Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD28 → Feedback comment stats → steamgirl
Feedback comments for LD28
steamgirl's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | steamgirl's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 20 14:40:00 | Silkworm Princess | I liked it! The music got repetitive a bit too quickly for my taste but other than that a solid entry. I disagree with poingferret, I don't think it needed more of a tutorial than what you already had. I was a little confused about the shield not travelling with the silkworm the first couple of times it happened, but I prefer figuring that out for myself over being told how it works. Good job! ;) | |
| Dec 20 14:57:00 | 17m 00s | The Story of Your Life | Good attempt and a good idea, but it was a bit boring to play, (you probably had loads more stuff you wanted to put in). It's like a really trimmed down version of Kudos, a game which I've enjoyed a lot in the past. Good job and getting it finished! :) |
| Dec 20 17:26:00 | 2h 29m | Crew: A Futuristic Detective Game | Love the idea I hope you'll work on it more. The graphics are great! <br/> <br/>I would have liked to be able to ask each crew member some questions - so if Ryan says Toko was in the nursery, I'd like to be able to ask Toko where she was to cross check the evidence. :) |
| Dec 20 17:27:00 | 1m 00s | One Arrow | I'm getting a 502 server error when I go to the link. :( |
| Dec 20 17:43:00 | 16m 00s | Princess Kingdom | Great entry! I'm amazed you managed to get ALL THAT done in such a short amount of time! Good job! Was candybox an inspiration? It reminds me a bit of that but with graphics. I liked the town building more than the jumpy princess bit, but then I'm not a massive fan of platformers generally. Anyway, good job well done! :) |
| Dec 20 17:52:00 | 9m 00s | Food Survival | Haha, funny! Like the interpretation of the theme, only one packet of fries! The scrolling was pretty unique as well, I haven't seen that in many games. Good job. |
| Dec 21 16:48:00 | 22h 56m | Yogo's Adventure | Hahaha, I totally fell for it on level 2! :) Wish the game had sound though... Still really well done for such a short time!!! |
| Dec 21 17:04:00 | 16m 00s | The Last Realm | Really enjoyable! I agree with code-11, would be nice to see what my budget is for purchasing. Quite a few times I purchased some frigates and then had no money left to spend on other ships. :( You should defo do a post-compo version though - it was fun to play. :) |
| Dec 21 17:18:00 | 14m 00s | The Social Avarice of an Adult Mayfly | I liked the concept more than the actual execution. My favourite part was planning beforehand, I got very confused about what I was actually supposed to do at the party. Also, quite a few times the guests liked teetotallers and drunks but I was never quite sure how much I had to drink and whether I was drinking at all (until alcohol did me in). I also noticed there's a countdown in the planning stage which seems to be in a slightly weird place? <br/> <br/>I agree with what others have said, more feedback during the real-time game as code-11 suggested would be great, and I agree with davisan, it has the potential to be really hilarious with a bit of dialogue. :) <br/> <br/>Overall though, good job! Hope you carry on with this game and polish it up! |
| Dec 21 17:37:00 | 19m 00s | Pretty Creatures | Aww, it's a shame it can only be played with 4 people. It looks so pretty! Kudos for trying something completely different though - if I get a chance to play it with friends I will! :) |
| Dec 21 17:56:00 | 19m 00s | Cardocalypse | Really funny audio and I really like the concept. I felt the game went on for a bit too long though and it felt more random than strategic. Perhaps if new cards didn't spontaneously turn up, but empty spaces would remain behind? That way you could click on the deck to deal a new card if you get stuck in your journey to a one-card-only-board and have more of a chance to complete the game. :) |
| Dec 22 16:12:00 | 22h 16m | One Cigarette | Very cool. The right kind of oppressive atmosphere, plenty of humour. I kept accidentally firing my one bullet... oops! Highly amusing. ^_^; |
| Dec 24 13:27:00 | 45h 15m | YOGO - The Detective Story | Really enjoyed it. I actually thought your English was perfectly comprehensible, didn't struggle to understand the story at all. The ending was a little disappointing, as I felt the reason for why I should have known who was the murderer wasn't strong enough. I would probably have said the same thing even if I was innocent. But I'm genuinely impressed with what you managed to achieve in such a short time - I've used Ren'py before and I'm not sure I could do the same! <br/> <br/>I hope you make more of these in your own time (maybe with an English editor buddy) - I'd play them! :) |
| Dec 28 12:29:00 | 95h 02m | You only get one happy little life | Really happy, made me smile the whole way through. I loved the "weehee". The physics felt good - kudos for achieving that! I didn't manage to make it all the way to the end, but that's okay, because I got a smile anyway. ;) PS. Loved the surprise button! |
| Dec 28 12:38:00 | 9m 00s | Shooting Atoms For Peace | Fun and addictive puzzle! The audio didn't work for me for some reason (so I haven't rated it) but that didn't impact my enjoyment at all. A solid LD entry, fun to play and original! Well done! |
