Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD36 → Feedback comment stats → joe40001
Feedback comments for LD36
joe40001's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | joe40001's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 18 01:59:00 | Ahab's Mystical Wagon Adventures | Looks very nice. Can't say too much more since there isn't much in the way of gameplay. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 2/5 <br/>Innovation 2/5 <br/>Fun 1/5 <br/>Theme 2/5 <br/>Graphics 4/5 <br/>Audio 0/5 <br/>Humor 2/5 <br/>Mood 4/5 | |
| Sep 18 02:49:00 | 50m 00s | Lorem Ipsum or Engineering for a Civilized Age | I liked it a lot, about the only problem I had was that it was pretty laggy for me, but that might have been my computer's fault. Also it wanted to go bigger than fullscreen so I had to mess with it. Fun game though and if it played a bit smoother and a bit faster I think it would be really good. If you could somehow do a 2D overhead version (that still had a height dimension) I think it would be an awesome tablet game. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 4/5 <br/>Innovation 3/5 <br/>Fun 4/5 <br/>Theme 4/5 <br/>Graphics 2/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 3/5 |
| Sep 18 03:04:00 | 15m 00s | Ancient Artifact (PLEASE COMMENT) | Interesting game, since you made the game for the compo that means you made all of it yourself in 48 hours? (Including music and graphics?) If that's true that's really really impressive. To complete all of something in that little time by yourself is really an impressive feat. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 4/5 <br/>Innovation 2/5 <br/>Fun 4/5 <br/>Theme 4/5 <br/>Graphics 4/5 <br/>Audio 4/5 <br/>Humor 3/5 <br/>Mood 4/5 |
| Sep 18 03:15:00 | 11m 00s | GRAVIQUATRO | Interesting game, I tried to play the game as if I'm two people and I don't know if it would play well or not. But I guess the same could be said of connect 4 itself. I liked the idea and graphics. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 3/5 <br/>Innovation 3/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 5/5 <br/>Graphics 4/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 3/5 |
| Sep 18 03:27:00 | 12m 00s | Oscilloschaos | Cool game! I really liked it a lot overall, my only complaint was that it crashed for me several times. I'm not sure why. I loved the look of the game and the nice little touches all around the game. I appreciated the humor of the "ancient tech" as well as "fixing" the oscilloscope. Aside from the crashing my only suggestion would be to alter it so red dots never went through other dots (particularly the goal dot) it just looked a bit off. I think having things not quite overlap fits the aesthetic better. Great game otherwise though. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 5/5 <br/>Innovation 3/5 <br/>Fun 5/5 <br/>Theme 5/5 <br/>Graphics 5/5 <br/>Audio 4/5 <br/>Humor 5/5 <br/>Mood 4/5 |
| Sep 18 09:54:00 | 6h 27m | Ancient Akkadians | I loved this game! I played the post-jam version and I ended up playing for like 4-5 hours. This game was super polished and addicting. By far my favorite game I played this LD. Also I think I like super-beat it, because I decided to build 12 ziggurats simultaneously (which was very hard to do). So I've probably played this game to more completion and longer than anybody else on earth. w00t. Fun game! <br/> <br/>Proof of my 12 ziggurat victory: <br/>http://i.imgur.com/LEIwTVl.png <br/>http://i.imgur.com/fUmKl5u.png <br/>http://i.imgur.com/LoRynHq.png <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 5/5 <br/>Innovation 4/5 <br/>Fun 5/5 <br/>Theme 5/5 <br/>Graphics 5/5 <br/>Audio 5/5 <br/>Humor 3/5 <br/>Mood 5/5 |
| Sep 18 10:03:00 | 9m 00s | Tower of Egypt | Interesting game, it didn't really escalate or change as you played longer. It was fine for what it was but could've used more polish. Still, it was playable and met the theme which is more than a lot of LD games. Good work. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 3/5 <br/>Innovation 1/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 4/5 <br/>Graphics 2/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 2/5 <br/>Mood 2/5 |
| Sep 18 10:13:00 | 10m 00s | Escape from planet Earth! | Interesting game, the art and music was quite good (the opening art in particular was nice). The gameplay wasn't anything too new or innovative. Fun take on the theme though, the game itself had several bugs and it seemed like the bad guys were too good a shot such that fighting them seemed like a waste and just running through was your best bet. Shows promise but needs bug fixes and stuff. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 2/5 <br/>Innovation 1/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 4/5 <br/>Graphics 3/5 <br/>Audio 2/5 <br/>Humor 3/5 <br/>Mood 2/5 |
