Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD41 → Heartless Ninjas
By king-kujito
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 345 | 3.37 | 35 | |
| Fun | 535 | 2.94 | 36 | |
| Innovation | 193 | 3.64 | 36 | |
| Theme | 247 | 3.80 | 36 | |
| Graphics | 299 | 3.36 | 36 | |
| Audio | 165 | 3.36 | 36 | |
| Humor | 443 | 2.35 | 30 | |
| Mood | 224 | 3.30 | 35 |
Any Tipps? This game is cool, I just don't understand the enemy routes ^^ But I really like the Idea and the gameplay (just sprinting looks weird and enemies as well as the merchant are a bit slow)
Is there a system behind enemy routes or is it random?
I was really impressed with this. The seeming randomness of the spotlights was a little bit frustrating. But you've struck an incredible balance, forcing players to weigh their security against their mobility. Very clever.
@leorid If I understand it correctly: you're asking me how I tackled enemy paths, right? I put up way points at every corner, once an enemy reaches those corners, they chose the next possible corner to move towards. They will never fall back though. They will always try to progress towards the castle.
@GeraldFIngBurke Thank you. Are you referring to the movement of the search lights when you say 'random' or something else?
@King Kujito Yes. I had a hard time timing my route because I couldn't figure out where the lights were going to be.
@GeraldFIngBurke I see, that makes a lot of sense. Unfortunately I don't like my game enough to find the motivation to make another patch but I'll definitely take your advise with me for future projects.
God no! If you start fixing everything on a jam game you'll shoot yourself in the foot. The game was great as it was. I was just looking for critique points.
Kinda hard to play, but nevermind it's a great entry ! Polished graphics, nice sounds... Well done !
You've hit on something pretty freaking cool here. Building up a tower defense that you can still beat, but the PC can't is genius. You're fighting against the computer on two different things, it's a great mashup and I feel it hits the theme very very well. Very impressed with how much you got done - I'd seriously run with this idea.
I always am intrigued by tower defense games. Maybe one day I'll make one :smirk:
Love the concept! It was a little hard for me to play it at first, but I thought the graphics were great and the music fit perfectly.
Brownie points for the time lapse video :smile:
Nice work!
Spectacular! Iām humbled at this masterpiece of a game.
Super impressive! Definently flesh this out more.
Great game!. I found that it's easy to place chokepoints to kill all the enemies before they can reach the rice, however I cannot deliver rice for the same reason XD
Interesting concept. Unfortunately, the HTML5 build suffered from terrible performance on my end, especially when having to move through the first line of defence. Graphics and audio are a good fit. Game looks and feels like it has potential for further expansion.
@Lumos could you go into more detail? On my MacBook (nowhere near gaming pc stats) I get decent performance. Only in stealth sections do I get 30-60 fps. Inside the Unity editor I had a drop to14 or 20 a couple of times.
If you would mind telling me your OS and where you ran into performance issues, it would help me out a lot. Thanks :-)
@King Kujito: Sure, but it might've been a false alarm. Win 10, Firefox. I tried it on Chromium too, and aside from a few hitches here and there, it worked a lot better. Guess it must've been Firefox being annoying again...
@Lumos Thanks for the response. I've heard about firefox screwing with unity games before.
Nice one, buddy! It was not easy to understand at first but I figured out =)
I like the combination of genres. I got lost trying to deliver my rice but then I remembered the castle acts as a pretty good landmark when you get lost lol. There wasn't a lot of feedback of when your towers were attacking. Some sounds or something would be nice. Cool entry.
@those-30-ninjas thanks for the feedback. I fully agree. I wanted to give some audio feedback but unfortunately hadn't the time to do so. :-( that's LD I guess
its amazing how much you got accomplished here - it is really a great concept for a game - thanks for making it - only problem was that it playe d a little slow - not sure if that was intended
@paulhocker are you talking about frame rate or something else? Either way, would you mind going into more detail about what the problem was in your experience? thanks :-)
Great combination of genres. I was a bit confused at first, but I got the idea and I liked it a lot! Congratulationsš
Great idea, I like how it first tests your strategy and then tests you memory and orientation. The music is also very fitting, good job!
Really like the idea of stealth tower defense. Really cool. The game overall would need some polish, I guess that is a fair point, but I think you have a nice potential here. Also thumbs up for the music! Good job.
Nicely done, music was nice and put you (me) in the mood for sneaking. Good work!
The idea of sneaking through your own defenses is super cool and it's a nice touch that the player can sell their units. (Potential cheese - place units to slay enemies and then remove them at the very last minute (at least remove from from 1 path) for the merchant to just breeze through. The music sets the setting really well.
Gripes/suggestions (on Chrome, Win 10, decent specs - i5, 8 gig of RAM, GXT 950M): * the run animation was super buggy for me and it rarely worked * the merchant mode was running poorly - low FPS * lack of feedback from the towers - I'm not at all sure how effective my towers were as some enemies passed through and some just kinda dropped dead * arrows for camera control were pretty annoying * does the merchant mode have to be 3D at all? I'd probably prefer to have it topdown, but that might be just me
The foundation is great. If you work on it further, it could really become something special. :thumbsup:
@SecretPocketCat thanks for the feedback. I knew about the run animation but hadn't the time to fix it (it was my first time using the Unity Animator component instead of the Animation component). Your last point is very good, topdown could've been more effective indeed.
@king-kujito No worries. I just hope I don't sound too critical - the more I like something, the more I tend to critise it and come up with my own designs :sweat_smile: If you decide on doing an revamped version, I'd love to see the result.
As for the Animator - I have to get into that myself. I pretty much use dotween for everything, which can get messy quite easily and I should probably look at the default Unity toolset to be able to mix and match...