your song in the game, that would have been great. Excellent game. Congratulations. | ||
| Simcano | I think is a good idea, but I couldn't make any money :( I didn't see trees or mountains. | ||
| Floating Islands | Great idea and execution. Some music would be great. | ||
| Zombie Grinder | It reminded me classics beat'em up's. A lot of potential. | ||
| Treasure Tub | Great graphics and sound effects. Multiplayer would be great. I believe that the control scheme could be simplified. | ||
| Stranded! | Hello, I edited the .bat to execute just "java -Djava.library.path=./natives/ -jar LD17.jar" and it worked. The game is very basic, but it could work if some challenge is added. | ||
| Ascention | Great idea, and excellent execution. Worked flawless in Chrome (XP). Fun and challenging. A lot of potential. I think it could be a great game for Wii/DSware where instead of pointing you could "draw" the line. I have to say that I don't see any "island-related" thing :) | ||
| Island Skate Delivery Boy | It's a good one-button jumping game and good homage to Wonder Boy :) A song would have been great. |