| Sep 18 19:51:00 | 9h 38m | Modus Catapultus | Interesting game, I had to play the post Jam version to get it. It's a kinda innovative/fun idea, I just wished there was some win condition or sense of progress. I got to like 165 advanced or something and stopped. I like the mechanics though they made themselves evident pretty fast without needing a tutorial or anything. Overall neat idea, not bad. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 3/5 <br/>Innovation 4/5 <br/>Fun 3/5 <br/>Theme 2/5 <br/>Graphics 3/5 <br/>Audio 2/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 2/5 |
| Sep 18 20:03:00 | 12m 00s | Og's Wheel | I liked the art on this game, unfortunately the wheel was so sluggish that I feel like it was a design error, I don't see how you can beat level 3 because even if you try to ramp behind you, you skip on the ground and lose all your momentum. I too like to make challenging games, but this one seemed unwinnable and kinda frustrating to play too. I still liked a lot of what was here though. (Like the art/music/theme) <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 2/5 <br/>Innovation 2/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 5/5 <br/>Graphics 4/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 3/5 |
| Sep 18 20:19:00 | 16m 00s | Trials of Daedalus | Careful, Icarus. <br/> <br/>Cool take on the theme, the music was decent (any original music impresses me), my main complaint is that the game is slow slow slow to move which took the fun out of it for me. I still beat it though. :) <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 2/5 <br/>Innovation 3/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 5/5 <br/>Graphics 2/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 3/5 |
| Sep 18 21:22:00 | 1h 03m | The Ancient Ti-Li Island | So I was impressed with the amount of work that went into this but some things could be improved. The biggest one for me was making it more clear how to interact with things and what things I could interact with. Once I read your note about the water puzzle I did fine but then I eventually made it to the very last island and there is no indication if there is a puzzle there or something else. After all the time it took to fill out the drawings I'd hoped for something more conclusive at the end. Anyway really great art assets and some good coding too. I liked the idea hear just needed some polish and clarity. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 3/5 <br/>Innovation 5/5 <br/>Fun 3/5 <br/>Theme 4/5 <br/>Graphics 4/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 5/5 |
| Sep 18 22:44:00 | 1h 22m | TrainStack | Great game! I really liked the polish and design and idea, about my only complaint was since the traps seemed to be timing based it seemed like mostly just guessing for the last few levels (I did beat them all). If there was a way to know from the starting line if you were going to hit the traps that would make it more puzzley and less guessy, still well made game though. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 4/5 <br/>Innovation 4/5 <br/>Fun 4/5 <br/>Theme 3/5 <br/>Graphics 5/5 <br/>Audio 4/5 <br/>Humor 2/5 <br/>Mood 4/5 |
| Sep 18 23:02:00 | 18m 00s | Back to Nature | I like the design and music a lot but as other people have said it's too hard to the point it's not that playable. It's neat though, and looks cool. I like you take on the theme, but it would need tweaks to become more of a game game. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 3/5 <br/>Innovation 3/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 4/5 <br/>Graphics 4/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 2/5 <br/>Mood 4/5 |
| Sep 18 23:12:00 | 10m 00s | Ancient Technologies | Clever take on the theme. I like what you did. For some reason it was very slow for me (the game itself) but most others didn't have this problem so I assume it's my computer. Not much to say aside from that it was a cool idea executed well. Good job! <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 4/5 <br/>Innovation 4/5 <br/>Fun 3/5 <br/>Theme 4/5 <br/>Graphics 4/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 4/5 <br/>Mood 4/5 |
| Sep 18 23:31:00 | 19m 00s | Cave Tale | Neat little game. It doesn't really end or escalate too much, by the time I got to 80 points and 0 misses I just quit, but good take on the theme and game does what it sets out to do. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 3/5 <br/>Innovation 2/5 <br/>Fun 3/5 <br/>Theme 3/5 <br/>Graphics 3/5 <br/>Audio 2/5 <br/>Humor 2/5 <br/>Mood 2/5 |
