Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD54 → Feedback comment stats → Martta
Feedback comments for LD54
Martta's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Martta's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 2 21:38:40 | Quicksand | ♥ 3 | Is the 2nd level impossible? I did not find a way to get past the lava. Also, in the first level, how would one get the middle part of the level? I tried pressing space and by running on top the sand, but it felt like nothing helped to get over the lava. I am sorry to say that I did not see the game past the 2nd level. The sound effects were the best part of this game. Gameplay felt nice, but if indeed it is possible to cross the lava somehow, there should be at least some written instructions somewhere. I quess the issue is that I do not know how to dash? Was there some button for it? Or did it somehow activate when picking up boots? I dont know... I am glad that you too hopped on the Godot hype train! Our 1st Godot game was also very basic, but now we are able to do more advanced games in game jams after little bit practice. Congratulations on finishing a game and learning completely new engine! Only few people can do that! | |
| Oct 2 21:47:39 | 8m 59s | Inventory Manager | ♥ 3 | Interesting time to start learning Unity. But congratulations on finishing a game, or at least some interactive demo! Obviously this game is not going to win this year, but we still can appreciate your effort put in to this. Learning new engine is hard, but I think best way to start learning is to just start publishing games, even unfinished ones. This game is great example of that valuable learning process. We all have been there. While I could give you some constructive feedback how to make the game better, I choose not to. You already know how to make the game better and what skills do you need to learn next. I will give you one tip: Never underestimate the importance of sounds. For example your mouse makes a clicking sound for a reason: It gives user feedback on what is happening. |
| Oct 3 12:39:31 | 14h 51m | LD54 A Space Station Odysee | ♥ 1 | Ah looks like that I accidentally played the version that was uncompletable... What a waste of time trying to complete the game... :D The game is quite fun, but lacks some polish. The music seems to stop playing after certain amount of time (you need to set the looping from the import setting in Godot and then reimport). I think you should have went for little bit smaller set of features. Now there were too many different resources for example. I really liked the fact that you could find new companions around the space station, but the RTS-style controls still felt little bit unnecessary. I think that one of the survivors should be selected at all times, no need for unselecting them. I see great potential with this game with little bit of polishing! |
| Oct 3 17:41:58 | 5h 02m | LD54 - Pack-Man's limited space | ♥ 1 | Nice game. I wish there would have been sound effect for returning the coins to a piggy bank. Also the 10 coin limit was rather generous, maybe 5 would have made more interesting gameplay. I liked the fact that there were so many ghosts, but they were slow and did not follow the player in very optimal way. There was great pressure from the ghosts as they were everywhere, but still I managed to escape them. Thank you for this great game, also the player animations looked cool! |
| Oct 4 17:32:22 | 23h 50m | Animal Teleporting | ♥ 2 | Cool game! Dont have anything to add to the other comments. It was very polished and all the puzzles were suprisingly well thought out and the difficulty was very suitable for a jam game. Maybe the graphics were little bit dull, and sound effects little bit annoying, but those are really minor things as the game still looked good and sounded good. |
| Oct 6 19:28:18 | 49h 55m | F.R.E.D | ♥ 1 | Fun game! I think some sort of tutorial would be essential for this game. The controls were not documented inside tha game, and it was difficult to remember what was the difference betwee x and c buttons and ended up dropping the items accidentally all the time. Also some kind of desciption of the goals would have been nice. But really compled and interesting game! |
| Oct 7 18:46:51 | 23h 18m | Fowl Play | ♥ 3 | - Great voice acting - Good graphics - Nice and kind of innovative gameplay - I got the right suspect, but I kind of fell of the plot anyway. So many ducks that were kind of similar and weird names. I would have needed to take notes on pen and paper to understand all the clues - Fight sequences were nice addition, but were not explained very well. Maybe one voiceline in the final sequence would have tied them better in the plot, something like "He/she used mercenaries in trying to stop the detective". - Nice and innovative interperation of the theme, as everything happened in small limited space as a play. However it had only little gameplay implications. Thanks for interesting and inspiring experience! I like this kind of Ludum Dare games that are small, interesting and polished short experiences. :-) Video games industry is too saturated for action games without nice story. |
| Oct 8 07:34:04 | 12h 47m | Crumble Cave | ♥ 1 | For some reason I do not see any rating buttons for this particular games, but for other games I am able to give ratings. What gives? I really liked this game and the graphics were quite nice, really liked the lighting. The gameplay was hard and infuriating, little bit like Flappy Bird. :D |
| Oct 8 07:42:16 | 8m 12s | Cap Sized | ♥ 0 | nimetön.png LOL this was fun! I wish there would have been little bit more polish, as this game had awesome idea and solid implementation. Dropping the survivors to the ladder was little bit buggy. There were no sounds? The movement of the boat felt little bit too on rails. |
| Oct 8 12:19:17 | 4h 37m | Limited Larry and the Lost Intern | ♥ 1 | Very confusing and I quickly forgot what I was doing and got stuck and was unable to proceed. Maybe I forgot something useful information that prevented me from progressing? The idea is very innovative and impressive, but maybe bit too ambitious for game jams. But I respect the effort! |
| Oct 8 13:00:54 | 41m 37s | I Need Some Space | ♥ 2 | I am getting an error when trying to start the game: "Following components are required to run this program: Microsoft Visual C++ Runtime". |
| Oct 9 13:57:34 | 24h 56m | The King is Watching | ♥ 4 | Great game! I dont have anything to add, you have already plenty of reviews. :D Keep up the good work! |
