Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD35 → Feedback comment stats → David Cookie
Feedback comments for LD35
David Cookie's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | David Cookie's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 18 22:37:00 | I Have Brig Plans | The 1st game I play, and it's a real blast! The music and the way the sounds merge perfectly with it.. it's just fantastic. Congrats! | |
| Apr 18 23:00:00 | 23m 00s | Totem | Good game! Kinda have a Towerfall feeling, which is impressive in only 3 days :o |
| Apr 18 23:32:00 | 32m 00s | windowframe | A really ambitious concept perfectly made. Well done sir, and huge respect o// |
| Apr 18 23:55:00 | 23m 00s | Polydrone | Wow! Great visuals and super fun to play! Just hard to really target the enemies properly, cause I'm too focused on getting my ships avoid them. Otherwhise it's preeetty good for a 3 days dev :o |
| Apr 19 00:07:00 | 12m 00s | Revamp | The game is really good! And really hard ahaha <br/>Too bad there's no music though, but I can make you a little chip/retro loop if you're interested! |
| Apr 19 00:19:00 | 12m 00s | Soko Match | It has a really good potential to be a hit like Threes, but it lacks some audio for now (it's mostly for this reason that I enjoyed Threes). But it has the smooth, the colors.. basically everything else! So yeah, I hope you will keep working on it :) If you need any music, I could give you a hand! |
| Apr 19 00:38:00 | 19m 00s | Incognito | The game has a certain atmosphere that is quite appealing, mostly due to the great music! A good idea and a solid entry that respects the theme :) |
| Apr 19 01:16:00 | 38m 00s | Sub Dragon | How.. how did you make a game so perfect in 48h!!?? Easily the best entry I've played so far, so well polished in every aspect! |
| Apr 19 01:23:00 | 7m 00s | Astro Zoids | Well.. it's effectively a really fun game! :) |
| Apr 19 02:17:00 | 54m 00s | Court Mage | I was confused at first and then I saw the minimap ^^ A good take at the theme, and an ambitious game to do for a first LD. I hope you had fun making it too :) |
| Apr 19 02:29:00 | 12m 00s | Disdain | The idea and visuals are really cool! Love this little blur effect around the ball. It's difficult to do anything though but it's really fun to just move and transform ^^ I would love to see a fast racing game interrupted by arenas with this concept. Just some tweaks, and it could be a great game. You definitely have some potential, especially for a 1st jam! |
| Apr 19 13:28:00 | 10h 59m | Cadori | Really cool game! Love the graphics and the atmosphere. It's easy and fun to control :) Too bad I've got no friends to play with.. Must fight with myself xD |
| Apr 19 13:42:00 | 14m 00s | Her Home | Really nice visuals, it reminds me of Besiege! I don't really understand what I was doing but I enjoyed doing it :) The camera angles are sometimes genius, other times we don't really see where we're going to jump. Fortunately there are lots of aerial jumps xD <br/>A fresh and solid entry! |
| Apr 19 13:54:00 | 12m 00s | Reconfigure | I made it to wave 10 \o/ (yeah, kinda lame ^^). As a fan of Geometry Wars, this entry was a real blast for me! Pretty impressive for a 3 days dev I should say. Congrats :D |
| Apr 19 14:06:00 | 12m 00s | Purity | What a piece of art! The concept is simple but it's so coherent, so well polished. The visuals and audio are very original and merge perfectly. Just.. huge respect for you! <br/> <br/>Can't get past 4200pts, sadly :( |
| Apr 19 14:17:00 | 11m 00s | Trionic | Impressive graphics and game overall! Love to charge the big cannon, it's like a kamehameha :p |
| Apr 19 14:39:00 | 22m 00s | JaJa's Bizarre Transformer | I didn't understand at first that our bullets bounce back, creating one of the maddest manic shooter I've ever played xD The design and title are hilarous, and the music is catchy but doesn't really fit the game imo. <br/>Other than that, it's a very good entry! :D |
| Apr 19 14:50:00 | 11m 00s | Splitter Critters | Just marvellous. Visuals, concept.. it's just top notch! It doesn't look like a game from a jam at all :o Hope you'll continue it, it has a really good potential! |
| Apr 19 14:55:00 | 5m 00s | Snap & Shift | The concept is perfect and well executed :o Too bad it's so short and there's no music :/ We all want more obviously! |
| Apr 19 15:01:00 | 6m 00s | Copy-Paste | Great graphics, physics and concept. Maybe the most ambitious game I've played so far during this jam! It just lacks some audio to really become a hit! |
| Apr 19 15:23:00 | 22m 00s | The Killer's Apprentice | A game of atmosphere, pretty rare! The gameplay is not that thrilling and would deserve 3D sequences (especially when we see these beautiful backgrounds). But the narration pushed me to continue to find out what it's all about! <br/>So yeah.. An ambitious title that deserves more work, but I can clearly detect a potential: a Dear Esther-lika game, with a darker tone. Great work! |
| Apr 19 15:42:00 | 19m 00s | Spaceshift | A solid entry, pretty impressive for a jam! I find the graphics a little too cold though, but it's kinda adapted for a space environment I suppose. The 3D assets are good, maybe it's too bright to my taste. I would love to see this a little more in the dark, with lasers and lights that would illuminate our way. <br/>Otherwise the mouse wheel fonctionnality is top notch! It's really a "waoow" effect :o I can definitely see a rogue-like with lots of transformations using this system! |
