Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD28 → Feedback comment stats → RodRoy1
Feedback comments for LD28
RodRoy1's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | RodRoy1's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 25 12:03:00 | Cure the infected! | Interesting idea, but its a bit slow. It could do with everything running a bit faster. | |
| Dec 25 12:15:00 | 12m 00s | One Color | Nice fun little game. I get the feeling this could be used for some sort of thing like ink blots. Just an idea :D |
| Dec 25 12:29:00 | 14m 00s | YouOnlyGetOnePath | Awsome game, looks like its come right off the Game Boy. It is really hard, would be nice if the target acted like a hole in minigolf but still an awsome little game. |
| Dec 25 12:56:00 | 27m 00s | A Snowball's Chance In Space | Nice idea, but i think the implimentation of the jam theme kind of ruins this game. Only getting one missle makes this anticlimactic. Maybe if you had to go through a level before coming to the boss. Just an idea :D |
| Dec 25 13:05:00 | 9m 00s | Static Room | Nice little game. Needs a little more veriaty, but enjoyable none the less. The theme dosent seem to be present though, but i may have just missed the point. |
| Dec 25 13:36:00 | 31m 00s | boom | It looks nice but its a bit difficult to play. Deffinatly an interesting idea though. Maybe with a bit more time you could develop it more. |
| Dec 25 14:09:00 | 33m 00s | The Zombie Skull Seeking Bullet | Awsome little game. Really enjoyed it but wish there was more tension. Maybe if the zombies agro radius was larger then the tension would be better. otherwise loved the idea, art and audio. |
| Dec 25 15:33:00 | 1h 24m | Out of Mind | Awsome game, nice idea, good sound, good visuals. All you have to do is clean it up a bit so the movement isnt as clunky. i dont see the theme, unless its you only get one life, but its not a big deal. Looking forward to seeing more from you guys. |
| Dec 25 19:11:00 | 3h 38m | One Jump | Good idea, the controlls are a bit floaty though. I like the wall grabbing, but i dont know if that was intentional or not. i think you could take this in a number of directions for levels if you can tighten the controlls up a bit. |
| Dec 25 19:45:00 | 34m 00s | One | Good game, i dont know if i was picking the right chest or not though, a little propt would be nice. Ideas interesting, visuals are nice, sound fits. All and all i think its a nice game. 158 points btw :D. |
| Dec 25 19:54:00 | 9m 00s | Bugged Bot | Great little game, love the use of theme as you can only use each ability once. Think our robot friend looks amazing. as well as the on screen propts. Love that there is more than one way to get through the level. All around amazing game, just wish there was more. |
| Dec 25 20:15:00 | 21m 00s | You, Only Get Won | I thought this was really good. Humor was great (well i thought so anyway). Theme was only there for fleeting appearences but added to the humor so that was fine. A fun little experience. |
| Dec 25 20:30:00 | 15m 00s | Nov 15 | Awsome game, just wish there was more of it. nice visuals and animation. controlls are a bit difficult to handle as you move so fast. Love the pop culture referance and idea. AI is great. All around a nicely made game. |
| Dec 25 20:43:00 | 13m 00s | Casting Call | Nice idea, im getting some odd bugs though. Its probibly my computer as the screen shots make it look fine. what i decifered looked good as well. |
| Jan 3 15:52:00 | 211h 09m | Trouble In Town | nice enjoyable game. I liked the sound effects especially. |
| Jan 3 16:01:00 | 9m 00s | You Only Get To Save One | verry interesting idea and visually you have done alot. The controlls are verry slipery though and tank controlls dont really work, although i can see whay you used them. nice game, but needs work. |
| Jan 3 16:09:00 | 8m 00s | Terminal Command | verry nice game. nice circuit bord text, and the idea is interesting. Its a bit hard to see but that might be my screen. Puzzle wise i think you might have to add more mechanics to give playes a few choices but otherwise nicely made game. |
| Jan 3 16:37:00 | 28m 00s | Maverick | amazingly good puzzle game but it is a little hard to understand at first. Music is nice and idea is sound. I dont see the theme but apart from that a verry well designed and implimented game. |
| Jan 3 17:59:00 | 1h 22m | The Hallowed Orb | Really fun game. Nice idea, well implimented, good music and visuals. the veriaty of eniemys is nice and the theme fits perfectly. Well done. Its really hard but thats fine, not alot of testing can be done in the timeframe. |
