Foon →
Ludum Dare Explorer →
LD41 →
Extreme Tower Fishing 2018
Extreme Tower Fishing 2018
By roka-josh and Thomu
View on ldjam.com
| Category | Rank | Score | Count |
|
|---|
| Overall | 380 | 3.63 | 25 | |
| Fun | 212 | 3.76 | 25 | |
| Innovation | 181 | 3.82 | 25 | |
| Theme | 268 | 3.97 | 25 | |
| Graphics | 655 | 3.37 | 25 | |
| Audio | 363 | 3.41 | 25 | |
| Humor | 446 | 3.11 | 24 | |
| Mood | 708 | 3.13 | 25 | |
Comments
This seems more like a tower defense game with a fishing minigame than necessarily a fusion of genres, but it does work well. However, on my second playthrough, only about seven fish spawned in and then no more showed up.
The only criticism I really have is with respect to graphics: it isn't too noticeable in this game, but it suffers from a stylistic choice that I personally feel is undesirable: multiple resolutions of pixel art, which often doesn't look too good.
Nice game, just think that you should be able to fishing during the defense
@TheMonsterFromTheDeep Hi thanks for playing our game, do you have a mac, as this spawning issue was encountered by my team mate who has a mac, and I have played more than him but still haven't encountered it. And thank you for giving fair criticism!
@Roka Josh : No, I'm playing on Windows.
@SamuelDeboni Thanks for playing the game, may I ask what you mean as you can switch to fishing while the tower defense is still going on, if you mean on the same screen then I agree with you in hindsight and that is definitely something we will consider working towards at a later date. Thanks again!
pur3
2018-04-24 17:45
Really liked the combination, defending was balanced quite nicely. Maybe show how much upgrades cost? Had fun playing, nice job! :)
@TheMonsterFromTheDeep Interesting, I'll look into it and thanks for responding so quickly!
@PUR3 Thanks a lot for playing the game, and I'm glad you feel that way about the defence side. It was quite a challenge to balance as much as possible in the time we had left! I can definitely add in the upgrade pricing for future versions, and once again thanks for playing!
Really cool combo. It would be nice to have a little more feedback as to when I was getting hit while fishing. May flash the screen red.
@theamazingb Thanks for playing our game, and I will add it to the list of things to do once the voting is over, we will definitely add to this once the competition is done, so your feedback is appreciated!
Fun game. But I have the same issue as @themonsterfromthedeep, I use Linux.
@yancharkin Thanks for playing our game, I'll look into it!
@TheMonsterFromTheDeep @yancharkin Thanks to the both of you, I was able to fix the bug and it is allowed in the rules to fix game breaking bugs, so once again thanks for playing the game and finding this bug!
Great! I think it actually fixes one of my biggest pet peeves with the tower defenses (a genre that I love/hate) which is that you end up in a death spiral when you don't get money from the guys you miss. When I first played I didn't realize that there was a tower defense game at all, though because I didn't fully read the instructions on the LD page (which I know is my own fault but it's nice if the instruction is in the game itself.) It would be great if there were levels to beat and a more finely tuned difficulty curve that didn't always overwhelm me, but as a jam game, this is fantastic. Good job!
@BryceLTaylor Thanks a lot for playing, and your feedback is greatly appreciated. We will be working on this game after the competition is up, so suggestions like more levels and a better difficulty progression and very important to us. Thanks again!
aszu
2018-05-03 17:03
Yeah, i feel like fishing and defending are two separate games. Also i can't understand much of what's going on, you should improve the graphics. But, the idea was good, and the mechanics work nicely. Good job!
t-mw
2018-05-04 12:51
I thought that the two genres work surprisingly well together. It gets quite tense trying to fish while the tower defense is going on in the background. One small issue (already mentioned by someone else) I found was that it's hard to tell how much the upgrades cost. Otherwise, good job!
Switching between defending and fishing was a lot of fun. I like that you cant see the tower side while fishing so you just have to trust that the defenses you placed are working. This is a game I can see myself playing many more times.
yashpal
2018-05-05 17:24
**Great game**
Programming, Art, sound all things are great :sunglasses:
It's fun game.
zanedd
2018-05-06 19:15
I really like it! Graphics were great, fishing was fun, and the background music was good. Biggest suggestion I might make would be to add some sort of indicator to know what's going on with the towers while you're fishing (like a minimap or something). But what you have is amazing for a weekend project!
@Aszu Thanks for your feedback!
@t-mw Thanks for your feedback, we'll be adding upgrade costs in the post jam version!
Nice game! Had a lot of fun playing =) Really enjoyed it!
Great Job
@AmigoPadilha Thanks a lot for playing!
kobrar
2018-05-07 20:43
The game is unfortunately ridden with bugs. I really like the concept and hope to see some more updates in the future :)
I think @BryceLTaylor makes a really good point. This is one of the very few TDs were you can earn money outside of the core game and get yourself out of pits. I liked that the fishing was decently skillbased so a better player could earn money faster. It was very satisfying to land a cast right on top of a fish. All in all I thought the fishing really shined, but the TD was kind of standard fare, but I guess that's the idea with this LD theme :)
@PeachTreeOath and @Kobrar Thank you for playing our game, if you could explain what bugs existed so we could work to fix them instead of just saying there are bugs that would be very helpful and much appreciated! And we will be working towards balancing both sides of the game, namely fleshing out the tower defense side, in the future. Thanks again!
No bugs on my end, but if I had to toss out an idea to integrate the 2 sides better you could try something along the lines of:
You can store fish or certain fish drop tower upgrades, then you can apply these onto the towers rather than just buying them (you still need $ to buy the actual tower). This could make rarer fish pretty valuable and give the player more of a link between the games than just cash. Just an idea, I'm sure you guys had plenty of great ideas that fell on the cutting room floor!
Thanks for clarifying on the bugs, both of us didn't encounter any bugs after playtesting the updated version, so we are confused by the "ridden with bugs" statement and would love more information. Also we love that idea, the idea that you could get something more from the fishing like upgrades or permanent global increases if we add more levels could be huge so that's a great suggestion!
kobrar
2018-05-09 00:48
@roka-josh Upgrading was kind of weird. It seems like the current upgrade levels aren't properly retrieved from the towers. It makes it hard to decide what to upgrade since I don't know what I've already upgraded.
@Kobrar Ah yes, thanks for this, I encountered once and thought I had fixed it but to know is it still there means I've got some more work to do. Are there anymore you encountered, because riddled implied there are more and we would like to iron them out before the post jam version. Thanks for your help!