| Sep 19 00:49:00 | 1h 18m | Into The Universe | Awesome game! My final score was 21320. I found the rules really easy to understand and the game really deep and fun, my only complaint was that it wasn't clear how you acquire additional scouts, it seemed very random. Also I think the damage might work better if it's DPS (continuous), as it was there really wasn't much difference between doing 55 a second to 75 a second but it still cost 4 upgrades to go between them. <br/> <br/>Really well made game, super polished, awesome job. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 5/5 <br/>Innovation 4/5 <br/>Fun 5/5 <br/>Theme 2/5 <br/>Graphics 5/5 <br/>Audio 5/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 4/5 |
| Sep 19 03:26:00 | 2h 37m | Guild Inc | So after watching your impressive timelapse of the game being made I decided to play it. And so I did play it... and played it... and ended up dumping some hours into it for some reason. So I'm pretty sure I won it (as much as one can). Here's where I got to (take a note of my score): <br/>http://i.imgur.com/7hZYQW2.png <br/> <br/>W00t! It took a lot of clicking and a good deal being offered but I think that's going to be a high score that will be tough to beat! lol <br/> <br/>Great game, very impressive for a 48hr compo entry. Technically the game could've allowed you to buy/sell in bulk or include a win condition but honestly I don't care. I loved it for what it was. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 5/5 <br/>Innovation 4/5 <br/>Fun 4/5 <br/>Theme 5/5 <br/>Graphics 5/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 4/5 |
| Sep 19 08:39:00 | 5h 13m | We Are Here To Help | I appreciate the effort on this game. I'm not a big fan of text adventures but clearly you put time into the story and art and I do appreciate that. Good job! <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 2/5 <br/>Innovation 3/5 <br/>Fun 1/5 <br/>Theme 3/5 <br/>Graphics 3/5 <br/>Audio 2/5 <br/>Humor 4/5 <br/>Mood 3/5 |
| Sep 19 08:45:00 | 6m 00s | HEAVEN Slime | Creative gameplay. Kinda trippy idea, for my taste it was more frustrating than fun but still I appreciate the effort/result. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 2/5 <br/>Innovation 4/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 4/5 <br/>Graphics 2/5 <br/>Audio 2/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 4/5 |
| Sep 19 08:50:00 | 5m 00s | Time Grabber | I was able to get to the end really quickly. The graphics and music are decent though. Good effort but I think it needs more of a twist to stand out. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 2/5 <br/>Innovation 1/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 3/5 <br/>Graphics 3/5 <br/>Audio 2/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 2/5 |
| Sep 19 08:54:00 | 4m 00s | George and the Mighty Ancient's technology (VR) | Good atmosphere. It wasn't really clear to me how to advance much in the game though. |
| Sep 19 08:58:00 | 4m 00s | Spear Dash | Good first effort. It plays smoothly which is more than a lot of people's first efforts. Also some of the art is decent. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 2/5 <br/>Innovation 1/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 2/5 <br/>Graphics 2/5 <br/>Audio 2/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 1/5 |
| Sep 19 09:06:00 | 8m 00s | Romans Vs Gauls | Neat game. Seems inspired by Plants vs Zombies. I was able to beat it in the end. <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 2/5 <br/>Innovation 2/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 2/5 <br/>Graphics 2/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 2/5 |
| Sep 19 09:22:00 | 16m 00s | Kramchay Dig | So I think I solved the riddle but nothing happened. I basically matched the door numbers with the corresponding spots for the password (so top left door exit being a 2 means top left character is 2, etc), but nothing happened. Am I missing something? <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 3/5 <br/>Innovation 4/5 <br/>Fun 3/5 <br/>Theme 3/5 <br/>Graphics 4/5 <br/>Audio 3/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 3/5 |
| Sep 19 09:48:00 | 26m 00s | Transcendence | I played the game to completion. Fun little game, audio was a bit annoying exploring was kinda fun though, and some of the art assets were good. Overall good job, the game played as intended. :) <br/> <br/>Score: (because I like scores) <br/>Overall 3/5 <br/>Innovation 2/5 <br/>Fun 2/5 <br/>Theme 3/5 <br/>Graphics 3/5 <br/>Audio 2/5 <br/>Humor 0/5 <br/>Mood 3/5 |