Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD34 → Feedback comment stats → Mr MadCat
Feedback comments for LD34
Mr MadCat's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Mr MadCat's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 15 20:23:00 | Beanstalks | Great take on the theme. <br/>Very cool puzzles. <br/>The only thing I found a bit annoying was that sometimes I would fail at a puzzle because my character would slide into another item. <br/>But all in all a great entry. | |
| Dec 15 20:38:00 | 15m 00s | Gravity Glide | Great concept. <br/>And very smooth Gameplay. Well done. |
| Dec 17 09:11:00 | 36h 33m | Shift & Run | Very innovative concept. <br/>I like the IllegalStateException ;) |
| Dec 17 09:17:00 | 6m 00s | The beanstalk (and maybe Jack) | I hope you can finish it later. <br/>I tried to write my name with the beanstalk, but I failed ^^ |
| Dec 17 09:28:00 | 11m 00s | Bean Rider | Pretty solid game. Well done. <br/>With some background music and some more sound effects for hitting different obstacles you could improve the mood of the game. |
| Dec 17 09:42:00 | 14m 00s | Phaseolus Magicus | Congratulations on your first compo entry. <br/>It's pretty solid gameplay and great use of the themes. <br/>There is one thing that annoyed me a bit: I can't really look at the beanstalk and the cards at the same time, so I can't appreciate the beauty of it as it grows without fearing to loose a life. It would be really cool if after you failed you could see the growing of your beanstalk like a replay or something. Because it really looks awesome. <br/>Another thing, which is not negative in my opinion but maybe something for you to think about for further games is the ratio of how many times I have to choose right and how many times I have to choose left. Because for like 75% (felt, I didn't create an actual statistic about it ;) ) of the time I could just press left, because it just is so much more likely thet two different cards will come up. Changing this ratio might affect the gameplay heavily, so depending on what you want to achieve you might consider things like this. <br/>All in all a very well done entry. <br/>I hope to see more from you the next LD. |
| Dec 18 12:29:00 | 26h 47m | Plutonium FREE | It took me while to figure out what packages I should suck up and which not. You might want to add one lline of description for that. I didn't notice that the screens change what you see, so it wasn't obvious to me. <br/>Also I think the sound effects became a bit annoying after some time. That might also be a point for improvement. <br/>Controls and graphics are great and theme is well met. <br/>All in all a well done entry. |
| Dec 18 12:33:00 | 4m 00s | Pete and the Beanstalk | Really great game. <br/>Smooth controls, fitting graphics and sound. <br/>Not much more to say I guess. <br/>Well done. |
| Dec 18 12:48:00 | 15m 00s | Growth of the Hive | Sadly the game doesn't support my screen resolution. This seems to mess up the text in the tutorial level. I could only read the first half of the sentences. The rest was blocked by the minimap. <br/>So I couldn't really understand how to pay the game. <br/>You might want to add an explanation in your game description. <br/>The graphics are really cool though. |
| Dec 18 13:06:00 | 18m 00s | 3:LLIS - PROTOCOL : PROTECT PLANTLIFE | Pretty cool game. <br/>Nice graphics and idea. <br/>However I had two problems while playing the game. First off all nothing happend after I got to 60% growth. I collected all the water that was around and then nothing happend. Maybe I just didn't understand what to do, but watering the plant wasn't effective either. <br/>Secondly I found out that it is possible to fall of the map on the top right corner if you jump there. <br/>But all in all a cool entry. |
| Dec 18 15:01:00 | 1h 55m | Personal Growth | Cool game. <br/>First one so far with some meaning for real life so far :) |
