Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD37 → Feedback comment stats → Naca
Feedback comments for LD37
Naca's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Naca's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 14 00:02:00 | Rent for 30 seconds | Nice one! Very funny interpretation of the theme, and great replay value :D When I got only 1 star the first time, I felt like I needed another chance to do better. | |
| Dec 14 01:22:00 | 1h 20m | clapclap | This is simply brilliant :D I've been in so many concerts where people were mad about clapping. <br/> <br/>Got 273 points ;) |
| Dec 14 01:53:00 | 31m 00s | General Room | Very good entry. Lovely graphics and sound effects, every detail was taken into account. Also very fun to play, so congratulations :) |
| Dec 14 16:15:00 | 14h 22m | Empty | Guys, I'm officially a big fan of your work. Your games' look and feel, your style... everything is really unique, personal and easily identifiable. Aeroteque was absolutely wonderful, and this is a great continuation, although in a slow-paced way. As in Aeroteque, the theme is taken very literally, but the gameplay is delicious. Also, you have an extremely good taste for music and color ;) <br/> <br/>I got through level 3 but I didn't really understand how de vase disappeared :D Then I got stuck on level 5 or 6, so a "reset level" button would be very useful, as some people have commented above. <br/> <br/>My congratulations! I like this very much :] |
| Dec 14 21:25:00 | 5h 10m | The Painted Lady | Wow, I don't know what to do with this one. <br/> <br/>I love the game. Nice pixel art, music is superb, and what in my opinion is by far the best feature: use of the theme and the social aspect in general. <br/> <br/>Now, I can't rate your game as long as you don't provide a jam version. The only one you link up above was uploaded about 36 hours after the jam was closed. As you may understand, it's too much time to rate it without a jam version. I usually play post-jam versions, as they tend to be just bugfixes and a bit of polish, but currently I can't confirm this for yours, I'm afraid. <br/> <br/>That said, you've made a very good work. I'm now looking at your previous LD entries and they're pretty good too. Very different, that's why I like them. So, congrats folks :D |
| Dec 18 03:43:00 | 78h 18m | Simulated | Great work man! While not as crazy funny as Disarranged (which is actually one of my favorite LD games ever), this one is also a good entry. I finally managed to get to the ending :) |
| Dec 18 03:55:00 | 12m 00s | illusianator | Nice entry :) The voice recording quality is not very good, but I like the clean graphics and the game is fun to play. Loved the platformer part :D |
| Dec 18 04:02:00 | 7m 00s | Non Euclidean Room | It looks really cool! I love this kind of games, and you've got an impressive result in only 48 hours! Great work!. I didn't like music very much, but it was really fun to explore this space. Congrats :) |
| Dec 18 04:23:00 | 21m 00s | The Library of Babel | Yeeeaaah!! Good one! I've always found Borges' Library of Babel a really interesting concept. And I've been thinking about making a digital version too! It's good to see people sharing this curious ideas. <br/> <br/>Regarding to the game, I have some questions for you in order to see how accurate it is respect to the novel: are the books' contents randomly generated? In the novel they were not. There was a limited number of books, not infinite, and each one was unique and different from the rest. If you generate them randomly, there could be two or more identical books. If they're not randomly generated... then how did you do it?? :D |
| Dec 18 20:02:00 | 15h 39m | The Magic Workshop | The gameplay is quite good. Random events and survival mode give some replay value. Wizards always prefer bitcoins :D |
| Dec 18 20:17:00 | 15m 00s | The Last Fish | Oh man, this game is much more hardcore than what it seems at the beginning :'( Hope that is not based on a true story :D |
| Dec 18 21:38:00 | 1h 21m | One Room Hotel | One of the best games on this LD!!! I'm having a great time with it, very funny and addictive. Love the sound effects :D <br/> <br/>As some people have already noted, it would be an interesting feature to add the posibility to change the hotel layout between days. <br/> <br/>Anyway, congratulations for this awesome work!! |
