Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD39 → Feedback comment stats → pklaschka
Feedback comments for LD39
pklaschka's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | pklaschka's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 1 07:40:31 | Mission Critical | ♥ 2 | Nice game π. The **art is very nice**, but it's **a bit too easy to land the ship**. Thanks for sharing. | |
| Aug 1 08:10:35 | 30m 04s | Running out of Coffee | ♥ 1 | The idea is interesting and has some potential, but I think it β¦ - β¦ is to hard (maybe, it would have been easier if the controls were side by side on the keyboard as thinking about which key did what in the game is to slow for the fast pace the game has βΒ and clicking also was a bit complicated, as then, one has to look to the bars on the right and the cursor). - β¦Β needs sound, because without sound, it's too hard, as there is only visual feedback (and even that is insufficient, as others already mentioned) telling you if you need to brew new coffee (which is too complicated for the fast pace of the game). Thank you for sharing. |
| Aug 1 08:34:27 | 23m 52s | Soaring | ♥ 2 | To be honest, I find the idea a bit boring (Flappy birds combined with some Picking coins and some fuel limitations) β also, I am not a big fan of Flappy birds. The implementation, and β to be more exact βΒ the **audio** aspect of itβ compensate for that, though. All things considered: An a bit boring idea (in my opinion) with a much better implementation (especially in mood and audio). Thank you for sharing. |
| Aug 1 09:47:34 | 1h 13m | Planet Drifter | ♥ 0 | Very good π, but I find the visible area a bit small (I often went "out of camera" when I had enough power left to just turn around, but as I didn't see the ship any more, I couldn't turn in the right direction). Thank you for sharing. |
| Aug 1 10:33:25 | 45m 51s | Journey in the Dark | ♥ 2 | **It's a great game π. ** **Just one thing:** I have to agree with @bajarymi and @arnage: I also understand your explanation, but it would have been great if it had been a bit clearer what's an obstacle and what's not (it doesn't have to be shining red, but just **a bit clearer** β maybe by having just a bit more contrast in the brightness of the colorsβ¦). All in all, a great game, thank you for sharing it. |
| Aug 2 11:36:39 | 25h 03m | Last Train Out | ♥ 3 | Very cool game, one of the best LD39 games I've played so far βΒ I would like to give some constructive feedback on what to do better, but I have nothing to say π. |
| Aug 2 16:59:50 | 5h 23m | TITAN, Defend Earth before it's too late | ♥ 1 | Very cool game β a bit difficult (getting to know the layout of the titan and so on), but if it wasn't, it would be boring π I would love to give some more constructive feedback, but the only thing I could think of was already mentioned by @james-dunlap (exiting the seat by just moving instead of jumping), so: **To keep it short and simple: A very cool game! π** |
| Aug 4 15:19:11 | 46h 19m | Lamplight | ♥ 0 | Very cool game. I have to agree with @drtizzle, though: Shooting flares is pretty much the primary thing I was doingβ¦ All in all: Great job π! |
| Aug 4 15:26:17 | 7m 06s | The Political Juggle | ♥ 1 | Much fun βΒ really hilarious and an interesting interpretation of the theme. I also liked the balancing (at the beginning, I thought "nice idea, but boring", but it was got quite challenging toward the end). Great job π! |
| Aug 4 15:33:48 | 7m 31s | RUN! Before the power runs out! | ♥ 1 | Wow, that was intense! It was amazing how such a simple concept can get you thrilled. Innovation βΒ as you already acknowledged βΒ wasn't the thing this game will get the best score, but it needn't βΒ it was tense and fun and that's what it's about. All in all: **Great game,** thank you for sharing it π! |
| Aug 4 15:44:13 | 10m 25s | Turrets Turrets | ♥ 0 | That was fun! Since I don't have any criticism that wasn't already mentioned here to offer: **Great game, thanks for sharing π!** |
| Aug 4 17:33:05 | 1h 48m | Horrible Politics | ♥ 1 | **Great job, I really laughed a lot while playing. π** A few things** you could have enhanced / done to perfect the game: - When having selected ones choices, I would have wished for a "continue" button as I had already read the full statement. - After each week / conference / whatever, at least the first time it wasn't quite clear to me due to the delay if the game was over, there was a bug and it didn't take my answers or something like that. Because of that, I clicked the other two options (which is still possible after making ones choices), and as it then continued, I thought it had something to do with that. Again: An argument for the "continue"-button, or at least for not being able to select anything after all gaps are filled. - Sometimes, when selecting two long words, the text overflows it's container (speech bubble), that could be fixed. All in all, my suggestions are purely cosmetics, so they didn't impact my experience with the game at all, which is why β¦ **β¦ all in all, it's a hilariously funny and entertaining game π** |
