Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD43 → Feedback comment stats → maximiliangeorg
Feedback comments for LD43
maximiliangeorg's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | maximiliangeorg's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 8 09:30:44 | The Chosen Sheep | ♥ 1 | The second phase literally gave me goosebumps! Nice work there with the whispering and thunder storm. You achieved a super cool look in the short time available and everything matches very well. My biggest complain is about balancing: In the second part sheep move way faster, have more health and spawn faster all at once, that is a big ramp up in difficulty in comparison to the first part. Still it was more motivating than frustrating but a smoother difficulty curve would have resulted in a better and more fun experience. Another thing worth tweaking is the camera distance. I played on PC and when the shit hit the fan and I where chasing many very fast sheep I only focused on the sheep icons on the border of the screen rather than the actual visuals. Otherwise the time I have to react is too short. This is especially unfortunate because your game looks so nice. I can imagine though, that the current camera setup is better for mobile. All in all, a perfectly scoped and well executed project that would be perfect with a little bit more tweaking. | |
| Dec 8 09:43:39 | 12m 55s | Martyr | ♥ 0 | You can easily get stuck when you need a specific character to proceed but this character is already dead. Also it took a while until I learned what each character can do because I did not memorize everything written down on the start screen. Some hint while playing would be nice to help my memory. The interactive elements (like the pressure plate that opens a door when a box is placed on it) are not different enough from decorative elements, so it becomes a game of trial and error. The amount of content you managed to create is stunning though. |
| Dec 8 10:24:16 | 40m 37s | Pre-Life | ♥ 1 | The game works fine and especially because of its amount of content this is already a big achievement. Unfortunately the actions I can take and their consequences are super unclear. Its too much trail and error. But on the bright side its a very nice take on the theme. |
| Dec 8 10:39:58 | 15m 42s | Of Gods And Rain | ♥ 3 | Wow! Great project and impressive character art. In general I enjoyed playing it but the main gameplay is a little slow and sometimes dull. The NPCs can be tricked to easily. |
| Dec 8 10:50:10 | 10m 12s | ETA: Estimated Time Of Arrival | ♥ 0 | Cool game, the nice combination of well known titles was already mentioned by others. I wasn't able to figure out how to open the door in the third or fourth level so some guidance would be nice. |
| Dec 8 11:00:21 | 10m 11s | The Delivery | ♥ 1 | Besides the main story this is not much about sacrifice. I would have loved to make some decisions about which part of my ship I want to sacrifice in order to proceed. |
| Dec 8 11:42:23 | 42m 02s | Let there bee sacrifices | ♥ 3 | Really cool game! It was super fun to be in control of a bee hive. What i disliked most is that you can easily run into a dead end if you run out of workers, drones and jelly. Then you cannot back on track but the game doesn't trigger a fail state. What would be super nice is to have a better recognizable cursor. I failed in some fights because I didn't see where my mouse was pointing. Overall a super cool idea that was very well executed. |
| Dec 8 12:02:45 | 20m 22s | Consilium - A history of life and choices | ♥ 1 | Cool game, super polished! My only complaint: I saw no reason not to hold down the left mouse button so it would be nice if the resources flow automatically and I have only to point on the tile and cycle through them. |
| Dec 8 12:54:29 | 51m 44s | Feed the Gods | ♥ 0 | Unbenannt.png I played quiet a while and had a lot of fun. Most things I could criticize are bugs regarding path findig or controls what would be very nick picky for a jam. Besides that there is a conflict between balancing and content: It takes to long to loose because at some point it becomes to repetitive without enough challenge or discovery. But all in all I think this is a great submission and a solid base for a bigger game. |
| Dec 9 16:02:13 | 27h 07m | The Selfish King | ♥ 1 | Ambitious plan for such a short time. I think this can be fun after a little polishing but with the current control issues (it's sometimes hard to perform attacks) and other bugs (I was not able to sacrifice because of a null reference) it's quiet clumsy. But as I said, I see where you are heading, nice game! |
| Dec 9 16:13:00 | 10m 47s | Cultist of sacrifices | ♥ 1 | You managed to implement a lot of mechanics that's super cool! I liked it, the quests had a nice variation and it's a finished game. The sound was hilarious :D |
