Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD52 → Feedback comment stats → pndaa
Feedback comments for LD52
pndaa's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | pndaa's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 10 08:38:34 | Scoopy the Spoon Thief | ♥ 1 | Got all of them ! Good job on the game it was really fun. I could play that for hours if there were more levels. | |
| Jan 10 08:59:54 | 21m 20s | Harvestar: Spaceship Farmer | ♥ 2 | I complete the voyage ! I really liked the mood and the visual. But it finished right when I understood how it worked. I have to say that I didn't fully knew what I was doing until the last level. Things that I didn't got in the first games: - You can only play 3 cards. - There are random modifiers on top of the growing plants that will mess up with what you want to do. There is too much to understand at the first level. You could add a new mecanics after each levels to make it easier to understand for the player. Nevertheless it was fun to play. I did a second run to enjoy the game fully. Good job ! |
| Jan 10 09:37:14 | 37m 20s | Necromancer Harvest | ♥ 1 | I played as much as I could but I feel that there is no ending. The game looks good. You didn't made the assets but you chose them. And you used them well. I just feel that the music doesn't really fit. I made a list what I think could be improved: - The "how to play" screen or your game description page should tell more thing about the game. Games are more enjoyable when you understand them. For example: - What does the "bubbles" that the enemies drop does. I understood the white bubble spawn a slave. But others I don't know. - Why do you need to buy fields? I feel like it increase attack speed but I'm not sure. - It took me few minutes to understand how to attack. I spammed click, but you need to let it pressed. - It would be good to have a "dead time" between waves. To let the player construct the fields needed by slaves. - The font is really hard to read. - The music doesn't loop. (On Unity, the AudioSource component you have "loop" checkbox) - You have a typo "Not Enoguh Field". Good job on making your game! |
| Jan 10 17:02:36 | 7h 25m | Bloodsoil | ♥ 0 | Sans titre.png The game looks really good and it was a lot of fun. The boss was really well made. It's not often that ld games are fun until the end. It took me too long to understand the red bar wasn't a life bar. But after that it was a blast. Good job ! |
| Jan 11 09:43:15 | 16h 40m | Disassembly Line | ♥ 2 | I don't know if there is an ending. I played until I had more than 20 points. It was fun at the begining, then a little repetitive, perhaps I played too long :D. The game is a too easy. I never had to sprint, which I think tells something is wrong with the game balance. The game is understandable without reading the instruction, good job on that. And the audio fits well. Good work! |
| Jan 11 10:36:22 | 53m 07s | Orchard Archer | ♥ 2 | Sans titre.png Fun game. I gave up at the last quest after 4 tries. I had purple fruits that was making my golden apples falls before they being grown. And I didn't manage to kill purples soon enough :(. It was really really fun. The only thing is a HP bar could have been helpful. The bow feels really great. And the purple fruits that become an enemy is a neat idea. Good job ! |
| Jan 11 11:01:52 | 25m 30s | Harvest Survivor | ♥ 3 | After few tries I decided that those enemies weren't worst killing. My strategy became to run and farm. I just buy movespeed and farmspeed ameliorations. Sans titre.png So I had few enemies tracking me. But I managed to win !!! Sans titre.png Good job it was a blast ! |
| Jan 12 10:23:37 | 23h 21m | The organ trees | ♥ 1 | I liked the 2D/3D graphics. The ground doesn't looks good though. Like already mentioned, it would be better to not have to start again each time we quit the UI. I also didn't understand the difference between harvesting a stomach or a bowel. Do you earn more money? I plaid until I got a bug. I was stucked on that screen after buying an upgrade, I believe it was the knockback one: 2023-01-12 11_12_18-The organ trees.png |
| Jan 12 10:40:09 | 16m 32s | Harvest Mouse: Veggie Survivor | ♥ 0 | Classic but fun. Good job ! I found a sweet spot at the top to easily win a lot of points ! sanstitre.png |
| Jan 12 21:01:40 | 10h 21m | King of Veggies | ♥ 1 | I succeed to do 184. After that it became hard with those 8s. The game is really addictive. It got a 2048/Tetris kind of addiction. I'm not sure I can make a better compliment^^. The sfx is brillant. Good job ! |
| Jan 13 08:04:12 | 11h 02m | The Pets Over The Innsmouth | ♥ 3 | The game looks really good. Those arts are wonderfull. And the story really add something to the game. The music fit perfectly. But the gameplay is really hard. I feel like we don't win enough souls when killing Cs. And since I can't tell when one of them is gonna die, it is hard to keep a good amount of C. By the way I don't know why but your game is 3go big. Maybe because of the images. |
| Jan 26 23:22:07 | 327h 17m | Carrot | ♥ 1 | Did few game then I also followed the A.B.C mantra. That made me succeed to do 132 carrots ! Had great fun, it is really well polished. Thanks for the game ! |