| Jan 3 18:03:00 | 4m 00s | Dumb Treasures | If this was made in eight hours i feel that something great could have come out of the full 48. Well I hope your next jam turns out better. |
| Jan 3 18:22:00 | 19m 00s | Diner Devil! | Good game, really impressed with the way it looks and plays. struggeling with the spatula and the knife and, the mouse clicks acted slowly but apart from that the control was good. Impressive amount of work done for 48 hours. |
| Jan 3 22:57:00 | 4h 35m | Conquest | Really nice game. loved how the theme fit into the quick story but i think the theme subtracted from the experience and maybe a health system should be added instead. Controlls where also a bit slipery and the bats AI seemed a bit strage at times. All and all a verry nicely made game with good enemy and level veriaty. Well done. |
| Jan 4 20:20:00 | 21h 23m | Marvie! | fun little maze game with nice visuals. little annoying you return to the begining when you take a wrong route but otherwise good little game. |
| Jan 4 20:29:00 | 9m 00s | Only One Remains | Awsome idea but really hard. the graphics and sound where good . The only thing i would suggest going forward is a better discription of how the game works. took me a few attempts to just understand the mechanics after the text at the beginning. |
| Jan 4 23:17:00 | 2h 48m | Lost in Space | verry nicely made but i think your right about it needing the substance to keep playing. It reminds me of the ur-quan masters. anyway verry tidaly implimented with nice visuals and an interesting introduction. well done |
| Jan 4 23:28:00 | 11m 00s | The Gold Coin | Hay, this program looks familiar. nice to see i am not the only one that made a twine game for LD28. I like the story and idea. The moral is nice too, only wish you could do a bit more with your gold. Keep at it, i would like to see where this story ends. |
| Jan 4 23:44:00 | 16m 00s | Red and Gold | nice game. The use of twine is great, and the management sim idea is good. I used twine for the competition, but i didnt manage to play much with the formatting before submission. I always love a good text game. |
| Jan 4 23:50:00 | 6m 00s | Baby Face | short little silly game, love it. i laghed so much when i saw what it randomly came out with. verry nice. Pity i can't tweet it right now. |
| Jan 5 00:22:00 | 32m 00s | John Power | Awsome game. Loved the music, thought the idea was amazingly simple, and the level design was good too. More please with polish and packaging. Well done :D |
| Jan 5 17:41:00 | 17h 19m | Where's my Present? | fun little puzzle game, nice idea for cristmas. |
| Jan 6 00:59:00 | 7h 18m | Serious Surgery | awsomely silly little platformer. loved in introduction of other hospital patrons who get in the way. well done. |
| Jan 6 01:05:00 | 6m 00s | One Pot | Interesting concept but you may need to do something along the way to keep people invested. Ether way an interesting idea for a social experiment. |
| Jan 6 01:11:00 | 6m 00s | One Bullet | interesting idea, i would say have a look at other stealth games and see what you can take out from them. Most stealth games function on frantic level designs with plenty of places to hide. I do like you get taken down in one shot though. |
| Jan 6 01:19:00 | 8m 00s | A Thing | nice idea but is verry difficult to play if you are playing alone. also its not got much of a goal or puzzle apart from place wall to get to eye, but that might not have been added yet. I your planning on taking this further you might want to add a maze or something for players to work through. Also i like that you can only play once before the game gets reset, but its verry restrictive. Works with the theme but like alot of the games i have played during this, the theme kinda holds it back. I do love the idea and multiplayer elements though. |
| Jan 6 01:25:00 | 6m 00s | O.S.B.L | nice game, you only get one life and you have to live it to the full is a good mesage. Maybe you can give the players some insentive to get some blocks and not others. if you had time maybe add a randomly generated story based on what you did when after you have finished. |
| Jan 6 01:30:00 | 5m 00s | Mad One | Fun little puzzler with some pretty impressive animated models. Story and music is nice too. |
| Jan 6 01:35:00 | 5m 00s | 1 Minute Capsule | really impressive little game. Loved the music and the idea. Its fun to play and looks pretty good too (although you may want to check the cyleing of the background star map). Ether way really nice little game. |
