Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD52 → Feedback comment stats → Mohamed_DKD
Feedback comments for LD52
Mohamed_DKD's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Mohamed_DKD's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 14 03:20:35 | Last Harvest | ♥ 1 | Love the joke and the atmosphere, but the controls seems too hard for me side note: I had a hard time running it at first since the exe kept saying "Visual Studio C++ runtime required" but managed to get the required files at the end. | |
| Jan 14 03:33:04 | 12m 29s | CRAWLER CRAWL | ♥ 1 | love the atmosphere and the art, really helps in selling the idea of fear and claustrophobia, but feels like the controls are bit hard to grasp especially hitting the insects with the net |
| Jan 14 03:43:48 | 10m 44s | Harville | ♥ 2 | Very nice concept, but still needs a lot of work. Love the idea of organs expiring and the funny dialogues |
| Jan 14 03:53:27 | 9m 39s | Harvest Monster | ♥ 1 | One of the best mechanics and gameplays I found so far XD. Love how the plants are both your resource and enemy. Would love for future versions to have a way to either heal or fight back. But obviously for a game jam this here is more than enough. Good job |
| Jan 14 04:07:55 | 14m 28s | LEXICONSTRUCTOR | ♥ 1 | Very fun game indeed Love how you "harvest" words and letters |
| Jan 14 04:26:18 | 18m 23s | When It's Harvest Time | ♥ 1 | The humor is definitely strong in this one XD Just like the other person said "it is hard to not spoil the game", but I think you could still put the first picture of the game, but with no context XD Also, it is almost impossible to use the cash, so it is better to rebalance the location to use cash |
| Jan 18 06:05:15 | 97h 38m | Harvest Construct Produce Destroy | ♥ 2 | Nice solid RTS game with tutorial, multiple levels and multiple units. Excellent job indeed. However, I feel like considering the pathfinding issues, the map sizes should've been much smaller to allow for a smoother gameplay experience and let us focus more on the positives of your game rather than the issues. Also, the differences between the missions wasn't large enough for me to play all of them as it just felt like the same mission but with more complex map and more enemies. So, personally I would have preferred if the game only had 2 or 3 levels but more polish. Super great work for a jam nonetheless ^_^ |
| Jan 18 16:40:12 | 10h 34m | Stalk: Blood Harvest | ♥ 1 | Very nice game idea, I love how you linked zombie hordes with harvesting and protecting your plants 😃 , but here are a few points to keep in mind for future improvements and other jams: -Add more screenshots to the game to make it clear what does the game involve -Try to limit file sizes in game jams, not everyone loves the idea of downloading an almost half gigabyte game -itch.io is better than google drive as it allows the game to be shown to more people, and jammers are more familiar with it -the enemies just disappearing doesn't feel rewarding, especially since you already have attack animation -the game needs more sounds -The enemies almost never attack the crops, so you need to balance between attacking the player and the plants -remember to play other people's games to receive more feedback on your game On the plus side, one thing I really liked about your game is how you start without a weapon and then go and pick it up. It is a small detail, but very lovely (it feels as if you were farming and then switched to "killing" mode) |
| Jan 19 05:57:43 | 13h 17m | Glitter | ♥ 1 | Hi I think you have the project as hidden as the itch.io link leads to a 404 error |
| Jan 19 06:09:25 | 11m 42s | The cornman | ♥ 0 | Very fun game. Feels like an old arcade, but with 3d art and webGL . Only thing missing is a score to give us an indication of how well we did and a way for the game to become harder (as it feels that the game wasnt getting harder, or maybe wasnt getting harder fast enough) |
| Jan 19 06:17:41 | 8m 16s | Blood Harvest | ♥ 1 | Love the game. My score is 496 s'corns. I think I might have broken my mouse in the process XD Love the game and atmosphere. Would love it if first enemies actually died and then progressively received harder to kill enemies |
| Jan 19 06:24:56 | 7m 15s | Fruit and Souls | ♥ 1 | Hi @neonspectre Have you updated the game yet, or it is lost to time? On a side note, I liked the character sprite and the attack animation |
| Jan 22 03:27:08 | 69h 02m | Potion Panic | ♥ 1 | Sask Team here (Robert the Druid)!. I see that the game is still as hard for me as it was two weeks ago 😢 😆 . Not sure if the RNG was just bad or I accidently angered too many enemies at once, but I ended up facing 6 slimes, 3 frogs and 5 skeletons all at once in the 2nd level 😲 (obviously I died XD). Nonetheless, awesome game with awesome graphics, and I especially loved that it has controller support (albeit it doesn't work for the home screen) |
| Jan 22 03:32:39 | 5m 31s | Fruit Frenzy | ♥ 0 | Sask team here (Robert the Druid) Loved the atmosphere, just serene "stardew valley" vibes while you are collecting the harvest |
| Jan 22 03:54:17 | 21m 38s | Harvest Homes | ♥ 0 | Very deep game indeed. Good job. Protip: in case you skipped the tutorial, E is for interacting with doors and items. The only thing I would like to point out is that the pacing feels very slow, especially since you have to rebuild three house |
| Jan 22 04:40:42 | 46m 25s | The Accursed Sandy Loam | ♥ 0 | Sask team here *Robert the Druid*. Loved the game concept. I think it only needed a more polished art and some SFX, and some game balancing and it would be a very good game. Also, I found a way to "hack the score". Just kept on building water sprinklers and nothing else and ended up having a score of 455 (I think this score is very close to the theoretical limit of having all green fields). |
| Jan 22 04:47:42 | 7m 00s | Berry Berry Berry Tangerine | ♥ 0 | Got a score of 7600. Super chill and simple game, with nice juice effect for extra game addiction |
| Jan 22 05:01:00 | 13m 18s | Farm Tower Defense | ♥ 0 | Made it all the way to level 14. I think it is impossible to beat the game after that XD |
| Jan 27 06:38:39 | 121h 37m | Overroasted | ♥ 1 | once I understood how the game played I really liked it. with some audio and high score or losing condition it would be a very solid jam game. Great job |
| Jan 27 06:50:54 | 12m 15s | Vegetable fighters! | ♥ 0 | Fun game. The dragging of the seeds gets tedious, especially in the last two stages, but it is funny seeing fruits vs vegetables XD |