Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD57 → Feedback comment stats → alyd asmar
Feedback comments for LD57
alyd asmar's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | alyd asmar's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 9 14:39:54 | Cursor Descend | ♥ 1 | OMGGG we also had the digestive track idea during our brainstorming, I'm so happy someone did it 😂 My trackpad is quite bad + I already have chronic tendonitis lmao, so I did not get past the small intestine. BUT the concept is super cool, and the game is simple but very efficient!! Nice one 😍 | |
| Apr 9 16:06:16 | 1h 26m | Journey to the Centre of the Ocean | ♥ 2 | This made me so nostalgic 😭 Great game, so many features!! (I didn't expect so many) I've just played for like 40 minutes and I could've played more if I had more time 😭 which is quite a lot for a jam game ✌️ Also loved the music!!! super chill, contrasts with the game category, but also reminds you that you're in the sea somehow? Anyway, thanks for the game! 🌟 |
| Apr 10 05:18:27 | 13h 12m | Escape From GR0K Tower | ♥ 1 | I liked the fact that there were many different interactibles, and that the first time you encounter each of them there's some puzzle mechanic of "what should I do to open this door". The fact that some are not very visible is quite cool too. The graphics, music and overall feel are quite coherent and pleasant. However, I think that I would've enjoyed the game more without the randomness. If it wasn't random, you could learn the moves of each floor, and get a sense of progression. In the current state, I would just die randomly on a peak between floors 75 and 85, without getting any feeling that the next run would be better, and that was a bit frustrating (I did not finish the game sorryyyy). This would also leave room for cool level design. The opening mechanism could still be random and randomly positioned, I think this was a really cool aspect of the game. Anyways that's just my feeling, because for me it would've increased the replayability. But the game is quite fun as it is! Good job! |
| Apr 11 04:50:50 | 23h 32m | Detector | ♥ 1 | Yaaayyy I won!!! 🎉 Thank you so much for having a level-based restart system, when I lost at lvl 2 I was so afraid of having to restart from scratch lol. Very simple mechanic, but well balanced, finding the pieces of metal was the right level of hard. The game is also quite polished, except for the graphics of the main game (but they're efficient), it's nice to have clear instructions, and a title screen (with some nice music too)! About the theme, it's there, but I would say maybe a bit weakly? but that's just a personal feeling, that maybe changing the "meter" info to a "depth" info for example would've added a bit more of... idk, 3D feeling lol. Anyway thanks for this game! |
| Apr 14 06:56:19 | 74h 05m | Voidwood | ♥ 5 | WOOOOW niceee @nuelijarma Same as you I died right before the giant pool, and... well redid the whole thing and indeed we both died 2 meters away from the end with the mischievous trap lol. Did not expect the second part, it was the best surprise, and also the end cinematic is super cool! **Graphics**: over the top, I absolutely loved the background art, the fossils in the first part, and the aesthetics of the second part. Eyessss + chromatic aberration 👁 💜 💜 💜 **Music**: not a musician here, but I loved the vibe and the progression! Gave me the feeling of speed. **Game design**: loved the "left or right... left or... AAAHHH" moments, controlling multiple roots at the same time, the fact that it can get hard to water some late roots, and also sometimes you end up with all your roots in the same place and you know that you're one bad decision away from losing them all... (cf. the end lol). **Prog / game feel**: The controls feel very nice, and also fair (I felt like I deserved all my deaths lmao). Liked that the scroll slows down when you drink. Also good use of SFX, the rock one is a bit louder than the rest which is good because with many roots it's easy to miss one being blocked! Overall a very polished entry and a super cool and inspiring game, thank you so much! ✨️ |
| Apr 21 09:08:31 | 170h 12m | Wamps Hate Falling Apples | ♥ 1 | Absolutely LOVED the intro 😂 pure gold Liked the epic music that reminded you that this was not just a game for the wamps 😆 Very cool gameplay, the first time around I was wondering if it was too easy, but then trying to beat the game as fast as possible ends up being quite a challenge! My lowest time was around 220s and I still felt like I made some lame choices lol. Thanks a lot!! |
| Apr 21 12:17:09 | 3h 08m | The Cleaner of the depth | ♥ 4 | Amazing game. Didn't have any trouble playing once I had read the instructions, and once I understood that the cleaning area is where the bird is (as opposed to in front of it, which was my first instinct, but the animations made it quite easy to adjust!). Obviously loved the art. The watercolor effects, all the little animations, the variations, wow. The game feel is equally amazing. The camera turning, how the bird's movements follow the slopes, the fact that basically if you stop every time you hear a nice tune, you are already in the right spot to clean... The sound design is also very cool, not too crowded, so the music is basically only the teeth sounds... I'm slightly frustrated I never managed to finish it though, if there's an end??? Cleaned all the teeth multiple times, but each time I "finish", nothing happens, so I go back on my steps to check for any forgotten teeth, and this time the teeth that used to be sick sound good, so I clean them, and die 🤣 (At first I thought that once you clean all the safe teeth, you can clean the other ones, which I found was a super interesting mechanic, but I guess it's just a bug? or I should try to download the game. Anyway probably the mechanic would only work for players that do it linearly, unfortunately) Anyway, super soothing experience, really had the feeling of BEING THE BIRD 🐦 (And well... please make multiple levels where the game is to guess the criterion for cleaning the teeth, I want to play more 😆 ✨️ ) Thank you so much for this game!!! |
| Apr 23 17:21:18 | 53h 04m | P8-Sweeper | ♥ 1 | Super cool game omgggggg ✨️ I liked realizing progressively all the implications of the half point tweak!! Especially the moment I realized 0.5 + 0.5 = 1 😂 Also loved the narrative snippets! |