Foon → Ludum Dare Explorer → LD24 → Feedback comment stats → panda
Feedback comments for LD24
panda's games and stats for all events →
| Timestamp | Since previous | Game | panda's comment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 27 02:02:00 | EvoBit | Wow, this is very fun! I love how the graphics evolve, and the little effects: the loading bar, the score numbers fading, the flash when things evolve! I kind of wish the edge pushed us instead of killing us, though. | |
| Aug 27 02:16:00 | 14m 00s | Evo Dash | Very fun game! I love the random evolving rules! It made me play again and again to see how far I could go. Good graphics too! And good job on the game being complete, with a welcome screen, game, conclusion screen, and even random tips! The only thing I'd change is to make it easier to see how charged my shield is. |
| Aug 27 22:30:00 | 20h 14m | Natural Selection - You vs the World | Very fun, and super original! This is a really interesting game! |
| Aug 27 22:41:00 | 11m 00s | Invaders: Evolution | It's weird, running it on IE10 I get letters instead of the invader graphics (?) |
| Aug 28 03:14:00 | 4h 33m | The Wrong Kind of Evolution | I heard no sound, but the game's pretty fun! It worked flawlessly (thanks for the "smooth scrolling" toggle, I needed it! Though it was a bit hard to find). Are the waves different from each other? I couldn't tell. The graphics are fine though a bit blocky, and the connection to the theme is a bit tenuous. The game works and it has a menu and all. Congrats! You made a game in 48h. I made it to wave 3, but it'd be easier if we could shoot in a direction other than where we're walking. |
| Aug 28 03:21:00 | 7m 00s | Modula | Very cool! I love the idea of the enemies being based on what gave you a hard time. The game's pretty hard, though, I don't think I even finished one level. I find myself pretty quickly with no wings or anything left, just a helpless ball! I like the shooting sound effect, and the graphics work well! The game feels well-rounded, though it could be easier and perhaps with some more visible way to see how the enemies evolve. |
| Aug 28 17:08:00 | 13h 47m | Bomb the Bunnies | Congrats for finishing a game even though you only had very little time! I know what it's like! Your idea is fun and sets a great mood for the game! |
| Aug 29 03:12:00 | 10h 04m | Bots Vs Fleshbags | I like how you have not just the core game, but also a map to move around! The stick figure outline could look a bit more robot-like, and more interactions and sounds would be nice. All in due time! Congrats for finishing a game! |
| Aug 29 05:00:00 | 1h 48m | Cosmogonie | Really cool graphics and sound! It's neat to see a little forest growing, and I like how we can select the colors! The color effects are very neat, too. |
| Aug 29 05:08:00 | 8m 00s | EvoTD | Very fun game! It's great to have a complete game (with sound even!) and I really like how the towers evolve! By looking at how quickly they are evolving I can see if I put them in good or bad spots. The game feels complete, with a menu and even several modes. Congratulations! |
| Aug 30 02:06:00 | 20h 58m | The Chamber | Is the "web" version supposed to work? I get a ".zip" to download instead of a web page. |
| Aug 30 02:16:00 | 10m 00s | Kittens vs Evolution | Haha, awesome! Very fun, and it's a complete game, with scrolling and even a final boss! I guess it has a message... that you didn't like the theme! Still, "fighting evolution" has evolution in it, right? |
| Sep 4 03:42:00 | 121h 26m | Life | I like the music! And it's cool that you got an intro and cutscenes despite the limited time. If I could change something in the parts of the game that are there, perhaps I would make the first level either shorter (it's fine to be short, we know there's little time to make the game), or with more variety. |
| Sep 4 03:49:00 | 7m 00s | Those Stupid Aliens | Congrats on finishing! I love the idea of the aliens evolving, very good use of the theme! And our ship's graphic is very cool! Am I guessing correctly that that the aliens' look represents their genes? The connection was difficult to make out. Another tip that would help is to be very clear to the player about what's going on: in the screen between the waves, you could say "aliens evolving..." - I think it would add to the game. |
| Sep 4 03:59:00 | 10m 00s | RobotCity | I like the idea, but could not start the game - it froze the browser on my mac. |
| Sep 4 04:13:00 | 14m 00s | Dawn of Dimension | Awesome idea! I love the idea of a persistent, group-created world. Kudos! It seems you got a complete implementation, though I wish I could use arrow keys instead of a/d. I never found the powerups either, too bad. Perhaps it might help if when we scroll, we see just the edge of the neighbor cells? This could make it easier to have consistent places. |
| Sep 4 04:23:00 | 10m 00s | The Phoenix Rising | Awesome game! Congrats, you made a complete game on the theme, and the graphics are great! The controls sometimes have the magical feel of being just what I meant, and sometimes they're a bit confusing (esp the second level with the running), but since when we die we return to the last level, that's ok. I really enjoyed it! Thank you and congratulations! I like the storytelling tyle of "do, don't tell", though I must admit that I have no idea what happened at the first level. |
| Sep 4 04:34:00 | 11m 00s | The World of What? | Beautiful game, and right on theme! Congrats for finishing it! The intro screen was a bit scary (so many controls and stuff going on, without any initial context to make sense of it). If you had more time, perhaps making things more progressive could make the game easy to learn? Also, I ended up clicking pretty aimlessly - some of the tools didn't seem to work, and I had no idea what it meant to have "3 leaves" for example. The game kind of looked like it was meant to present a challenge (were the seasons a threat to my animals?), but I never got the sense that there was much danger, or much of a link between my clicks and what was happening. Some animals appeared sad. Is that a bad thing? Anyways, if the player's goal is to reach achievements, it may be good to show a place where the achievements will go, so we get this feeling that there's something we want to get! Overall, beautiful art and cool idea, but I got lost playing it. |
| Sep 7 17:01:00 | 84h 27m | Dorobou Neko! | Congrats on finishing a whole game! You have an intro screen, the mechanics, and everything! The chicky even falls offs the edge if you don't lead it carefully! The game's fun, though I would have liked a way to skip the early easy levels. And the iso view is awesome! It looks really good! If I had to change anything, I would perhaps not make it pause when it doesn't have focus (perhaps I know the duck will be safe the first few steps and I want to quickly check reddit?). Perhaps add some more animations at the end (perhaps a victory dance, a "sinking" animation, a "eaten by cat" animation?) - I know those are work and I totally understand them not being there now. I'm just saying this so that my comment gives you some advice, and not just a mindless rave :) |
| Sep 7 17:38:00 | 37m 00s | Fit to Fight | On the mac this gives me a download... it's not really a web game after all. |
| Sep 7 17:44:00 | 6m 00s | What if Pandas could Fly? | I wish I could fly! I love the intro! Congrats on making a full game! It's a very funny story, and the game's pretty fun! I only wish I had more pandas in the game. I ran out before getting to the cannon! |
| Sep 11 22:46:00 | 101h 02m | Axolotl Pop | Very fun game, and very complete! Congratulations! The weapons are fun, and the graphics and sounds well done. All that in a weekend? Wow! I don't see the connection to evolution, though. |
| Sep 11 23:05:00 | 19m 00s | dronepool | Wow, just wow. That's an awesome concept! I'd love to see this brought to completion. As it is, my program fights itself... the good news is that I always win! :) |
| Sep 11 23:07:00 | 2m 00s | Kitten Farts | I couldn't play it because it's Windows-only, but I wanted to say: awesome title! |
| Sep 12 05:38:00 | 6h 31m | E-VOLV | Awesome game! Perfectly on-theme, and fun to play to boot! It's so cool to have 31 turrets around your little ship! Congratulations! Perhaps next time, make the boss a little easier :) |