Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD25 → Feedback comment stats → Atomic

Atomic

Feedback comments for LD25

Atomic's games and stats for all events →

Timestamp	Since previous	Game	Atomic's comment
Dec 17 13:32:00		Kidnap	It's an interesting concept. It should consider a very small amount of drag as a shot, that'd make it a lot more fun! The "lace" would also be nicer if it was somewhat smarter. Graphics and sounds are in the right direction but the lack of variety makes you stop playing very quickly.
Dec 17 13:41:00	9m 00s	You are the (NOIR) Villain	Love the graphics but I just circled the map 3 times and didn't find where to place the bomb. Could really use ASD, mouse control doesn't work very well.
Dec 17 13:46:00	5m 00s	Ino und Rakete	I found the green guy's graphics hilarious but that's about it.
Dec 17 13:53:00	7m 00s	Devon	Love the slime graphics and the title screen. Sounds are OK. Gameplay is very buggy and unstable but I managed to finish it.
Dec 17 14:00:00	7m 00s	FumbleAttack	Not sure if it's running correctly here, there seems to be no interaction between the hero and my dropper creatures.
Dec 17 14:08:00	8m 00s	Goat Hate Jug Band	I like the concept and love the graphics but in the end the music annoys as much as it annoys the goat :( Couldn't finish it.
Dec 17 16:50:00	2h 42m	Lord of the Dungeons!	The idea of tower defense with monsters is quite cool but the "status" screens get in the way and there's not enough time to set up the dungeons properly before the hero comes. Battle sounds and animation would make this a lot cooler. The music is great!
Dec 17 17:13:00	23m 00s	Bank Job	I like this kind of game but the music didn't play (only gun shots) and it crashed as soon as I returned $454 to the van. Found no goat... Had a real hard time differentiating walls from floor and finding out that I was supposed to dodge the actual red lines and not the guard's FoV (that makes little sense). Random movement makes the game hard but that's kinda nice.
Dec 17 17:38:00	25m 00s	Escape	I really like this one! Fun to play, good variety of stuff. Nice graphics, funny animations. Good music. IMHO all negative aspects are related to text: the dialog shouldn't stop the game, there are lots of mistakes (that's of course forgivable) and some guys show up with girl's names (random generator?).
Dec 17 18:07:00	29m 00s	CYBERQUEEN	Yeah, I didn't enjoy this at all. But I have to admit it's very well done... in a very fucked up way!
Dec 17 18:46:00	39m 00s	My Kingdom for a Line Block	I like your take on inverted tetris, two players always works better than an AI! I'd prefer it without automatic side switching, it's sort of confusing. Found a bug - selecting the next piece with WASD/arrows doesn't work when your selected piece is surrounded by used up pieces.
Dec 17 19:21:00	35m 00s	Pathos	Great idea, had never played anything like this before! Sometimes you can't tell what's a tile and what's not, specially on the easter island one. Doesn't run in FF 17.0.1, had to use Chrome (argh). Great game overall!
Dec 17 19:28:00	7m 00s	Cat Licker	It's funny but gets boring quickly. IMHO not very themeish. Sound's great!
Dec 17 19:52:00	24m 00s	DONUT HEIST: Nom in 60 Seconds	Nice game, good difficulty level. Finished it on my fourth try with about 1s to go :P
Dec 17 20:23:00	31m 00s	How To Be A Super Successful Politician	Doesn't run in FF, only in Chrome. I like the basic idea and know this is supposed to be a parody but why would funding education or reducing corruption decrease support? IMHO it should be more realistic (politicians would still be the villains)
