Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD46 → Feedback comment stats → stmatn
Feedback comments for LD46
stmatn's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | stmatn's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 20 19:42:37 | Compfire | ♥ 3 | Your game looks really nicely crafted. The ambient sounds are atmosperic (especially the crackling ofthe fire) and the graphics look very nice. Gameplay is fun for some time. Once you collect a hand full of upgrades you become a machine that blazes through the forest smashing down trees and hurling a metric ton of wood to the fire, which is fun at first. Since it feels like a positive feedback loop, you seem to get more and more powerful without a real goal. It yould have been nice, if the fire would increase the burn rate over time or you had something like a final tree to chop down. All in all great work! P.S.: Is the typo in the title screen of the german version a joke I do not get? (L**o**gerfeuer) | |
| Apr 20 19:58:37 | 16m 00s | ZenTuree | ♥ 0 | That was quite a relaxing experience :) When I first read that the tree needs two years to grow, my first thought was that you did not really follow the tipp that the game should be beatable in about 5 Minutes :D Adding the LD-Modes was a very good idea ;) When the tree is fully grown, the framerate significantly dropped for me. All in all nice work. |
| Apr 20 20:17:27 | 18m 50s | DeeperWeDelve | ♥ 1 | I really liked that the events were not hardcoded but would change on different playthroughs. Nice work! |
| Apr 20 20:32:18 | 14m 51s | The Mad Piper | ♥ 1 | Nice game. I like the graphcs, but the game is not very hard. It would be nice, if the difficukty would increase over time. The enemies could for example have more and more hitpoints. I got the following error twice in the following situation: * I had a basic tower placed * That basic tower was selected * I was in build wizard mode * Mouse over the basic tower * Right clicked mouse Unbenannt.png |
| Apr 20 20:45:55 | 13m 37s | Floyd's Fire | ♥ 2 | Nice little game. I like the graphics :) Battling ghosts seems pointless, since they seem to always cost more than they give. It also seemed that the light will not go out if you keep moving. Finally an end goal would be nice. All in all nice work :) |
| Apr 20 21:03:02 | 17m 07s | Tiny Fragments | ♥ 1 | The game looks and feels really nice! Reminds me of classic flash games for some reason :) Great work! |
| Apr 20 21:10:46 | 7m 44s | Just Fishing | ♥ 1 | This was a really relaxing experience :) Staying alive in survival mode seems quite hard. Maybe I do not get the biting mechanig completely. Awesome work! |
| Apr 20 21:29:31 | 18m 45s | Keep It Alive | ♥ 3 | This is really amazing. I really like the artstyle, the sfx are perfect and the world is very interesting. Awesome job! |
| Apr 20 21:45:17 | 15m 46s | Crackles | ♥ 4 | This is realy nice. It reminds me of Tasty Planet, which I like very much. The artstyle is great and at some point it has this satisfying point, where growth seems to accelerate. However, unfortunately this stops at the last stage. It is really hard to burn houses, since you shrink quite fast at that stage. I would rather had grown indefinitely until everything would have been burned and the snowmen would have melted for good ;) All in all really awesome work :) |
| Apr 21 22:26:01 | 24h 40m | Save It With Fire!!! | ♥ 1 | I really liked your game :) I think after reading the instrucions it is not that hard to understand. The only thing that may be a little bit tricky are the mixing recipes, since the color codings are not completely obvious. I also think that the game is balanced pretty on point. It leaves enough room in the first level to explore and find the dispensers, but keeps you busy on later stages. Unfortunately the mixer kept bugging out which did not let me finish the fifth level. On my first playthrough it gave me fire after inserting only iron. However after that it would not accept anything at all. On My second playthrough the same kept happening, but I always inserted sulfur, before taking out the fire. Though, at one point I forgot that and took the only-iron-fire. I somehow managed to make the mixer work again, but at that point I had lost so much time that I could not keep up with the demand on mixed materials. Nonetheless, I like how you need to plan a bit ahead on the last stages :) All in all great work :) |
| Apr 30 12:17:08 | 205h 51m | 3 Minutes To Freeze | ♥ 0 | Nice game! I like the graphics :) It seems quite important to plan theroutes through the forest ahead of time in order to not freeze to death and also not leave behind single sticks. I hab the feeling that you need to collect all the sticks. However I am not sureif the fire burns faster if it is bigger. That might be an interesting mechanic. It would demand to find a trede-off between building time for collecting wood and conserving already collected fuel. All in all good work! |
| Apr 30 12:35:54 | 18m 46s | Grow! | ♥ 1 | I like your game. The graphics look nice, sounds are fitting and gameplay feels good. On my first try I ran out of water pretty quickly, but on the second one I grew a nice plant :) I do not exactly why I wanted to explore the borders of playing field, but I did so and discovered the ground water. I think at that pint the game broke in some way, because I knew I could pretty much do what i want at that point without thinking about water conservation. I am not sure if it would be more fun if there was no ground water. It might be interesting to test that ;) |
| Apr 30 12:56:23 | 20m 29s | Square Loves Circle! | ♥ 1 | I really enjoyed playing the game. Well... most of it. The last level was really hard, but also satisfying to finish at last :) The floaty controls are a bit hard to master, but I am not sure if they should be changed or not. All in all great game! |
| Apr 30 21:15:19 | 8h 18m | Queen's Rose Garden | ♥ 0 | The game was really fun. At first I did not realise that you can turn the patterns. And I managed to beat the game on the first try, so it might be made a bit harder. All in all great game :) |
| May 4 15:39:21 | 90h 24m | Entropia | ♥ 2 | Nice game :) I like the idea of trading mechanics, but I did not realize at first that the planets would give you the resources for free. The artstyle is really beautiful and sound are fitting. Unfortunately I ran into the same bug that has already been described here, so my score does not count ;) |
| May 4 15:48:11 | 8m 50s | Save the torch! | ♥ 1 | Nice game! I like the graphics a lot :) However it is quite difficult, since the fire goes out so quickly and flames hurt you, when you do not hold the torch. That was a bit frustrating, however it was really fun to play :) |