| Apr 19 15:59:00 | 17m 00s | Turbo Transform | I've got no reward for completing the 5 levels without dying? Huge disappointment! ^^ <br/>The game is great.. really great! I had a lot of fun playing it :D Congrats! |
| Apr 19 16:45:00 | 46m 00s | Can't Drive This - #cantdrivethis | It's just fantastic! I've got no player 2 but it's already really fun just by myself (and quite hard ^^). The graphics are and audio are great too! |
| Apr 19 16:55:00 | 10m 00s | Shift 'n Drift | A pretty good interpretation of the theme! The physics and design are top notch, the game is not too hard, it's even relaxing with this little theme :) Overall it's very solid, there are really no downs in your game! Congrats |
| Apr 19 17:20:00 | 25m 00s | WolfBit | Great graphics & audio, original concept (it took me a while to really understand but it was quite fun when I eventually realize ^^). Very good entry, GG! |
| Apr 19 17:45:00 | 25m 00s | The Creation | Well.. That was unexpected ahaha. It's pretty cruel but that makes me laugh for a little moment ^^ The text at the end is surprisely appealing and makes us want to see more. In any case, good job for a 1st! |
| Apr 19 21:21:00 | 3h 36m | 55 Days | Excellent entry! Great quality in every aspect, really impressive for a jam. Respect! <br/> <br/>My score is 4904 :) |
| Apr 19 21:28:00 | 7m 00s | H2Olympics | Love you character and graphics overall, it's pretty cute! The concept is good but it gets repetitive, alternate the patterns more often would be good :) And also some little sound/effect feedbacks when we pass an obstacle correctly would be a great addition imo. <br/>I say this because I really enjoy the game and it has a real potential! Keep going :D |
| Apr 19 21:35:00 | 7m 00s | Shapegrammer | Really hard, especially with some shapes already rotated by defaults, but I had great fun with your game! Good looking, addictive, never ending. It has a huuuge potential! Congrats to you :D |
| Apr 19 21:45:00 | 10m 00s | Listen and Shift | It's a damn good entry for a 24h work :o Minimalist but it works well! I would have loved to see other patterns cause it gets a bit repetitive, but I think you didn't have enough time for that ^^ You made a polished and finished game, and that is already something impressive especially when it's that fun :) |
| Apr 19 22:35:00 | 50m 00s | Dr. Deckenstein: An Adventure in Severed Parts | For someone like me who plays Hearthstone and Hand of Fate, this entry is both awesome and disappointing. Awesome because it has all the basics for a great card game that combines these two titles, and disappointing because it gets a little repetitive and it lacks audio, which is a great deal for a card game in my opinion. <br/> <br/>Otherwise it's clearly impressive to have produced such a game in only 2 days, my Hearthstone daily playing surely has made me more demanding with card games ^^ <br/>But I really think going on for the 3rd day to add some audio would have really benefit the game.. but maybe you didn't have the time or you didn't want to. Either way, I'm really interested to see more! Hope you'll continue working on it :) |
| Apr 19 23:20:00 | 45m 00s | 2ShiftDrift | Love it! Reminds me of The Next Penelope in the same genre and feeling. Great visuals and music, fun to control! Really great, well done :) |
| Apr 19 23:42:00 | 22m 00s | Super Shape Drop | Just another Bejeweled game I think at first. And then I spend 20 minutes trying to beat the high score, but maan 80000 is high :o So yeah, not very original, but so well executed! <br/> <br/>You capture the essence of that type of game perfectly: feedbacks, lots of feedbacks.. either visual or audible ones. And combos, lots of combos. And the rewarding feeling when we're about to loose and we obtain a time extend. All these details that keep the player focus. <br/> <br/>Many entries may have a better concept than yours, but most of them lack of feedbacks, music or sounds (if it's not all three). It's also important to be able to polish a game, even in 3 days. That's why I'll reward you for that in my rating :) |
| Apr 20 00:03:00 | 21m 00s | The Magnificent Lepus | I didn't understand the game at all at the beginning, but I tried hard and finally be able to enjoy the full concept of your game! And I must say it was pretty good :D I finished all levels, all well designed. The difficulty scaling is well made, it's not too hard or too easy. <br/> <br/>If graphics and audio were just slightly better, it could have been the killer app of this jam! <br/> <br/>It's still overall a great entry :) |
| Apr 20 00:15:00 | 12m 00s | Oops! My Dear is a Deer | It's a superb concept, but it's just too bad it's a technical demo more than a game. You could make such great games with this MorphGun, it's so well made and the feedback is excellent! I imagine it took you a while to obtain this result. Congrats anyway, it's really cool! Just want some more ^^ |
| Apr 20 22:42:00 | 22h 27m | Shadow of the Red Hand | Should we call you andyman or 'hand'yman? :° Really a great idea and superb realisation! The gameplay is simple but works, and I love the fact that you can hear the boss coming with the guitar! The music is good but I think it doesn't fit to your design all that well, though it kinda represents the danger of being pursued. <br/>Would love to see you keep working on that! |
