Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD49 → Feedback comment stats → ilbini
Feedback comments for LD49
ilbini's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | ilbini's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 4 23:21:02 | Glenn The Alienn | ♥ 2 | Good game overall. The graphics were really great! I had a good time playing it and i can see the experience you guys have doing games. Just a couple of things to include as feedback that i think could have improved my experience. * The controls felt weird, i would like to look up and down. Some obstacles were down and i could not see the path to it * The game is very difficult, i felt over in some obstacle and had to start everything again and i did it once, the second time i felt like it was too much effort, i think there was some other world but unfortunately could not reach them. I think this kind of punish is not as needed in a game jam where you want people to see everything you've done * I think the theme was not so strong in the game, would like to see more reference to it Keep working hard guys! | |
| Oct 6 03:30:36 | 28h 09m | Confession | ♥ 2 | I enjoyed the game, seems really professional for me, nice art, sound and atmosphere. I think the "darkwood" vibes were good, the lightning and paranoia effect, well made. I can see the effort you guys put on this game. Some points that could have improved my experience as a player: * More feedback on the things that were happening, it could be sounds or even an effect in the world (particles or something) for example for events like bullets when hit, enemy spawns, health lost, sometimes i were about to die and didn't notice. * Some difference in some enemy, i know is a jam and we have little to none time, but some change in color or something to felt enemies different, even bosses, i fought only one and i think it was the same that small enemies. I am not sure about the respawn enemies decision, maybe too difficult if you want players to complete the experience with no problems * Some different room or different sounds on rooms, game felt repetitive at some point * Maybe more explanation in game, i killed a boss and the game restart and i lost my items, that was confusing and i didn't get the journal i unlocked, maybe it was just me, but did not totally get the lore behind without reading the itch page Anyway, good job guys, keep working this great. |
| Oct 7 00:45:16 | 21h 14m | Unstable Environment | ♥ 1 | I couldn't save the world, and i tried a few times so i guess i am not the person :( The game is good, the intro is awesome and i enjoy these kind of games. I think it was challenging not knowing what my selections could lead too, i found myself guessing most of the times but i understand it was the idea. Some things maybe to improve my experience next time :D * Graphics could improve, not a blocker to play this game but it is always nice to play a nice looking game. Maybe using more images ingame i dunno i am a programmer myself so dont count me on this * I could not find how to restart the game, had to close and open, could be useful to have the retry button in this kind of games were you expect to fail a few times * Maybe the game could be simplified a little, i could not handle all the information sometimes. Maybe the same idea with less choices or less indicators was good also but to be honest maybe its something personal and the game is easy and simple for everyone. Even in the year result maybe use more colors to easily match for example, all sociaty related information is blue. The humor is great, the texts and voice acting are cool, good job on that. Keep it up! |
| Oct 7 01:15:05 | 29m 49s | A Stable Life | ♥ 1 | I enjoyed this game, made me read a lot in a clever way showing some suspense and engagement on the story step by step. If i knew all the text on that intro upfront, i am not sure if i was reading it hehe. The story is solid, the ambience and the mood in general. Nice entry. Maybe some things that could have worked better for me: * Movement felt clunchy, i got stuck in some places near the bed and the crouch could have some "smooth" movement just to be more immersive * Some more audio in the game, maybe when inspect, walk, find an important clue * Highlight interactables when i am close (maybe makes the game too easy not sure) but i think its to consider to deal with "lazy" players Overall nice game, really made me feel like a detective, the theme was subtle almost only in the title, but i can see there were good game design decisions in the lecture and ending of the game (not punishing the bad choices were a great decision for my perspective). Keep it up! |
| Oct 7 01:22:40 | 7m 35s | eXtreme Restaurant Simulator | ♥ 2 | Awesome! The game is great, the gameplay is fun and really well made. The idea of using phone movement, vibration, the stability of the waitress, really well choices and to me i can see you have experience in what you are doing. It takes a challange to do a mobile game in a weekend using this kind of mechanics but i think you nailed it. Congratulations! |
| Oct 7 02:30:23 | 1h 07m | Cairn | ♥ 1 | I really enjoyed the mood of the game, the graphics are great and i think it was a very original approach to the theme using the village and the cairn to gather rocks. To be honest i couldn't made a pile of rocks, the base was not plane and some problems with gravity and drags. But i could see the first part and the dialogs and it was really well made, the cairn part didn't work out for me because of this frustration and its a shame because if it was a little bit easier it could've been a really great entry. I understand the time limitation to work on this on a weekend, but maybe it was a matter of priorities, the cairn and rocks part for me it was where you want the player to have the best experience, because is the name of the game and the theme and i feel most of the "polish" was done in the first part which i enjoyed btw. Well, just a little feedback if its useful for you guys for future projects. Best of lucks, keep doing awesome games! |