lasska 2025-10-06 21:16
very cute game!
Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD58 → Witchlist
By Qinchen Wang, aSHoPounYoung, provence-apple, ave2brave, Runyi Zhu and zmh070811
| Category | Rank | Score | Count | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 85 | 4.00 | 27 | |
| Fun | 110 | 3.85 | 26 | |
| Innovation | 220 | 3.56 | 27 | |
| Theme | 107 | 4.16 | 27 | |
| Graphics | 23 | 4.59 | 28 | |
| Audio | 96 | 3.96 | 27 | |
| Humor | 114 | 3.81 | 26 | |
| Mood | 72 | 4.20 | 27 |
very cute game!
Love the art and animations ! Two small notes if you're interested in feedback! 1) I got a bit stuck when I seemed to run out of inventory space, and when I created a new item, it vanished. 2) The footsteps sounds i found a little bit too harsh and repetitive, but totally understandable due to the time constraints! What you put together is really impressive. Overall, nice work!
thanks for the feedback!! we didn't have enough time for designing better player guidance so :[ for the inventory slots - you can just discard items by dragging them out. @lrdjj
edit: i posted a crafting recipe - check out the links.
Cute art work
Impressive style consistency under such tight schedule. It's fun trying out all the weird combinations as well. I think it'll be great to have some small hints, like an ingredient book when player gets stuck. There's also a bug that when you hit "stir" multiple times, the ingredients that comes after it will land in the pot not inside the circle above it. Overall amazing work😉its one of my favorite out of all LDJ58 participant games
Although there have been unhappy and quarrels in the process of making this game, I really felt happy as a planner when I saw the finished product. I also hope that everyone who plays this game can feel happy after being scared by * * ~ Thank you!
Great work! 玩了半天才发现道具栏在左侧被收起来了，我还寻思怎么砍树不掉落道具哈哈哈
This game is so cute! I especially love the walking animation and sound effects. Overall, the atmosphere is fantastic!
Pretty cute art style!
Beautiful entry. And very complete game. Had a great time playing it.
Very cute game! I really liked the concept of collecting things compulsively and then trying to do weird combinations with them. Also the art style and the small animations are very cute and they fit perfectly the theme with the also very nice music. I could not find how to make the iPad though, so maybe some hints would have been nice but I understand the time constraints, together with the footsteps sound which might be a bit repetitive after a bit. Overall, really nice work !!
Thanks everyone for playing our game and giving us ratings! Programmer here. It's been an absolutely wild ride during the last ~8 hours, at 10 PM CST, we found a game breaking bug with the inventory combination system that breaks pretty much any potential to reach above day 2. Night time was usually when I write bugs, not fix them, but luck was on our side for those few hours and somehow that game breaking issue was fixed. I see that there are still edge cases that I overlooked for the inventory combination module, unfortunately those were not caught before the ddl :( But for anyone who can still reach day 5 amidst those glitches, you are in for a (pleasant?) surprise!
Very cute visual style and animation! I think it's one of the most overall solid game that I've encountered so far for this jam. Really enjoyable gameplay and exploration. Amazing work!
The art and animations are adorable, paired with great music. The potion making is great, but I cant work out the ipad either haha. If someone works it out leave a spoiler and I will try the later days.
For anyone who struggle with ipad - Try making a stone tablet & combine tablet with apple.(sorry for lacking guidance again) @enad96 @angelpatanez
Thanks for playing our game! And thanks for all the nice comments and feedbacks! I'm one of the two artists in this team. I drew the objects in the environment, the animals, the map and did the level design with the other artist.
