Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD41 → Feedback comment stats → PSiv

PSiv

Feedback comments for LD41

Timestamp	Since previous	Game		PSiv's comment
Apr 24 13:42:15		The Roads Away	♥ 1	This is a really interesting combination of genres, good fun. A couple of issues, firstly no way back to main menu to try out the different characters and I think a little information about each ability would be useful. The robot in particular I couldn't work out what it did until suddenly a box blew up and I realised.
Apr 24 14:19:55	37m 40s	Aloisius	♥ 2	I really like the strategy elements of this, the choice to spend a turn investing in buildings and moving workers to resources to have more gold in the future or building units and attacking now to try and win the game. The different scenarios are all interesting as well.
Apr 24 16:30:43	2h 10m	Date or Die	♥ 1	It's like the binding of isaac but instead of bosses there's girls to chat up! I chose to burn it all down with the fire lady :) Minor issue, Some rooms the enemies spawned too close to the entrance so as soon as you walk in they hit you
Apr 24 16:50:11	19m 28s	Golf with Guns	♥ 1	Really fun, an entire 18 hole course of this would be amazing!
Apr 24 17:36:43	46m 32s	Flappy Bird + Tetirs = FLAPTRIS	♥ 1	So if the goal of tetris is to line up blocks to remove them, does this count as winning? :) flaptris.png Bugs aside it is a fantastic game, the visuals and audio in particular are great, and the intro is top tier.
Apr 25 12:53:52	19h 17m	LudumDare 41 - Threerena	♥ 3	I could see this being really fun as a full multiplayer game, the mixtures of modifiers are interesting and I think if the games lasted a bit longer it would let you experience all the fun combinations more. A big issue for me is the font, it goes well with the aesthetics of the game but it makes some words difficult to read.
Apr 25 13:46:11	52m 19s	Jeff From Accounting	♥ 1	Visually amazing and good fun, hugely impressive as it is and even more so considering the time constraints! Hit detection felt a bit off on the paintings and when there was a space in the name, for example shooting out mrschair quickly sometimes only the mrs hit. Also a button to delete all letters at once would be useful in a pinch.
Apr 28 12:40:35	70h 54m	OptiShot	♥ 2	First across the line rules for finishing do not go well with turn based. If it takes players the same number of shots to get to the finish then whoever goes first is always going to win, simply because they got to take their final shot first. If a player finishes on turn 5, the game should continue until everyone has had turn 5, and then determine a winner (or joint winners). Also the starting positions should be the same for everyone (either one fixed starting position, or a small area where you can choose where to start) to ensure a fair start. Aside from that the mechanics work well, I think the transparent walls from behind is a really nice touch, and for your first completed 3d game you should be proud!
Apr 30 13:07:16	48h 26m	Are You Smarter Than An Alien?	♥ 1	I love the gameshow vibe of this with the music, voiceover and audiences cheers and stuff, very amusing. I'm not sure how, but maybe if the background or the enemies were more gameshowy it would really tie it all in nicely, maybe more sparkles or lights or something. Misspelling of distance.
May 1 13:36:36	24h 29m	Funk Escape	♥ 2	I really love the concept, it is realy enjoyable to play, and the rhythm section is really well done. I'm imagining a full guitar hero game with well know songs, but with a shoot em up, and I want it! I want it now! The clear distinct sounds for the red, green and yellow notes make them easy to hear and press the right button at the right time for, but for me the blue note was not as clear. Beats like the one in the picture below are perfect for this game, clear, catchy, easy to remember, meaning players can do the rhythm part by ear and focus more on the shoot em up aspect. ld41.png So if the rhythm section is easier, the shoot em up section could be made more interesting, maybe add some enemies that shoot you, make the asteroids move at different speeds, or maybe have a system where the more funk power you have the more enemies/asteroids there are.