Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD16 → Feedback comment stats → mathias

mathias

Feedback comments for LD16

mathias's games and stats for all events →

Timestamp	Since previous	Game	mathias's comment
		Topsy Turvy	Really really hard.
		Ezo	Very good audio, otherwise I don't really get it, sorry. Is there game in there or is it just a multiple choise experience?
		Soundscape	Great idea, but too hard for me to actually have the patience to finish it. Maybe it would've been more playable if you'd use stereo sound. And maybe defining turning a bit better, I had no idea how much every press turned the player.
		Forest	Was it actually a game? Seemed more like wondering around in a (pick your own city) museum of modern arts.
		5 Colors: Pandora	Nice complete game with a good idea supporting it. The controls were a bit too "fiddly" for my taste though. I didn't have the patience to continue after I would've had to start backtracking the levels. (Thanks for the youtube footage so I could actually see it played through!)
		This is Infinity	The brain damage inducing flashing gfx make this unplayable for me. And like others have said, audio should be really done by yourself.
		Apocalypse Adventure	Really hard. Awkward controls, I never know what I should click and when. Nice amount of content done in such a short time.
		Cat Planet	Not very innovative gameplay wise, but very fun and funny, love the cats. Bonus points for great music tracks too! Way too hard for me to actually finish it.
		Penguinagain	That was cool. Altough I don't think you're very nice teasing the penguins by placing the food just above their heads. :)
		the light at the end of the tunnel	Was interesting until I got stuck inside ground.
		Deep Field	Quite cool game for such a simple thing, I hope you continue this. Reminds me a bit of Strange Adventures in Infinite Space.
		Explorium	Graphics were nice, fun to look at. I could've used some more things to do. And a minor point, in readme.txt you say that you got the ambience sound from some website when technically we are supposed to make all sound ourselves. (not that I care, just thought I'd let you know)
		MindPloration	Nice use of the theme. I explored different pathways and eventually got to "my son" and the dead end text, I guess that was it? I felt that I didn't have much choises to do gameplay wise.
		EchoExplorer	Loved it. The small bits of dialogue gave it life.
		Zelnick	I wished that it would've moved on a bit faster, interesting otherwise.
		Redwalk	Nice start, I wish there was a game in there.
		Jimmy's Adventure	Nice graphics. A few pixel perfect jumps required could've been fixed. Otherwise, just needs more content and gameplay elements.
		I Never Missed Anyone Until They Were All Gone	Didn't really figure out what to do, maybe there wasn't anything since its unfinished. Nice idea for an art style, keep working on it!
		Drowning	Quite an interesting and a bit scary even, but was there a game in there?
		Hole Jump	Reminds me of the recent aaaaAAaaaAAAaaA game. Could've used a bit more something to do.
		Do you see it? I saw it	Had the potential to be a fun game, but the technical implementation leaves it a bit weak. I was constantly getting stuck everywhere and eventually ended in a room in the house from where I couldn't get out. Funny sound effects and lots of bugs to find.
		Scouting only!	(It's the most fun part of Civilization for me too btw., I usually stop playing after that.) I had difficulty understanding what each of the tiles represented and the controls were really hard. I could complete it easiest just by running from wall to wall.