Dec 17 21:34:00	1h 11m	Earth Destroyer	I'll write a lot because this is my favorite game so far. <br/>The good: <br/>-LOVE the graphic style <br/>-Great sounds and music <br/>-Great levels <br/>-Love wiping cities out <br/>The bad: <br/>-Got very laggy towards the end and my computer isn't a weakling <br/>-Line weapon was very hard to aim, would b better if you could actually draw a line <br/>-Once I levelled every building and the alien still told me I could do better... go figure <br/>-Some clipping/out of map glitches but that's fine <br/>The ugly: <br/>-With such a good entry you guys didn't need the gratuitous vote begging, seriously! <br/> <br/>Still the best entry so far!
Dec 18 13:47:00	16h 13m	Bullet Hell Reversed	I like the idea but the gameplay feels too random to me..
Dec 18 13:57:00	10m 00s	NONEX	Great idea, I like the grapic style and the sound is OK. It would be better if it waited a couple seconds after you kill all enemies, it's hard to know you won on the first couple of levels. Would be more fun if you made it harder ;)
Dec 18 14:11:00	14m 00s	Dracula Super Goat Hunter	Best story ever! Nice graphics, fantastic moody music, great gameplay! <br/>Goat spawning feels strange and enemies shouldn't be something traditionally evil (slimes).. maybe vampire hunters, priests or something like that.
Dec 18 18:17:00	4h 06m	Trina of The Depths	This has great graphics and music but the gameplay is far too slow for me. The movement mechanic seems right in theory but TBH it isn't fun. If it wasn't for the description I would've missed the connection to the theme.
Dec 18 19:25:00	1h 08m	'Goat, give me back my clothes !'	This could have been fun if collision detection and throwing worked in a predictable manner... right now it's just pixel porn (great pixel porn BTW)!
Dec 18 19:34:00	9m 00s	Bad Guy Boot Camp	Congratulations on having the guts to do this! My first 5 on theme 0 on fun so far.
Dec 18 20:03:00	29m 00s	Dr. Vile in The Greater Good	I'd give you a 5 on graphics if I could identify what the needed parts represent. City looks nice as well and the intro is cool.
Dec 18 20:10:00	7m 00s	Carnage	Not sure how to explain but the gameplay feels a bit artificial
Dec 18 20:43:00	33m 00s	Bad Santa	Better graphics and an evil Christmas song would bring this into the top 5 easily. It's fun and hard, I might not have been able to finish the first list if I hadn't found a relatively unprotected house and camped there. <br/>Can I have a Flux Capacitor for Christmas? Please?!?!?
Dec 19 23:07:00	26h 24m	Knights of Uruk	Graphics look good but are very glitchy. Music is great but feels more like Metroid than LOTR. Battle sounds are great! Not sure how it fits the theme. Controls are very awkward on the web version.
Dec 20 01:44:00	2h 37m	Mad Princess	Great in every aspect! The only issue I found is with the try again and next wave screens. There's something odd about the way they respond, not sure exactly what. <br/> <br/>Still might be the best I've played up to now :)
Dec 20 02:15:00	31m 00s	Nature's Villain	Froze twice and gave victory to nature while I still had 3 soldiers, then I gave up.. It's got nice graphics and could become a nice game after the bugs are crushed (pun intended) ;)
Dec 20 17:18:00	15h 03m	Villains of Milk and Madness	I like the humor and the narration but the gameplay is waaay too much on the grinding side. 300 milk for the vaporizer?!?
Dec 22 01:03:00	31h 45m	Unsave the Princess	Cool mechanics, reminds me of Trine. I'd certainly play a more complete version with the bugs ironed out. Bugs: tile borders showing up everywhere, when you die the previsouly spawned fireballs are still there.
Dec 22 16:53:00	15h 50m	Here be Dragn	Nice mechanics, best audio so far (music and effects), great humor. Could use more variety of enemies/spawn directions. There's a bug causing the dragon not to die.
Dec 22 17:15:00	22m 00s	MidBoss	Controls are very awkward and I don't mean just numpad - I'd suggest going with mouse clicks instead of the whole "press a button to attack, position a crosshair and press another button" thing. TBH I found the idea very nice but couldn't figure out how to play properly (only managed to possess once and had a hard time telling who was winning combat).