r4m0n 2010-12-20 03:41
Nice game overall!
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD19 → Lost Races' Abandoned Artifact Recovery
By eli
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audio | 35 | 3.35 | ||
| Humor | 60 | 2.77 | ||
| Community | 66 | 3.31 | ||
| Innovation | 75 | 3.17 | ||
| Theme | 77 | 3.35 | ||
| Overall | 80 | 3.13 | ||
| Coolness | 121 | 4 | ||
| Fun | 140 | 2.57 | ||
| Graphics | 174 | 2.43 |
Nice game overall!
Interesting idea but doesn't have a lot of expansion after it is introduced to the player, therefore becomes a bit grindey and bland. The weird voices creeped me out though.
Great work man! I LOVE the audio, so weird, in a wonderful way! Well made, although I wish gameplay was a bit more concise... GO GO!
I'm always amazed at my willingness to let computer games give me menial tasks. The payoff was a bit of a let down...
The audio was Great! really made me want to finish the game to hear more weird voices (should I be worried?) and thought that the idea was quite different as well. But as good as the audio was, I was really disappointed at the end, I was looking forward to a translation or story or something, other than just a finish screen. Good overall though.
Thanks, everyone for feedback.
I'm very interested in hearing if anyone managed to LOSE the game. That was kind of the point. If everyone who finished managed to win the game, then it's even worse than I thought =)
I lost ;_: The alien noises were creepy.
I think the biggest mistake you made in the game design was assuming that players would make new piles for each artifact. I just moved my one pile from each artifact to the next, and this never gained much alien attention. Top notch audio.
A few interesting ideas in there, but they didn't want to come together.
The alien overlord thingie is nice but it didn't make any impact I could deduce.
At least you posted a post mortem, some blog entries. But i did not get what you said about the timelapse. So is there one or not? I don't see a link so none for me to give a point to.
You said the game is no fun. But actually I had at least this much fun to play through it to the end. Yeah I did not get the mini map, also not the alien stuff, but i found it rather ambient. I liked it actually.
So yeah, I did have fun, the graphics were nice, the game was simple enough to finish for my ADD self, so yeah. Good work there.
@squax, @thristhart, @endurion: I guess relying on that one mechanic was much too flimsy. Thanks for the feedback, I'll try to improve!
@joekinley: I didn't make a timelapse, and I don't believe I ever mentioned one. Thanks for the feedback!
Cool idea. It took me a little bit to get the game mechanics, but once I did I thought it was quite interesting.