Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD28 → Feedback comment stats → cwkx

cwkx

Feedback comments for LD28

Timestamp	Since previous	Game	cwkx's comment
Dec 16 11:44:00		Last Minute Christmas Chopping	I liked that you tried an interesting perspective and an ambitious genre, so gave 5's in innovation, humor and mood (Christmas!). The weakest parts were the audio and theme (3's) but overall it was good and fun (4's) :) While the time spent on the effects is very cute, I think additional gameplay mechanics should have been introduced instead to make it more fun, such as up-down for speed, upgrades, or better score/point rewards. It'd be nice to have some background ambient sound/music, even if just blowing/whistling in a mike to represent cold wind. Great for entering :)
Dec 16 11:49:00	5m 00s	Tankdare	Awesome! I love the random level generation and 1-hit kill mechanic, makes it very challenging. Lighting and turrets are superb :)
Dec 16 12:44:00	55m 00s	The Wizardry of Differentiation	Extremely good entry - I can't believe you managed to implement such complex mechanics in such little time. The spell combining is very cool in the later levels, great job!
Dec 16 12:51:00	7m 00s	Destroy The Core	This is very tough, but extremely good; well polished with fantastic audio/text, the tutorial is nice at the start but you should be able to skip it and go directly into the ship after dying. Amazing work! 5/5/5/4/5/5/5/5
Dec 16 13:09:00	18m 00s	P.O.W. Rescue	The graphics are great. Maybe spend more time on the platforming/logic/levels next time, but good entry! :)
Dec 16 17:55:00	4h 46m	Sweat Marathon	Great use of theme, great use of haxeflixel, especially like the main character animation :)
Dec 16 18:09:00	14m 00s	The Last Planet	Love the intro, audio, and the art is fantastic, especially when in motion. C++/SFML -> .exe makes it a little less portable, try to compile with emscripten? Maybe make enemy spawning a bit more predictable. 5/5/4/5/5/5/5/5 Great!
Dec 16 18:19:00	10m 00s	You Only Get One Chance to Impress your Girlfriend with a Game You Made	Really cute little entry, hope she liked it :)
Dec 16 18:39:00	20m 00s	What The Sock	Yes! Best use of theme ever :D 5/5/5/5/5/5/5/5
Dec 16 19:48:00	1h 09m	Medieval Combat	Really innovative real-time strategy genre, especially with the formation mechanics; lots of potential here. Great work!
Dec 16 19:51:00	3m 00s	No Drag in Space	I love 2D space games. This was fun with pretty visuals :) Great work!
Dec 17 08:19:00	12h 28m	Thrust Issues	Great work, at first I just held space but later after taking it slower it got easier. Fun to play :)
Dec 17 08:25:00	6m 00s	A Rose in the Rain	Very simple but effective, not sure why a wet rose made me feel sorry for the guy, but it worked.
Dec 17 08:33:00	8m 00s	Escape from Aleonia!	Really lovely graphics, audio and gameplay. Great entry! :)
Dec 17 08:42:00	9m 00s	Nature's Howl	Great work on the art and audio, and very innovative genre.
Dec 17 08:50:00	8m 00s	Blue Harpoon	I especially loved the spear: 1 shot, 1 death - awesome!! 5's for overall, innovation, fun, graphics, audio.
Dec 17 08:57:00	7m 00s	You Only Get One Shot	Really great for 3 hours, and that you learnt unity with it too - excellent job for persevering! :)
Dec 17 08:58:00	1m 00s	Ursa Miner	I couldn't resist the blocks when I saw this in the screenshots :D I love the simple art style, runs fine on my laptop. Excellent work!
Dec 17 09:12:00	14m 00s	Santa Claws	This is stunningly beautiful: graphics = extremely talented to do all this in such short time!! As its unity, try to release a webplayer version. Amazing job.
Dec 17 09:33:00	21m 00s	Virtual Sniper Trials	Yeah this is very fun, and the facing worlds nostalgia tops it :D
Dec 17 09:35:00	2m 00s	Pilot's Last Stand	Fantastic voice overs, and the gameplay was great too -Excellent work!
Dec 17 09:57:00	22m 00s	One Minute To War	Got up to level 23 before dying; I enjoyed trying to read the numbers through the text - I liked how if you shake the sheets the numbers stand out (intentional?) :)
Dec 17 10:16:00	19m 00s	Jump Chip	This is beautiful and fun, I especially like the grain and particles on the end platforms. The background theme was fantastic too, loved it!
Dec 17 17:32:00	7h 16m	A.D. 2101	Stunning pixel art. I'd prefer nearest-neighbor rather than bilinear for pixel art, very retro-audio that I liked. Maybe next time get a more solid platforming base, but I appreciate how hard this is. Great work!
Dec 17 17:49:00	17m 00s	Medieval Fantasy Island	I liked the audio and postprocessing, however the gameplay is not innovative. Next time I would encourage you to put your skill/time into something more simple and fun (and less ambitious), rather than emulating a MMO in 72 hours; just polish one basic gameplay mechanic first then layer complexity if you have time. However this was a good exercise to practice an ambitious genre :)
Dec 17 18:19:00	30m 00s	Leap of Faith	The two endings are so sad, I tried to press Left and Right :( Excellent game.
Dec 17 18:27:00	8m 00s	Club Man	Great work on the low poly graphics and animation :)
Dec 17 18:32:00	5m 00s	Humanity's Last Hope	You got the beginning of a great space shooter here, so a post-compo release with upgrades will be awesome; I would try and get more consistency in the graphics - don't mix pseudo 3D asteroid with 2D cutout art. The controls are great and responsive and the starfield is lovely. Great coding!
Dec 17 18:43:00	11m 00s	You Only Get One Limb	Exceptional use of theme and physics (especially ropes), with stunning art direction - full marks, fantastic!
Dec 17 19:28:00	45m 00s	clic only	This is very good; simple mechanic well polished into a great game - excellent!
Dec 20 10:29:00	63h 01m	Loop Desert	Really fun little puzzle, very innovative, full marks! :D
Dec 20 10:41:00	12m 00s	Berathen Jam	Impressive amount of work for such a short time :)
Jan 5 14:21:00	387h 40m	Doubt	Great use of haxe! :D
Jan 5 15:05:00	44m 00s	Uno Terra	Awesome work, loved the polish and music. Good balance of multiple complex mechanics.