| Aug 4 17:49:54 | 16m 49s | Lionel's Weekend | ♥ 3 | **Great game π.** As others have already mentioned, very innovative ("new genre"), and I really like how you have to rely on memory and sounds to navigate. The only thing I would have liked (but it's more challenging the way it is, so maybe, it's intentional?) would have been to climb down ladders, as sometimes, I didn't know where I was and would have liked to go to that computer the floor below, from where I knew the way to the doorβ¦ **All in all, very innovative, much fun and a great experience, thank you for sharing π.** |
| Aug 4 18:11:54 | 22m 00s | Battery Booster | ♥ 1 | **Great work!** I actually enjoyed that there were no AI cars (I like playing without AI and in such a short amount of time, working on a good AI is almost impossible in my opinion). And it's better to have no AI then to have a bad one. Also, I loved the simplicity of it. The feeling was just right when "driving". **All in all: A great game, especially for you second LD π** |
| Aug 4 18:37:53 | 25m 59s | End of Time | ♥ 1 | A really interesing, great concept with a great implementation. A few things you maybe could have enhanced: - **When clicking a button,** it sometimes happened that I wanted to click the button, but in this moment, a new question "came in" and I answered something I didn't want to answer in a way I didn't want. - **Maybe, making it a bit easier at the beginning** would have helped (like this, I got thrown into the game and had to study the UI while already getting thousands of questions) After getting into it it was much fun playing, although unfortunately I didn't have the time to complete the game (I'm looking forward to trying it again with more time) **All in All:** One of the most complex games I've seen so far, which means I pretty much like it however good or bad the game is π **Jokes aside: A great concept and a great game π!** |
| Aug 4 21:31:45 | 2h 53m | The forgotten mission | ♥ 2 | A great game, although, as others have already mentioned, it would be great if there was sound. The concept is one of the key strengths of the game βΒ I really like what you did out of the theme. Also, I liked the dialog system very much. **So, all in all:** **It's a great game π** βΒ it needs a bit of polishing here and there (especially audio and visual feedback), but I know it's hard to do those things in such a short amount of time, so: Well done! |
| Aug 5 10:33:47 | 13h 02m | Mothership | ♥ 0 | Probably the game I had the most fun playing so far. As I'm into space games anyway (and combined with strategy, I find it even cooler), I really enjoyed this game. All in all, I don't have any criticism to offer, so let's just conclude: **Very cool game, great job and thank you for sharing π!** |
| Aug 5 22:15:09 | 11h 41m | Light The Way | ♥ 1 | A decent game β not the best I've seen, not the worst. For your first Unity Game however, it is really good π. Gameplay would need a bit more polishing, but others have already mentioned that βΒ and I understand that would be mostly impossible in your first game made with Unity, so no hard feelings there π. The mood was excellent βΒ you get *5/5* there. It really suited the game and I really got a bit scared seeing the ghosts starting to move toward me. As there really isn't much more to say (that hasn't been said before), I conclude: **Great work, a decent game (a very good one for your first LD and Unity Game) => π** |
| Aug 5 22:23:59 | 8m 50s | Energy Drones | ♥ 1 | **That was fun!** I liked how you made it quite hard from the beginning, as it got me quite frustrated, and, to be honest, I liked that in a strange manner (it's this "it can't be that hard, this time, I have to get it"-feeling, if you know what I mean π) Jokes aside: There isn't much more to say. As @tyranosaw already mentioned, some visual polishing (especially on an enemy's death) would have been nice, but otherwise, I don't have any criticism to give. **Great game, much fun to play, thank you for sharing π** |
| Aug 5 22:35:28 | 11m 29s | Blitztanz | ♥ 1 | **Great work π!** I really liked the concept of it. You really took the theme and went into a direction I wouldn't have expected a game to go with this theme. Also, the implementation rounded everything of. One little thing: Although the power level meters are nice, but I didn't have the time to look over to them while playing as your game has a very high pace, which meant I just tried to balance it by intuition. Maybe, some more feedback would have been nice (colors getting less saturated or something like that). **All in all: a great game, much fun to play, so: Great work, thanks for sharing it π!** |