Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD40 → Feedback comment stats → Sherwood
Feedback comments for LD40
Sherwood's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Sherwood's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 5 14:20:44 | The lost strawberry | ♥ 1 | I have to admit my brain was freezed at the begining. I was totally confused by the colors. However it gives a great explosive mood. That's the kind of game I'd like to have on a pocket emulator haha. Very nice. The only reproach I could make is about the game mechanic which is kind of hard to start with. I guess it would be awesome with controllers ;) | |
| Dec 5 15:21:46 | 1h 01m | Lost Sakura | ♥ 1 | Hentai Dude : > Slicin' haters with my blade, ronin wit the code, though They call me Mugen, put my flow up on the rhyme Disintegratin' my enemies, my way of samurai" I love the idea. Same as above though. I would also say that a music would be welcome. Something that could enhance the atmosphere. The concept reminds me of Final Fantasy IX when you have to pretend fighting with Frank during the theater performance. Good job ! |
| Dec 5 21:33:55 | 6h 12m | Crimson Recon | ♥ 0 | I really appreciate the main idea of living bullets. Sadly I broke my mouse a while ago so It is extremely hard for me to play this x) It's a funny challenge actually to be the target of your own power. The atmosphere is nicely done thanks to the narrative aspects and the global quitness. I have to admit that, because of my mouse problem, I couldn't go far through the game. That's on me. Thanks for the (future) experience. |
| Dec 5 22:47:55 | 1h 14m | Mortal Komba | ♥ 1 | Me, after the second character came on screen >Whaaaaaaaaaat just happened ??? Like I said about another game, this also reminds of Final Fantasy IX... When you first play with Bibi and you can play this minigame in the city. Yeah, my childhood... But this one pushes the difficulty higher. So thanks for the remembrance and this innocent but hard entry ;) |
| Dec 5 22:57:19 | 9m 24s | Bloom | ♥ 1 | First of all, I was surprised to see Carrie from The Amazing World of Gumball. It's kind of funny as it could have been an extra episode of her life. I don't even know if you know this TV Show though. Then I would say it totally fits the theme. Trees are so annoying ! In a good way ;) Despite the fact that I didn't feel satisfied when I won (probably because I expected more friends to save), I liked to play it. Thanks ! |
| Dec 6 01:11:35 | 2h 14m | ThemeTris | ♥ 1 | Yosh ! I have to say that I needed time to dig the concept you worked on. It's actually a good idea. Honestly, I feel the reason why you merge your concept with tetris. But maybe you should have tried to find a different artstyle approach. Even something pretty simple could fit the idea. Lines of codes following each others, getting built one on another. The more disorganized code you have, the more messy it is. That is what I feel. So it couldn't be closer to the theme. The point is that I can't really reward the innovation as the only difference between this Themetris & Tetris is that some "narrative" stuff appears sometimes. So the advice I can give you would be to improve the "story" elements and add levels of self-improvements (the same way we Learn). So that way you would be able to make a game, based on Tetris mechanics but enhanced with narrative contents. Don't know if you feel the idea though 😊 |
| Dec 6 01:22:09 | 10m 34s | A Spark of Light | ♥ 1 | A game that made me feel claustrophobic at the end. I'd definitely see some additional content like a light devourer (Some monsters following you to eat your light in case you don't move that much). It would give an horror atmosphere to the game and something stressing. Really good concept. |
| Dec 6 01:42:09 | 20m 00s | Too Many Chooks | ♥ 1 | Ok first impression is that the artstyle is close to something funny. Yeah, the idea is fun so you could definitely make the design funny too. 🎵**"Push it to the limit"**🎵 Even the music could be "stupid" (in the good way). Like someone else said above the animation before they lay is the instinctive touch that make things a bit "predictible". Nice touch. It was actually really challenging, liked the idea. |
| Dec 6 01:58:17 | 16m 08s | Chicken Tender | ♥ 1 | Really satisfying game and also STRESSING because of the dialogues appearing in front of the toolbox. That's part of the loving details I like in games. Especially when the farmer reminds it to you haha. Fun game, solid idea, would make a lovely game with more contents. |
| Dec 6 02:10:18 | 12m 01s | BLOK'D | ♥ 1 | Actually before getting 134 points I didn't expect to play that much x) It has something addictive I really appreciated. Sticks perfectly to the theme, simple graphics, instinctive, easy to understand. Could be a classic. It doesn't need a humor aspect though (from my point of view of course). |
| Dec 6 17:04:37 | 14h 54m | Scrooge the Cat | ♥ 1 | Simple and very well done artstyle. Smooth and clean. I agree the atmosphere fits with christmas 😄 The game is chalenging and to my opinion, it could be easely implemented into a bigger game as a mini game. There's some inspiration to dig up here. Nice work ! |
| Dec 6 17:20:05 | 15m 28s | Coastal Postal | ♥ 1 | Very nice little puzzle game. I really like the way you played on the theme with these kind of puzzle. Also the way you gave it a context. However I'm being stuck at a the same point as @unfinished. Don't know if I'm not smart enough or if it's a lack of explanations. Great entry though ! |
| Dec 6 21:02:11 | 3h 42m | Glutton's Heaven | ♥ 1 | This was a challenging experience ! Guess it's hard to finish it. I was also suprised by the fact that pressing spacebar skip to the next text. I won't tell you the same advice twice then. Nice humor approach though ;) |
| Dec 6 21:19:17 | 17m 06s | Tiny Empires | ♥ 1 | The only reason why I stopped playing was because at a certain point I was unable to move my troops. Just like @mikomikisomi. Beside this fact, I really enjoyed it, I just don't really see how the more I have the worse it gets. Maybe you should clarify this point. |
| Dec 6 21:36:31 | 17m 14s | For Better or For Worse | ♥ 1 | The more I would say, the worse it would be. Things have already been said. I enjoyed this poetic atmosphere. That was touching. Plus it fits perfectly to the theme. Easy mechanic, easy to understand, challenging ; serious stuff. |
| Dec 7 12:04:21 | 14h 27m | Bum Bag Bangin' | ♥ 2 | Love what you did based on Ego :) The atmosphere is really well set up, lively beat, It would have been really awesome with more enemies, or something more challenging. But I know that everything was also a matter of time challenge. Oh, the only "disappointment" I have is the font you used for the title ^^ It just feels impersonal compared to the whole game. In other words, very very pleasant entry. |