Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD33 → Feedback comment stats → Will Edwards
Feedback comments for LD33
Will Edwards's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Will Edwards's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 23 22:51:00 | KITTEN KILLER! | Sweat and simple. Well, simple anyway :D <br/> <br/>Tutorial works great. +1 for web play too. | |
| Aug 24 22:11:00 | 23h 20m | Adam the Alien | Very innovative mechanic :) <br/> <br/>Although you are a monster, you are not monstrous. <br/> <br/>I felt the jump was a bit low. But I really liked the puzzles anyway. I didn't do terribly well, but I had fun playing badly :) |
| Aug 24 22:24:00 | 13m 00s | Wake the Monster | Must be some pretty cool path finding or AI buried in there perhaps? :D |
| Aug 25 06:12:00 | 7h 48m | You are the GM | I admit that, whilst I get the concept, I'm not familiar enough with the DnD type of rules to know what any of the abbreviations or anything mean. I mostly just clicked about. <br/> <br/>Although you are the DM, you are really developing the players, choosing to nurture, nourish or hurt them. A developed game could have AI players but with an attempt at character richness and a feeling of dialog between DM and players as you 'develop' them? |
| Aug 25 07:11:00 | 59m 00s | Tentacles | Saw this when you posted to the main page and *really* *really* wanted to play, but am web-only :( From your gifs it looks absolutely stunning perfect fun. A really polished looking clean base defender inverted. I had started this LD thinking of building a Kraken that attacks ships, but I was thinking 3D and it was not workable in the timescales with my programmer approach to graphics. Anyway, such a polished looking game as yours deserves to be admired, kudos :) |
| Aug 26 11:10:00 | 27h 59m | McTremson Bar | Excellent! I'm not sure I progressed very well or very far, but spent a happy long time clicking around. Was disappointed I couldn't be a monster and set the lady on fire after dowsing her with alcohol; I asked the barman for matches and even a napkin to use as a wick...? |
| Aug 26 12:18:00 | 1h 08m | Corruption-5 | Excellent entry again :) <br/> <br/>Hi res shading meets pixel art, lovely :) <br/> <br/>If you have a working html5 player, why bother with downloads for platforms? |
| Sep 1 07:39:00 | 139h 21m | Inokan | Its a classic mistake to not explain the controls. Nobody reads the description, they just play the game. Put on-screen "tool tip" help so everyone finds the controls :) I have learned this lesson so hard in my own entries... <br/> <br/>The use of semi-transparency was excellent. <br/> <br/>Would look excellent put through an upsampling shader like 2xSal. <br/> <br/>A proper opening animation, and the "achievements", excellent! <br/> <br/>I couldn't get very far; I felt I was very quickly overwhelmed. <br/> <br/>But I still score this very highly; that I'm no good with button mashing doesn't mean I can't appreciate there is actually a seemingly complete game here :) |
| Sep 1 11:49:00 | 4h 10m | Path of a Psychopath | Enjoyed this immensely :) <br/> <br/>The graphics were excellent. Sometimes simple is best; very effective! <br/> <br/>Lots of subtle animation and cues. <br/> <br/>I basically got through each scene by trial and error and retrying. |
| Sep 1 11:55:00 | 6m 00s | Grave | Excellent animations and effects! <br/> <br/>Might look nice with an unsampling filter like 2xSal? <br/> <br/>Had to come back to read the controls instructions; would be better if they were in-game. <br/> <br/>Really missing a jump :) |
| Sep 1 12:03:00 | 8m 00s | You Have Been Found Guilty | Short and sweet, and fun :) I liked that to recharge so quickly. <br/> <br/>Fun how when you die your antagonists are suddenly carrying lanterns. |
| Sep 9 09:21:00 | 189h 18m | Tactical Superiority | Superb graphics and a decent AI :) I like the isometric fixed camera; reminds me of an RTS :) |
| Sep 9 16:22:00 | 7h 01m | I May Have Misunderstood: RPG | Absolutely loved it! Reminds me of a grail quest :) <br/> <br/>I wasn't very good at winning; often got stomped on by the pirates and mages. <br/> <br/>Instead of random dice rolls, there could be something the user can influence e.g. a roulette wheel where they can stop it. |
| Sep 14 05:40:00 | 109h 18m | The Banana Eater | Gorgeous soundtrack :) <br/> <br/>Liked the missiles etc. Actually found myself running back into them on occasion, they move so slow. <br/> <br/>You really needed to put a link to the game in your recent post to the front page -- I couldn't find it ;) |