Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD38 → Feedback comment stats → giusex27
Feedback comments for LD38
giusex27's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | giusex27's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 2 22:59:07 | Antnator | ♥ 1 | I found the game great in terms of the gameplay, very simple to play and that's a plus, but I didn't really like that much the level design, it kind of got repetitive, nothing to do with it being hard (although it could at least have been a bit easier in the beggining in order to understand better the mechanics and get used to the dynamic of the game), still for a game made by a single person in just 48 hours though it does end up as a very solid product. Congrats on the game! | |
| May 3 01:53:32 | 2h 54m | Nuclear Treehouse | ♥ 1 | Well after playing a while through the game I can say that I noticed that it's the first game you've made (at least for the Ludum Dare, I think) and so what I have to tell you is that I found the gameplay completely fine and I loved the way the camera worked when you move but, the problem I had with the game is that it lacks a bit of personality and "soul", it feels like emotionless because it starts with no background story, description of the characters nor anything that gets you to immerse into the world of the game (plus the lack of music also doesn't help with this). So my humble opinion is that I suggest you that next time you should try something a little bit easier to work on but that it has it's own thing that makes it super special. That said, I do congratulate you for participating and encourage you to keep getting better at game development, hope my opinion is of some help for you! |
| May 3 02:09:17 | 15m 45s | The Little World | ♥ 0 | Really nice and simple game and concept, a job well done! The only things that lacks are music and a score system, like the comment above me says. |
| May 4 00:22:47 | 22h 13m | What Remains. | ♥ 1 | That was a very elaborate game, all I have to say is congrats on your final result, good job! (Next time though try to find some music too!) |
| May 4 00:40:51 | 18m 04s | Qwer CiTy | ♥ 2 | Wow, this really was a fun game, even though I'm terribly bad at it because I'm too nervous, but it's really innovative and different yet so simple. I really liked the tools you could use and how everything worked in the game. Really, all I have to say is congrats to all of you and keep going! |
| May 4 01:08:08 | 27m 17s | Pluto is a Planet | ♥ 1 | It's really funny that the background story of both of our games and the idea that gave birth to all that was really simillar, yet the games theirselves are really different. Now, about your game, the gameplay it's kinda tricky (even after you have read the instructions), so maybe if you would have made a little more clear the buttons and the options you could use for the game it could have been way better. Also, you should have allowed the option to control your planet to make the game more exciting and don't make it feel as slow as it ended up being. The fighting parts were really challenging and the most entertaining thing about the game. Overall, I wouldn't say I was that entertained playing but I definitely thought it was interesting, so next time you should maybe do something a little more simple but that works and flows way better, keep up the work!. (Also I had the same error the first comment mentions happening to me, so you should be careful next time about that too!) |
| May 4 01:46:56 | 38m 48s | For The Love Of Money | ♥ 1 | Well, the game is really simple, just a normal platformer, really fun to play but with nothing really new to add on, it lacks personality. Of course, that doesn't mean it can't be enjoyed because, like I said before, it was a really good retro style platformer, but after all it's just that and nothing more. Also, I didn't really see the relation with LD theme. So to sum up, I think the game is a really solid effort but next time you should think of doing something a little more innovative, because that's what gives games that special quality to attract people to go and play it. |
| May 4 02:02:32 | 15m 36s | The World At Your Feet | ♥ 1 | All I have to say is simply wow, you just made a game so incredibly simple, yet so fun to play, to the point that it gets really addictive. Gameplay is just fine, graphics are neat, the mechanics are flawless, maybe a lil back story and less repitive and interesting music would have made the game even better than what the actual game ended up being, but still I really congratulate for this effort and clever concept, and keep doing more! |
| May 4 22:56:21 | 20h 53m | Flight Club | ♥ 1 | After playing it what I can tell you is that it is definitely a really cool and original concept, the music was great, however about the gameplay it would have been better if you had like a really small visual tutorial at the beginning to help people understand better how the controls work in the game. Also, if you would have made much clearer when storms where approaching and also made the game a little easier at the beginning to let people adapt to the flow it would have made the game a little more exciting and attractive. Still, despise all that, what you ended up having was a very solid product and I do congratulate you with that. Keep more games coming! |
| May 4 23:22:06 | 25m 45s | Neuroso | ♥ 1 | After playing it all I can say is that I enjoyed playing it, it's got some really nice visuals, terrific music which fits just perfectly with the game, the concept is also really interesting and really elaborated, which is a surprise because of the short amount of time you have to finish the game. I found the gameplay also good, although it would have helped to put the end text button in another place cos it was kinda uncomfortable for me, but that maybe just me. Also, I had the same problem as @coleslaughter, after a couple of deaths, having to skip the dialogues got really frustrating so a skip dialog button or function would have also improved the gameplay a lot. But yeah, overall I thought the game was a really strong product, maybe improving some gameplay aspects would have made it a way better game that what it already is and I also wanna congratulate you guys for all the effort put into this, keep more games coming!!! |
| May 5 01:02:23 | 1h 40m | Expand Your World | ♥ 2 | What can I say? I loved this game so much! The concept itself which is so simple yet so innovative, loved the level design, the mechanics and puzzle-solvineg, the graphics look excellent and the sound fx was really good too, even though it was just one it fit so well with the whole game. My only complaints would be: 1) If this had any music it would have been perfect! But I do understand that since this was a compo entry you either didn't have much time to do that or simply didn't know too much of how to produce music. 2) If it had been a bit longer, maybe at least 5+ more puzzles it would have made it even more addictive and with a lot more of replay value. But that said, I still think this has been so far the best game I've played for this LD. Congrats and keep coming with more games mate! |