| Apr 20 23:24:00 | 42m 00s | Zen and the Art of Transhumanism | One of the most polished and ambitious game I've played so far! It's just amazing in every aspects, except for the "design your shape" phase that is a bit frustrating sometimes. It's just top notch otherwise! |
| Apr 20 23:38:00 | 14m 00s | Pluto's Tears | One of the few entries with some storytelling from I've played. Love how you make Pluto get revenge, even though the tone is quite sad :( <br/>The gameplay is not that exciting, but it's like Flow and Katamari. We play mostly for their graphics and atmosphere, and that works for you entry! I really wanted to see how it will end :) Well done! |
| Apr 20 23:43:00 | 5m 00s | Shieft | Really great idea! It was an ambitious one to make in 3 days but you perfectly managed it. It could really be the base for a complete released game imo! Congrats :p |
| Apr 21 00:02:00 | 19m 00s | Forest Rampage | Soo.. I don't really have the feeling it respects the theme. It's more like a Skyrim-like where we can switch characters, which is still pretty amazing btw in only 3 days! It's kinda a tower defense too but it's difficult to see that aspect: it lacks some feedbacks about enemies or when we pass to the next wave for example. <br/> <br/>BUT, the game is pretty fun and is clearly ambitious in design! I run like a crazy while casting spells on anyone in my way. I really loved the fast-paced movement that reminds the old FPS (it surely would be boring with Skyrim speed). <br/> <br/>So great work all the team! Keep doing good stuff :) |
| Apr 21 00:14:00 | 12m 00s | Lumiania | Not that original but it's very cool to play and really well polished! I love when everything has a feedback and you are the example of what it should be done :) Well done Yword! |
| Apr 22 17:06:00 | 40h 52m | ShapeShift for Cheese | A great point and click with impressive graphics in such a short amount of time! Well done |
| Apr 22 17:18:00 | 12m 00s | Party at the Knightclub | It's just a perfect entry for me! It looks like a real game and I was so sad when I get to the "to do" point, I wanted to play more!! But I guess it's already pretty amazing content for 3 days ^^ The tracks are really great too! Huge congrats to you! |
| Apr 22 17:39:00 | 21m 00s | The Great Biohazard Escape | The end is just a black screen, much sad :( I wanted to see an ending after all these efforts ^^ Great game overall, a good point and click not that easy! I had to read the walkthrough for the 2nd room, I didn't see we could click at the bottom (a dedicated button could have been better). <br/> <br/>Otherwise, it's a very solid entry, with some nice touch and atmosphere. The music is a little bit repetitive but add to the tension. Very coherent, well made! |
| May 2 14:21:00 | 236h 42m | Shifted Defence | Always nice to see some tower defense games :) It was quite fun to play and would deserve and enhanced version with better graphics and audio imo. Otherwise, good job! |
| May 2 14:28:00 | 7m 00s | THE SHAPELINGS | I love Lemmings game design, and you adapt it really well to the theme! Now, it just needs some more work on graphics, audio and level design and you're good for a post jam version :) Well done! |
| May 2 14:39:00 | 11m 00s | RainbowSnakeFail | The visual is somehow attractive, and overall it's a pretty cool experiment for a project made in such a short amount of time! It obviously lacks some audio and an explanation/objective for this jam but.. I feel like you're onto something, and you could transform this proto into something glorious! Maybe a game like Flow could do the trick, or a drawing game, or a much more ambitious game based on this "character" (I love its movements!). |
| May 2 14:48:00 | 9m 00s | Hard to know | Ooh, I'm the "Great Cookie"? :o Cool writing skills right here, even if there's some mistakes in the english version (but it's reasonable ^^). The 1st novel-game I've played so far in this jam, and I'm surprised I didn't see more as the theme fits quite well imo. It's a little short and it lacks a little ambient music, but otherwise it's pretty well done! |
| May 3 01:20:00 | 10h 32m | Shape Attack | I think the spawn of enemies drastically rises after each restart, making the game almost unbeatable! It's a shame though, as it looks like a professional mobile game. Just lacks some audio and it needs some polish on the difficulty (more like a debug ^^), and you're good to go :) Well done! |
| May 3 01:31:00 | 11m 00s | Goblinesque Shadows | Ok, can't get pass the level 3 where the enemy jumps on me right at the start xD Graphics and controls remind me of The Impossible Game, but it really lacks a music and it needs some tweaks on the difficulty. Also, didn't really find the link with the theme but maybe it was after level 3 ^^ Good job anyway! With some more work, it could become a good game as it is already pretty fun and satisfying to shoot on enemies :p |
| May 9 22:18:00 | 164h 47m | Prince Charmless | Perfection! The platformer is already really good and there's an even better game with the mirror stage!? Just amazing how you manage to do that in just 3 days. You could almost sell it right now with this level of polish! Well done! |