Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD45 → Feedback comment stats → CodeKoto
Feedback comments for LD45
CodeKoto's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | CodeKoto's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 24 14:52:53 | Neon Void | ♥ 2 | I quite enjoyed the gane, i can't really find any downsides to be honest. The only thing i could think of is that it was slightly underwhelming but when you die you just try again. If there was a bit more content with using all of the powers with some better controls (maybe using the mouse and shift/ctrl to decide which ability is used). But otherwise, really good game I am looking forward to what you will be making in the future ;D | |
| Oct 24 15:26:51 | 33m 58s | The Carpenter | ♥ 3 | I loved the graphics, but it seemed some of the generation was a bit laggy for me, though that wasn't much of an issue. What made the game unesseceraly harder is the "slidey" movement when you collect materials. In my opinion you could have removed the building part as the whole game is pretty much collecting the materials. Overall a good entry, i wish you best of luck for all your next games as well. |
| Oct 24 16:17:04 | 50m 13s | Fragmented Reality | ♥ 1 | Wow, haven't seen a game like this in a while during a Ludum Dare, and a Compo at that! First of all, i love the simplistic design that you made, it's clean, consistent, and doesn't hurt the eye. The effects and sounds fit very well, they almost blended with the music, bfxr came in handy too i see :P The gameplay was fun and not too challenging, except for the last part where i think it should've been a bit slower when you die. I loved the littlbe pieces of extra levels where you can collect the music parts, it made me want to replay the game because of it, music itself was pretty good too, pleasant and ambient. You've simply done a good job, well done! |
| Oct 24 16:30:04 | 13m 00s | Osage | ♥ 1 | The game looks quite good, i loved the art style. However it was a bit confusing what the purpose of the gameplay was, i as collecting acorns and droplets but that was about it, the platformer wasn't that fun neither was the collecting. Good job overall though! I am sure you will do even better next time. |
| Oct 25 17:43:32 | 25h 13m | Rude Bear Refurbished | ♥ 0 | I general I enjoyed the game, starting from an empty house is a unique idea. What I like: - I liked the little details that were in the game such as the time in the clock actual changing and items having different weights. - The characters were unique with their one quirks and that added to the atmosphere. - There were different radios which were quite cool, the comedic house was quite funny xD, I felt the game dev soul right there ;D. - There were a decent amount of items that you could find which was interesting to find. - The map was quite decently big which made it interesting to explore with the previous points. - I liked the fact that you could make a quite unique house and almost all the objects could be picked up. What I didn't like: - When you die you restart from the beginning, even though it's somewhat fair, that's what prevented me from ultimately not finishing the game. - There was a lack of sounds of punching and getting punched, picking up and placing things down etc. - The combat was a bit laggy and at some places, it made it quite unneeded as IMO i think the game would be more fun as a stealth/stealing game not a fighting game with 2 buttons. - The camera was a bit too small thus I was at times losing my directions. - There wasn't a particular challenge for fighting or stealing the items, only repetitiveness which could be replaced by something more fun and dynamic. - The doors were quite confusing and weird when they were vertically placed. - The objects lacked collision thus it didn't really feel as I was building "something". What you could add/improve: - Add a small pin to your house which would show you the direction of your house where ever you are. - Make the doors properly connect to the walls to avoid confusion of the colliders. - Add some better way to place the objects, like a snap to a position or something to give more structure to your house. Overall a really good game IMO, there are just some things you might need to rework, but to be honest, I can see this becoming a small game that you can finish and maybe even post on steam. It just lacks polish and proper features, extended gameplay and mechanics. Continue developing ;D |
| Oct 26 09:56:56 | 16h 13m | Game from the Void | ♥ 2 | I loved the voice acting and the simplistic atmposhpere, you actually tricked me by saying "It's not one of those games with multiple endings..." And i didn't believe you so i knocked all the white boxes out just just for the hell of it, well nothing happened of course XD. The only thing that was really missing is the boss feed back, i only heard him in pain once and that's it. I only realized that i need to keep spamming after multiple tries. Otherwise great game! (You could even extend it and make it a full fledged game for steam imo) |