| Jan 6 01:47:00 | 12m 00s | Food Survival | fun game, nice graphics, good music and sound effects. Well done. |
| Jan 6 01:57:00 | 10m 00s | Save Octavius | simple, but fun and looks good. a little variation in enemys and bosses would have been great though. i thought the art assets really capture the idea of the game though. |
| Jan 6 02:05:00 | 8m 00s | CHOOSE W1SELY | fun idea and i love the gameboy like graphics. verry hard but thats fine, challange is fun. range of obsticals is great and music and sound effects are nice. Great marioesk game. |
| Jan 6 02:13:00 | 8m 00s | Race The One | simple but can keep you entertained for ONE min (sorry not a funy joke). Yea i like it, just wish there was some replayability like a scorboard or something. I know you only did this in an hour but some veriaty and compatition and you would have a solid enough game. good job :D |
| Jan 6 10:48:00 | 8h 35m | Jam Panic! | your right, making something is better than not making anything. I was in the position of lerning twine over the weekend and the tutorials there are, are actually quite good. The program is actually farely simple and a basic knowlage of programming will get you understanding it if your one of the people who comes from a programming background. Even a "basics about code class" will give you an idea about most of the features. Anyway i digress, a meta game about writing a game is an interesting idea, but each of the options are basically success or fail and are fairly clearly stamped. A one track road isn't a bad thing you just have to give the player some reason for being there other than this basic option. I think bringing up that your narrator says that woman can't make games is a good way of spurring a discussion about social lables, but you might want to follow it up with something so it dosen't feel like a personal accusation for the players just in case. Like a warning about it. I like the game in general, but you may need to focus the story a bit more and write metaphorically to give people a sence of what the narrator is feeling. anyway keep at writing twine games, i have enjoyed seeing them through this jam and you can get plenty of writing practice with twine. |
| Jan 6 10:54:00 | 6m 00s | Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs | fun little game about timing and management. I like the idea about the classic fairy story being used and the characetured dwarves. |
| Jan 6 11:00:00 | 6m 00s | Aggrogate | this idea looks fun, but confusing. I think you would need to practice a bit before you got the hang of it. I wish i could play it with a second player but right now im all alone :(. anyway i watched the video as well to get an idea of play. verry impressive game, can't wait to try it out properly when i have a friend around. |
| Jan 6 11:07:00 | 7m 00s | You Only Get One Boat | fun but the computer cheats XD. ok so ai is hard, i know, but otherwise the controll and movement of the boat feels right out of one of the old top down racers. Add a couple of corses and you would have one fun game here. verry loose theme but thats fine. |
| Jan 6 21:00:00 | 9h 53m | Double Cannon | fun game, i havent tryed with a friend but i bet it would be more fun. I think you may need a bigger arena or smaller targets as i could leave the turrets in the same position for the majoraty of the game. otherwise great little game. |
| Jan 6 21:13:00 | 13m 00s | Zombies... ON CHRISTMAS | Fun cristmas game. Music and lighting was verry effective, and the idea is fun. 21300 was my best score |
| Jan 6 21:21:00 | 8m 00s | Hope for an Audible Future | verry nice looking but really hard to play. the trails and ripples make cool effects but i can barely see what is going on its too hectic for me. otherwise its pretty good. |
| Jan 6 22:10:00 | 49m 00s | Call of Monsters | awsome game, funny concept and good method of making it into a game. Loved the sillyness, and the music was pretty good too. I had a ball... (sorry bad pun) XD |
| Jan 6 22:24:00 | 14m 00s | Only One Chance to Kill Souperman | intresting, but there isnt much play in it. music and the intro screen is nice though. |
| Jan 6 22:42:00 | 18m 00s | EVA : You only get one... | Awsome little text game. Makes me wish i had used ren'py instead of twine if i had known. fun little dialoge between two characters with a maze puzzle thrown in for good mesure. Bravo. |
| Jan 6 22:51:00 | 9m 00s | You have one NAND | i have had a play and i love logic gate puzzles, but i can't figure out the goal of the level. I might just be missing something. a bit more of a tutorial would be nice but otherwise it looks like it functions properly. Well done |