| Dec 18 15:09:00 | 8m 00s | Game of Life - Decide and Grow [GERMAN] | Cool idea. <br/>It's a pity you couldn't translate it all. <br/>One thing though, the WebGL version seems to be broken. It can't find some files I think. <br/>The windows version works just fine. |
| Dec 19 11:14:00 | 20h 05m | Authentic Roman History Simulator | Very cool game. <br/>Some music and some more sound effects would be an improvement. <br/>But this is definitely the funniest game I played so far. <br/>There is one minor flaw. The ball got stuck between Asia and Africa two times. That is quite frustrating, when you almost beat the game and then you have to reset everything. |
| Dec 21 14:49:00 | 51h 35m | AscenS | Nice game. <br/>Reminds me of those bullet-hell games, only way more relaxing ;) <br/>However I found it a bit confusing that I couldn't move completely to the left or right although it looked like it from the picture. <br/>But nice entry. |
| Dec 22 14:42:00 | 23h 53m | Metal World Chaos | The concept sounds interesting. <br/>Sadly not much to play though. <br/>I hope you will finish next time. Or maybe try to create a more finished version of this game to learn a bit for the next LD. |
| Dec 22 14:57:00 | 15m 00s | Nightlight | Great way to set the mood. <br/>Controls feel a bit slow. This feels a bit contradictory to the feeling of 'I have to rush to the next socket'. <br/>Also the Flashes of lightning are cool for the mood and a nice help, until you figure out that you can just keep standing near the light, wait for the flash and see where the sockets and important objects are. This is a great danger to the mood once a player figures it out. <br/>But all in all a cool entry. |
| Dec 22 15:05:00 | 8m 00s | Shaman Flower | Great game. <br/>Very fitting artstyle and music. <br/>Not much more to say. ;) |
| Dec 22 15:12:00 | 7m 00s | Magic Beans | Interesting idea. <br/>However I didn't understand, when I can affect a branch. <br/>Sometimes a branch would react to me pressing a button and sometimes not. <br/>That was abit confusing. <br/>But it is very relaxing nonetheless ;) |
| Dec 22 16:24:00 | 1h 12m | Kitty McBlubberton | Cute little game. <br/>Very cute protagonist ;) <br/>Some sound effects and music would really help to create a good mood for the game. <br/>But once you reach 250 kg the kitty can eat the cakes without any problem and just get fatter and fatter :) |
| Dec 22 16:35:00 | 11m 00s | Augmentum | Pretty cool game. <br/>The jump animation looks a bit weird, but that is only a minor thing. <br/>You can get a score of over 200 by just keeping right pressed and repeatedly pressing up. You don't even have to look at the screen. <br/>But it is still very impressive what you created. Well done. |
| Dec 22 17:39:00 | 1h 04m | 2 Roll | Very cool atmosphere and very creative gameplay. <br/>Well done. |
| Dec 22 17:47:00 | 8m 00s | Bug Plus Plus | Cool game. <br/>The sound effects are just awesome. Some background music would be nice. <br/>Well done. |
| Dec 23 10:55:00 | 17h 08m | Chomp | Cool entry. <br/>It plays pretty well and music and artstyle are a perfect match to the game. |
| Dec 23 11:07:00 | 12m 00s | Mon Démon et Moi | Awesome atmosphere. The music and graphics are a perfect match. <br/>The game really gpt me immersed although I didn't really understand what I was doing or why. <br/>But it is a great entry. Probably the game with best mood I have played this LD. |
| Dec 23 13:59:00 | 2h 52m | White Rose | Neat idea. <br/>I was missing a bit of a challenge beacause I could just keep beating up the bad guys without ever getting hit. <br/>But all in all a cool entry. |
| Dec 23 14:11:00 | 12m 00s | Secret of the Little Lamb | Very cute protagonist. <br/>Also music and sound effects were nicely fitting. <br/>However I found the controls in combination with the collision detection a bit unfair. This would need some finetuning. <br/>But it is a great entry with a nice use of the themes. |
| Dec 23 18:00:00 | 3h 49m | Jack Bean: The Stalkening | Cool soundeffects. <br/>But the sometimes-autojumping is a bit annoying. <br/>Also the background doesn't change anymore after it gets black. <br/>But all in all a nice little game. |