Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD50 → Feedback comment stats → nathanoc
Feedback comments for LD50
nathanoc's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | nathanoc's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 4 19:00:20 | Delay The Inevitable | ♥ 0 | I agree with the other commenters - I think the length will have to limit my rating, but I found the game enjoyable and I can tell you could have made something excellent if you'd had the time to. | |
| Apr 4 19:03:32 | 3m 12s | ALL IS LOST | ♥ 3 | I don't know if it's just me, but I got an error when I caught the first piece of trash. Hopefully you can fix it and if I remember to I'll come back to this in a day or two. Edit: That problem's gone now - the game was playable, though the end screen did say my score was zero. I enjoyed playing, but it got repetitive after a while - I think the difficulty did seem to increase, but I think especially later in the game it should have risen a bit faster so that a single round doesn't become too long and repetitive. Overall though it's a nice game, especially the art, and I enjoyed playing it. |
| Apr 4 19:42:53 | 39m 21s | The Fall of Mezentople | ♥ 2 | Unless this is just a whole type of game that I've never been aware of, this game to me was very new and unique. I found it confusing at times, especially to begin with, but once I began to understand what was going on it was quite enjoyable. Overall definitely a solid submission. |
| Apr 5 09:38:56 | 13h 56m | Sunday Traffic | ♥ 2 | This was very fun - one of the only games so far that I've played twice. The graphics are pretty, though I agree with some others that the traffic lights could benefit from being bigger or more visible. That doesn't take away from the fact that this is a very good game though. |
| Apr 5 09:57:09 | 18m 13s | Wobbly Plankster | ♥ 1 | The game's very simple but somehow probably the most fun game I've played so far. I spent a lot of time playing trying to get on the leaderboard. |
| Apr 5 10:10:08 | 12m 59s | Foundations | ♥ 1 | I don't really see how this fits the theme, but I found it very fun - if you look past the theme, it's an excellent idea and game; one of the few that I think I'll be coming back to. |
| Apr 5 13:05:12 | 2h 55m | Warmer | ♥ 0 | It's a shame you didn't have time to finish - this a nice game, and I can definitely see the potential for it to have been a really good entry. I still enjoyed playing what is there of it - I think you'll definitely do well if you can plan better in your future jams. |
| Apr 5 13:13:44 | 8m 32s | SNIP SNAP BOOM | ♥ 4 | Very fun and intense - probably the best game I've come across so far. |
| Apr 6 11:20:20 | 22h 06m | Oh No My Trophy | ♥ 1 | This was a nice game. I liked the graphics, and the gameplay was interesting. I will say I found it a lot easier to just swing the pump around everywhere - I think the game may have benefitted from making the other tools more effective and easier to use. The start screen was quite confusing at first glance, but looking at it I feel like it's made to look a lot more complicated than it really is - a lot of it could just be summarised in a few words. It also could have helped to colour the stick figures depending on what they're immune to - i.e. have the red ones be immune to lava but vulnerable to everything else. Overall though, don't let the amount of criticism deceive you into thinking I found this to be a bad game. In many ways it was very polished, which is rare for a jam game, let alone a compo game. Overall it's definitely one of the better games I've played so far. Edit: High score - 627 |
| Apr 6 11:38:13 | 17m 53s | FlowerPower | ♥ 1 | The vibe reminded me a lot of stardew valley - is that what you were going for? This is a very cute game, I enjoyed it a lot. |
| Apr 6 11:50:31 | 12m 18s | Comet | ♥ 1 | The art is very pretty, and the game is fun to play but I feel like it's a bit too challenging to win - the comet just always seems to land a bit before you've had time to fill all the cannons. I didn't find the slimes to be too bad after playing for a bit, though maybe a health system rather than instant death would have made it feel a bit less punishing. Overall though, very nice game - I had a lot of fun with it. |
| Apr 8 10:33:17 | 46h 42m | Defy Godwin | ♥ 1 | Really enjoyable game, I was surprised by how much content it seems to have. I enjoyed it a lot. |