Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD27 → Feedback comment stats → tompudding
Feedback comments for LD27
tompudding's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | tompudding's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 27 21:33:00 | Robots Save the Day | This is the first game I've rated, and I hope they're all this good! Great concept (I love games with programming!), really fits the theme well trying to get the instructions done in time. If anything I'd say the last few levels were too easy, but extremely impressive overall. | |
| Aug 27 22:03:00 | 30m 00s | Once upon a flight | Really cool idea, nice use of the theme to give us a 10 second glimpse at the obstacles. In practice the birds can be very hard to avoid sometimes, and I think that poor knight would be crushed after such a long fall! Great job |
| Aug 27 22:09:00 | 6m 00s | Goat Tower | I appreciate the digestive accuracy, though I wish the goat poop could be used to damage or dissuade the enemy! |
| Aug 28 08:14:00 | 10h 05m | Day of the Vampire | Great mechanic that fits the theme really well and really fun to play. The last part of the the last level took me a few tries so I was really pleased when I finally got it. I think music would have been especially nice since it could have been an additional indicator of the time of day |
| Aug 31 11:22:00 | 75h 08m | Subject 127 | Nice job. I disagree about the level design on the second level, after a couple of cameras I just legged it for the exit and just made it, so it worked for me at least :) <br/> <br/>The level design on the other levels could use some polish though I admit. In a game like this with potentially frustrating mechanics (those saws on the floor and the ceiling, AARRGH :) you really need all the other aspects to be very polished to avoid frustration. <br/> <br/>Very impressive overall, though get a sound person for next time ! |
| Aug 31 11:35:00 | 13m 00s | Navigator | Fantastic idea, it's not often you get to try something totally novel. On the first level I thought it was a neat idea that wouldn't be much fun, but it's very addictive! |
| Aug 31 11:46:00 | 11m 00s | Grind | Looks great, and I liked the music (though the sound effects were somewhat annoying). I wish the theme was 60 seconds though because it really felt like not enough time. I lost most of the 1 second between mana potions waiting to press return again to take another (I am old and have bad reflexes) |
| Sep 1 10:04:00 | 22h 18m | Corn PoP | Music is awesome, great job! Quite addicitive too, though the timer is kind of hard to see when you're busy clicking |
| Sep 8 19:04:00 | 177h 00m | Crazy Genetist | Nice idea and quite fun, but I think it actually would have been better without the time limit |
| Sep 8 19:07:00 | 3m 00s | Breakdown Countdown | It was very confusing, but I launched a rocket, hooray! |
| Sep 13 19:27:00 | 120h 20m | SF-1 | Really nice idea, having to count the 10 seconds is quite innovative. It was a bit too hard though I think, but it looks good. Nice job |
| Sep 15 13:43:00 | 42h 16m | Timed Ninjas | Superb idea, great execution. Well done! |
| Sep 15 16:42:00 | 2h 59m | YOU MUST GET THE ATOMS | I loved the music, but I echo other comments about not adequately forcing the player to learn the rules in the early levels. Great job! |
| Sep 15 16:51:00 | 9m 00s | Raging Clue | Exceptionally well polished, though I feel unfairly discriminated against due to my terrible ignorance. Great fun though, and an awesome voice over. Great job. |
| Sep 15 17:10:00 | 19m 00s | Proletarian Ninja X | Looks gorgeous, extremely polished, funny concept and great control system. The gameplay itself is quite frustrating though, too hardcore for me. Amazing work overall though. |