Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD43 → Feedback comment stats → Hadik
Feedback comments for LD43
Hadik's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | Hadik's comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 9 18:05:44 | Soul Clicker | ♥ 2 | Pros: - Your entry nicely fit into theme - Interesting mechanics in the tower defense style - Grafics design of your game is not bad, I like it :) Cons: - Base building asset is more pixel art then other game assets. So it's looks wierd in my opinion - Game dificullity is not changing and is static. So after few minutes game is very repettive and not challanding. - In game is missing some kind of scoring, like count of killed souls of somethink like that Overall: Game idea and game overall is good, I like it. Graphics part of the game is also not bad. But after few minuts game is very repetitive and not challanging because lack of incresing diffuculity. Yes I summoned satan :) | |
| Dec 9 18:15:39 | 9m 55s | **FREEZING IS THE MAIN PROBLEM ** | ♥ 2 | Pros: - Nicely fit into theme (also christmas theme :) ) - I like that simple hand drawed graphics - Simple but fun and working game mechanics Cons: - Too fast tutorial message, I can't read that :D - Some optional navigation to delivery target or minimap will be good, becuase for the first time I wanering around only. After few plays I know where every house is (Okay my fault, I not read everythink, right mouse click :D ) Overall: I think you made very polished game. Everythink fits OK :) Graphics is nice to look :). Game mechanics is fun. So I think this LD you will recieve nice score. |
| Dec 9 18:24:02 | 8m 23s | Antlerman | ♥ 0 | Pros: - I love simple pixel art, and yours is :) - Background music is simple but works and again thats what I like :) Cons: - In the game is not clear what to do, expect shoot down bats. I dont know how exactly sacriface that blood and get upgrades - In the browser is wiered streched and my browser shows scrollbars for X and Y and it looks terrible. Overall: In my opinion if you invest more time in explanation of the game mechanics it will helps most of players of your game. Because without read I dont know what to do expect shoot down these bats. (Yes I did same mistake in my game but I make compo :D) But audiovisual of the game is good, and better the most of LD entry. |
| Dec 9 19:12:16 | 48m 14s | Deadline of the Dead | ♥ 2 | I saved company, see at the monday :D Pros: - That graphics... Really in 72 hours? Your graphics designer is god :) - It's not like another zombie shooter, at has juice and humor :) - Nicely fit into theme - Still fun, I finished it. - Humor situatuions: I need find another work, but I need go to the toiler, unfortunetly I am chaised by horde of zombies :D Cons: - I am not sure is game has any in 72 hour case :) Overall: Mostly I write it in pros. So I think we have here winner in the graphics section and maybe TOP 10 for fun category :) |
| Dec 9 19:21:17 | 9m 01s | The Cave God | ♥ 1 | Pros: - Simple but nice to look pixel art - God but humor, ok thats what I like in these games :) - Fits in to the theme Cons: - Some longer gameplay will be good Overall: Short but fun game :) I like that simple pixel art, its overall very well polished. |
| Dec 9 19:34:20 | 13m 03s | Astronaut's Journey | ♥ 1 | Pros: - For LD games has very long game time :) - Simple vector graphics but for this game style fit very well - I love space flights, so you hit me :) Cons: - In space, stability on last stage is very poor, and after 20 attemps with maxed rocket I gived up - Sounds missing Overall: Very simplified kerbal space program :) So your mini apollo program with saturn rocket is succeed :) |