This is my first Game Jam. Although the process it's a bit stressful, the final result was wayyyyy beyond what I expected. I gained a ton of experience in this jam. I had great teammates who I could really count on. We all came up with the gameplay and mechanics together and everyone did an amazing job. It was a lot of hardwork but the result was absolutely worth it. 10/10 recommended would try this again
26307b49cd2bfd2efa2c6497c02138f4.jpg
Impressive work - I really enjoyed playing until the end! Did not expected from the cozy atmosphere in the beginning that things would take a twist after day 3 - but the sudden change of music really supported the story perfectly. I was a bit confused at first how to move on with the dialogue box - maybe a menu with a short "how to play" would have been helpful. Nonetheless, it was a great game - I'm a fan! :)
The game's graphics are cute, and the atmosphere is warm. However, there is room for improvement in playability. The most significant issue currently is the lack of hints for crafting recipes. I got stuck on the iPad the first time and on the Map the second time. Overall, it's a good game. Snipaste_2025-10-08_16-20-02.png
I loved the vibe of this game! :D Especially the cute art and the cute music. The gameplay also fit this feeling really well. It was very relaxing to try to think of ways to make certain items, and then to stroll through the forest to try to find fitting items. I really loved the 'clever' combinations, such as how to make an eggplant, since I could puzzle those out myself (and feel very clever in the process :P). Other combinations, such as a wooden plank or stone tablet or baseball bat, felt a bit arbitrary to me. For these some extra guidance would have helped not getting stuck, as others have also mentioned.
But I also fully understand you can only do so much in a weekend and you guys did a really great job! I really enjoyed this one :D
witchlist-min.png
Sadly, the game bugged at day 4 for me. I couldn't combine any more items to make the lantern, because the interface kind of disappeared.
Nevertheless, I enjoyed the game sooo much, thank you! I really want to know if I guessed correctly which animal murdered all the others :sweat_smile: So maybe I'll try once again just to ease my mind haha.
I also loved combining all the items to find the requested quest item. It was very helpful to see which items can be mixed together in the pot preview, so I didn't get stuck that long.
My favorite entry so far <3 Amazing job!
Bildschirmfoto 2025-10-08 um 17.29.17.png
Well, I had to know :smile:
I am the designer of this game, thank you very much for loving and playing this game, and I have also gained a lot of help and support from many people in the process. I am very grateful to this competition for giving me such valuable experience! Thank you very much! !
@mia-143 <3 im so impressed that u r the first one reach the end (w/o any hint) :cry: i guess ur the supreme witch outsmarting all of us. tysm for liking it!! hope u enjoyed :]
@justuspan thanks for the review - i got u. it's true that the game lacks proper player guidance and recipe hints. we can't fix it now but we've added a crafting recipe to the links now so feel free to check it out if needed):3
@wuppos tysm for the feedback - glad that u enjoyed :3 ! some items are there for the narrative, that we failed come up with more clever/funnier recipe such as the map;w; but there's a recipe book added to a link now, im sure i'll be helpful. btw i really had fun with mailbox mania XD gotta replay it later for higher score.
@nivbeth u dont know how surprised i am to see u complete the game and actually enjoyed it;w; tysm & congrats!! btw the requested items are also a big part of storytelling n im really wondering if u found that out XD.
Just so you know, everyone on the team contributed to the game design, the mechanics and the narrative. Not just one person.
Thank you all for playing the game! I am the audio designer of the game. I re-played the entire game from start to finish. Because I didn't participate much in the design of element synthesis,so it also retained my "player perspective" experience. I think this game play is very interesting, so I am very grateful that our artist and programmer came up with this game play. The whole plot and final performance effects also exceeded my expectations. I still remember the excitement of our team reaching the final plot late at night. In all, respect to my team. I hope everyone enjoys the game and its audio!
Cool mechanics and nice art style!.
beautiful game, exciting plot, short action, great humor, jesus, best game on LD 4me!
Very cool style! So far, this is the most interesting game I’ve played in this jam. It’s missing a pause menu and an exit button, and there are some interface issues on widescreen monitors — but that’s minor within the scope of a jam.Screenshot_1.jpg
very pretty game, It reminded me of those old combination games where you start from very basic elements and start making a ton of different ones I think the game would feel better if there was no "wrong" combination of the basic elements that you can gather, even if it requires you to put a few less in the game at first
Really cool concept. I love the little puns and coziness, but I got stuck while trying to make the iPad the elements started stacking in the pots instead of the bubble, so I wasn't able to preview the mix, and I ended up creating 3 shovels in one mix kinda weird.
3.png Alchemy is too hard. (Making meatballs instead) Just some random doodles
@thyoi Our first fan art! This is adorable ❤️
I love your cute storybook art style and the little animals! The game also feels really polished!
@thyoi hehehe dont starve more like dont stir
The Game is super cool, very chill! I really love the overall aspect That clearly one of my favorite submission so far !! Great entry !!
Loved the look of this game, very cozy! It was fun figuring out how to make everything, and the world was interesting to explore! Great job!