Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD37 → Feedback comment stats → commodoreKid
Feedback comments for LD37
commodoreKid's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | commodoreKid's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 13 20:33:00 | 1 biT Strike | There is not much to it, I played hundreds of similar games so I cannot really say it's innovative. I think you should try to challenge yourself more next time and come up with a more original idea. No offense, keep working :) | |
| Dec 13 20:37:00 | 4m 00s | Jim is Moving Out! | Very good idea for a mechanic. I like the simplicity and theme-relatedness of this game but I think you could do something more with the environment. Anyway I enjoyed it a lot. |
| Dec 13 20:39:00 | 2m 00s | Exit The Room Update 1.1 | Escaping the room idea fits the theme but I'm not even sure if it's a game. Next time I'd suggest you try to create something you would like to play yourself. |
| Dec 13 20:41:00 | 2m 00s | Haunted Room | I like the idea of using a number of resources in a tactical manner but I think player could have more foresight to what is to come so he could be more prepared. I think from this core idea you can create a much sophisticated and better game. Keep up! |
| Dec 13 20:43:00 | 2m 00s | Sleeper's Curse | I really liked the point and click adventure feel to this game especially when you have to place objects correctly and combine two of them. I think you could have explored that part even more. Graphics were fine but collisions were a little strange overall. I hope this helps for your future projects, cool game :) |
| Dec 13 20:45:00 | 2m 00s | levelone | I really liked the humor and use of space in this game. Graphics, collisions and sounds could use a bit of work. It flows very well so good job :) |
| Dec 13 20:48:00 | 3m 00s | Booking Mama | I liked the game a lot I think this falls in my "could easily be a mobile game" category. I found objects not easily distinguishable in rooms so it requires quite a while to get used to it. Overall, a very good job with graphics, mechanic and music anyway. |
| Dec 13 20:50:00 | 2m 00s | Bob & Bernard Against the Nazis | Very good art and story but it's very repetitive. It felt to me like one of those mobile games where upgrades are infinite and you grind to get to the next weapon. I personally don't like that kind of games but if you do this for mobile I'm sure you'll have an audience. |
| Dec 13 20:52:00 | 2m 00s | INFINIROOM | Very simple but hard to master mechanic. I got confused with direction change when you double jumped almost every time. I think you definitely need to create a mobile game out of this since it can be played with one button. Graphics and sound are also good. Excellent job. |
| Dec 13 20:54:00 | 2m 00s | My Friend Bubba | It's a chill game. I think this could be easily a multiplayer experience with much more content and published on market. I could only get 3 achievements but it was enough to understand the concept. Very good idea. |
| Dec 14 09:07:00 | 12h 13m | That's Still One Room | I like these vs.developer kind of games but I think it could be longer and more challenging. You also need work on graphics. Good humor and not bad at all for a first game. |
| Dec 14 21:34:00 | 12h 27m | Walkie Talkie | Well it's you again with another original idea. What can I say? |
| Dec 14 22:48:00 | 1h 14m | Boomerang Boy | Wow it was intense. I tried to find a sweet spot and I kind of managed but it was still hard for me to get past 15. Graphics and sound could use some work but otherwise it's a nice weapon mechanic. Reminded me of Titan Souls :) |
| Dec 14 22:59:00 | 11m 00s | Snapped | As I already told you the production quality is not that high but you still managed to get me in the mood which is something :) I wish it would be more of an adventure game :P |
| Dec 14 23:16:00 | 17m 00s | HourGlass Collector | I wanted it to never end because every rule was very different than the last one :) I really like it. I died all my deaths in Newton part :P |
| Dec 19 22:59:00 | 119h 43m | Tangent | Nicely designed puzzles with limited number of mechanics. They might be a little predictable but I can imagine how it could look in a fully developed game with a few more mechanics. Music is nice, graphics are alright, very good job. |
| Dec 21 23:11:00 | 48h 12m | Chat Room One | I like the idea but it is quite easy to explain or give a hint at the moment. Maybe words instead of single characters would be better. But still you could put ____ instead of the word I guess. Then you could introduce a time limit as well. However as I said the potential is there. Good job. |