| Dec 28 12:51:00 | 13m 00s | Castle Uno | I'm not a big fan of platformers, but this game is really well executed. It's quite cerebral and I'm amazed by the level of polish, with little details like the dude looking over his shoulder! Good use of the theme too! Sadly it's really not my type of game and my wrist hurt quite quickly (on a keyboard), but while it wasn't much fun for me, I can appreciate the game probably pushes all the right buttons for people who like supermeatboy and similar. Good job well done! :) |
| Dec 28 14:57:00 | 2h 06m | Lumen | Wow, what an amazing entry! Looks gorgeous, very atmospheric! However it was a bit too difficult to play for my taste - would have been nice to have a "call back" mechanism for the light. I tried firing it down and behind me to avoid traps but still ended up having to retry - gave up after about 6 attempts. Nonetheless, the most impressive LD entry I have seen so far. Spectacularly beautiful. |
| Dec 28 15:05:00 | 8m 00s | Pillage Rush | Amusing and great graphics! Wish I could drop the girls though. Did it miss instructions? It took a little while for me to figure out to use AWD for controls... |
| Dec 28 15:14:00 | 9m 00s | Just. One. Second. | Nice one on your first entry! And in C++ nonetheless! I got to 17, but I got bored at that point so stopped. It's actually surprisingly fun though - the feedback really works. Also got a bit of an adrenaline rush from it. :D <br/> <br/>Would have been nice if there were two dots after level 10, or maybe something else to vary the game up a bit. Anyway, good job! |
| Dec 28 15:33:00 | 19m 00s | Dive | Hehe, we had similar ideas! I participated in the #nokill subtheme so no killing in mine. ;) <br/> <br/>Simple but effective - like the animation a lot. Wish I could restart into the game quicker after running out of breath though. On the upside the intro is really nicely done. Good job! <br/> <br/>PS. Sound didn't work for me for some reason so I've left that unrated. |
| Dec 28 15:48:00 | 15m 00s | Uno Terra | My favourite game so far! Amazingly fun to play, great music, great everything. Loved it! |
| Dec 29 16:36:00 | 24h 48m | Contentment | Haha, the bit where you get presented 3 chess tables made me laugh. For once I was making my own choices. ;) <br/> <br/>I love the style of this and your way of storytelling - even if the main character seems a bit of a downer. Hope you continue with this - I'd totally play a more complete version at a later date! |
| Dec 29 17:35:00 | 59m 00s | Mama is Sick | Very touching game, really enjoyed playing it! What a great take on the theme. Boy am I grateful to that family that kept sending $1 a day, could not have survived without it. The storytelling was also very cute and added a lot of character to the game. <br/> <br/>PS. I haven't rated the audio (for some reason it didn't play for me). |
| Jan 4 12:09:00 | 138h 34m | You Set Us Up The Bomb | Loved the theme song! Too bad the explosion sound effect was choppy - I found the explosions unsatisfying as a result. The concept is quite original though and a good take on the theme! Will you be doing a post-compo version? |
| Jan 4 12:36:00 | 27m 00s | One shot | Unfortunately anything I choose (knife, hacking tools, cardboard box) gives me an exception error. game/location.rpy renpy/common/000statements.rpy error reading PNG file. :( <br/> <br/>Using the Windows version. |
| Jan 4 12:46:00 | 10m 00s | One Dish | I really like the idea of this game, but actually playing it wasn't that much fun for me. It wasn't quite clear what I was supposed to do. Take an average of all the customers scores? Avoid any flavours that people completely disliked? Try and maximise flavour in the hopes of ticking everyone's favourite flavour box? Looking at, and memorising, what all 10 customers wanted felt like a hassle. Maybe if there had been 1 customer to start with and the game ramped up to 2, 3, 4, 5, or something like that? <br/> <br/>Still, well done on finishing the game! I really liked the concept and would play a post-jam version if you decide to make one. :) |
| Jan 4 13:05:00 | 19m 00s | Nature's Howl | Wow, what a gorgeous game! Beautiful visuals, music, and gameplay. Gave it a 5 in most categories. Blown away! <br/> <br/>If I had to nitpick, it would be that the stage between the rabbit and the ferret felt a bit too long. But that's nitpicking. |
| Jan 5 16:07:00 | 27h 02m | Creator Story Saga Tycoon | Wish there was a way to mute the sound so I can have it running in the background. Other than that, great game! I've recently gotten into idle games so this is right up my street. Totally addicted. Some of the humour was maybe a bit too self-referential for my taste - eg some guy called Bruno (presumably the creator) and girlfriend not liking the game, but that's really minor. Overall great entry! |
| Jan 5 18:27:00 | 2h 20m | Process Journey | Really enjoyed it! Beautiful game, full of atmosphere! Unfortunately I had to cheat to get the good ending. I kept thinking I must have missed something in the scene because when I asked Sehya for advice she kept telling me to keep looking. Maybe after you have examined the scene fully there could be a different response. ;) |
| Jan 6 22:12:00 | 27h 45m | Doubt | Beautiful art, a game full of atmosphere. The puzzles felt mind-bendy, thoughtful. I loved the take on the theme with the cat. Wow, just wow. If you don't get into the top 3 games, I'd be surprised. |