| Dec 20 06:37:00 | 32h 59m | INFINIROOM | Well done! Simple mechanic, yet very fun and addictive. I like it! |
| Dec 20 07:09:00 | 32m 00s | Ask Her | Woooow, this is so heeeavy in the end. I had a great time figuring it out for myself, and then getting totally shocked :D It's a very innovative interpratation of the "one room" theme. Moreover, you've done a great work with graphics: while eliminating the need for pixel art or modeling, you've still managed to generate empathy and make visuals go along with narrative. So, good work! I liked it very much :) |
| Dec 20 22:52:00 | 15h 43m | Books! | "There should be a book in there entitled "Instructions" which will tell you what to do. If you find it, please let me know where it is." Hahahahaha sooo good man! You really understand what this library is :D <br/> <br/>I love this one! I've always found Borges' Library of Babel a super mind-blowing concept. And it was in my plan to make a digital version someday. But you (and someone else) have been faster than me :D In case you didn't noticed yet, there's another game in this jam about this topic, but it's not in full 3D: <br/> <br/>http://ludumdare.com/compo/ludum-dare-37/?action=preview&uid=38743 <br/> <br/>I'm glad to see this kind of fresh ideas come to surface. To take worlds from other media and to implement them as "games" or "simulations" is so interesting for me. <br/> <br/>Now, I want to ask you the same questions I've asked to the other developer, in order to see how accurate is the game respect to the novel: are the books' contents randomly generated? In the novel they were not. There was a limited number of books, not infinite, and each one was unique and different from the rest. If you generate them randomly, there could be two or more identical books. If they're not randomly generated... then how did you do it?? :D It's impossible to load all the variations of 410 pages x 40 lines x 80 characters. So you have to load them room by room. Then, they cannot be randomly generated, because that way could be repeated books. So in order to generate them, you have to sort them in some way. But then you have to "unsort" them. How? |
| Dec 22 02:26:00 | 27h 34m | The Wiggle Room | Hyper-funny game!! Pretty hard to beat though. Anyway, after a bunch of tries I managed to win the Final :P I had a great time! |
| Jan 2 05:06:00 | 266h 40m | One Womb | Our game is the sequel to yours :D Great use of the theme! |
| Jan 2 05:14:00 | 8m 00s | Alone | I like the topic you've selected for the "one room" theme. It's a very interesting work, imprisonment made gameplay, and very well made. If a game can explain what is to be in jail, this must be very close to do it. It doesn't let you interact with anything, it doesn't let you see beyond your cell... well, that's to be in an isolation cell. Graphics are pretty simple but help to preserve the dark mood. |
| Jan 2 05:18:00 | 4m 00s | Shadow Fencer Theatre | Very funny game :) Great graphics. |
| Jan 2 05:27:00 | 9m 00s | Sonder | Very good one! I like how you've used the theme. For me, waiting rooms are kind of special places, don't know exactly why. I also liked this "sonder" concept. After googling a bit, I've found this project that you may find interesting: http://www.kamaikamai.com/index.php/en/projects |
| Jan 2 05:35:00 | 8m 00s | Waiting Room - The Game | I like it! Short experience, yet fun to discover its content. I think it's a good first entry, and fits the theme well. Also, I like waiting rooms :D They've got something special. |
| Jan 2 21:43:00 | 16h 08m | SkyCorridor | Cool! I played it until the end (and there was a funny surprise :D). I find it pretty good balanced, not too hard but not too easy. Control is fine. It would be also funny to have kind of a "good ending" on the left side. When I saw the sign on the right side end I tried to go left at the beginning but there was nothing. |
| Jan 2 21:47:00 | 4m 00s | Tiny World | Nice entry! I had a good time collecting molecules :D |
| Jan 3 01:41:00 | 3h 54m | RAINWATER (is free) | Lovely game :) It's been a pleasure to play this. The gameplay is so smooth and polished, I've enjoyed quite for a while. Very funny take on the theme, and great job with sound and pixel-art! <br/> <br/>Felt like a genius when I figured out the relation between falling scrap and water streams :D My best score: 141 |